Proof Syrup Reviews

Marianne R.

I don't like to think of myself as a lazy person - but this delicious syrup may just make me into a lazy cocktail mixer! This makes everything so simple. I added a couple of Griottine cherries and the perfect amount of this syrup to some good bourbon and it was divine. Thank you so much for this wonderful product!!

Charles C.

Proof has earned a spot, front and center on my bar! I have been mixing my own syrup and ingredients for Old Fashioneds for years, but those days are over. I am about to try the Maple and Bacon.

Jenn L.

I have t say this company provided by far the best customer service of any company I’ve done business with in a long time. I needed a little help getting my order quickly and the personal responses were amazing. The product is amazing as well. Better than you would expect from a mix. My husband said it makes the best old fashioned he has ever had, and he’s had more than a few. I’d give these guys 10 stars out of 5.

Michael C.

We love Proof Syrup both Traditional & Pecan flavors and so does our friends.This was our second purchase Of multiple bottles and we’re ready for the third purchase. Makes great gifts too!

Sean L.

The syrup is delicious. However, I doubt I will reorder because the company is relentless with emails after you buy. I can see the frequency being important for therapy patients, but this is a drink mixer. I know it's the current fad for e-commerce companies to send daily emails to keep people engaged, however, most companies (like this one) have forgotten that they are not the only company people buy from. The public at large is tiring of constant emails from places they have purchased from...

James M.

Had good friends (who love Manhattans) over for dinner. These guys are tough to please and know their Manhattans. They loved it and all took photos of the bottle to order. Great stuff. Good for you!

James K.

Reluctant to spend the money at first, glad I did. I now make an Old Fashioned reminiscent of one served in a fine hotel. Now that I think about it, there is a little nostalgia attached to using this.

Jeffrey A.

This stuff is wonderful! I love the maple bacon one the best, but they’re all very nice. Great compliment to my Woodford Reserve. My only suggestion would be to make the bottle pour a bit better. I get sad when I have to wipe up the counter! :(

Linda S.

Old fashioned’s are expensive to get at a bar and you never know what you’re going to get. This makes it so easy and it tastes like the best bartender made it!

Tracy C.

Purchased for my husband who has a sudden affection for an old fashioned. He really enjoys it, heck we’re more the half way thru our first bottle. Will definitely be buying more.

Tamara O.

Absolutely awesome! The made the best Old Fashion at home that we have ever had! And it was soooo easy! ❤️ Bought the Maple Bacon but haven’t opened it yet! THAT will be a Thanksgiving Day cocktail!

Joe T.

Great product! I love old fashions but hate the extra work in making them at home. Proof is the perfect mix and tastes great! Definitely recommend it and will be buying more + trying the other flavors

Anthony G.

We are regulars ordering and re-ordering the ‘traditional’ flavor. It compliments a variety of bourbons and whiskies. I have not found another product that is any thing like the quality of the Proof products. TG

Susan L.

This Proof will change your life! The perfect Old Fashioned always meant bashing the sugar cube and bitters and adding a touch of maraschino cherry to the mix— but Proof does all that. 2oz of bourbon and 1/2 oz of Proof over ice — garnish with orange slice and a cherry.. snd voila— Nirvana.

Phillip L.

I have been drinking Old Fashions long before Hipsters, Snowflakes and millennials made it cool again. Its one of those drinks that every man should know, however not an easy task to make and always struggled to find a Bartender who could do it justice. But then low and behold Proof comes along and dam this is right up there, now I can make a quick Old Fashion with my cigar in no time. Thanks Proof good product, look forward to trying others.

Marcia R.

Excellent! Not too sweet! Takes all The guess work out of the amounts of betters and simple syrup. Easy as one, two, three, ice, bourbon, proof! Maybe it should be call Poof! Like magic!

Scott K.

Being from Wisconsin I was sceptical about this product. Old fashions are taken very seriously in Wisconsin. I'm happy to report this product is awesome. Makes a truly great Old Fashion. I still muddle my orange and add my cherry but no need for a sugar cube or soda topper. This is definitely the way to go. Can't wait to buy more.

Paul J.

It really does the make the perfect Old Fashioned. My holiday shopping has been made extremely easy. My next move will be to barrel age a batch. My gut is telling me they will be legendary!!! I may be Proof's biggest fan!

Connie H.

Wow! What an easy and delicious Old Fashion. The flavor is excellent. I bought some for my son and son-in-law for Christmas and I think they’ll love it, too.

Kasandra G.

I purchased this to surprise my husband. Old fashioned’s are his drink and he is particular about them! He loved it! He said it tastes authentic and loves how easy his evening cocktails are now. Can’t wait to try other flavors!

Scott H.

Absolutely amazing flavor. Mixed it with Bulleit and it was one of the best Old Fashioned's I've ever had. I followed the recipe but had to add a little club soda because it was a little too thick and sweet. I think this is now my go-to for my evening cocktail!

Raymond R.

It was EXACTLY as advertised...and I have not had a better Old Fashioned served to me anywhere. I love being able to experiment with different bourbons at will. I will definitely be a repeat customer of the Original, but I now want to try some of the others as well.

Sandy B.

Sent this as a special gift to my sister and her husband who love old fashions! It was a huge hit! With social distancing concerns and lockdowns, they rarely have an opportunity to share drinks over dinner in their favorite restaurants. When I saw Proof! advertised it was a definite order! They were delighted and plan to order more themselves...

Ann W.

I ordered a bottle a few months ago and my husband fell in love with it! Makes the best Old Fashions!! Ordered a bottle for my son in law and another for my husband!! It is “good stuff”!

Sam W.

I was on a side by side trip in the mountains of West Virginia, when a friend pulled a bottle out at the end of the day. Asked me if I had ever tried it before. Well, three drinks later, I was ordering my own bottle from the cabin to be at my house when I got home. It's a must try for a quick drink in the mountains or at home. I am looking forward to trying more flavors that are offered.

Joseph J.

This is by far the best old fashioned mix I have ever got or made etc. I was just saying how I wish I could make a great old fashioned. Then I saw the add for proof. It is simple to make a drink & awesome tasting. Thanks

Joseph B.

I have always been a an “Old School” type of man. Making drinks from scratch was the only way IMO, until now! Pour was and is the best and quickest way to make an Old Fashion. This past weekend a few of my friends and I went to a farm for fresh air and to do some drinking without fear of COVID with a full bottle of POUR. Let’s just say that I came home with enough of it to make just one more OF!! Outstanding flavor!!!

Randolph B.

Tasty and Thrifty -- it is sooooo easy! I wondered if a pre-made syrup would truly give me a delicious Old Fashioned. Well, I can tell you it surely does. Flavorful and well-balanced. No taste of anything artificial or out-of-place. Just right! Now a new favorite in our household ... not only for the taste but because it makes everything so easy. Nothing else is needed, no muddling, no whatever. Very pleased.

Scott S.

Was hesitant to try Proof, after all home made has to be better., right. Well, it took one long night with 8 good friends to empty the bottle and order a replacement. Looking forward to trying the bacon and maple as well. Great product.

Travis J.

I love this Old Fashion mix. It tastes amazing, and makes a drink in no time at all. This syrup has changed my quality of drinks at home! Love it!!!

Brad W.

Awesome cocktail mix. I was looking for an easy to make cocktail solution that was pour and go....and this is perfectly it. Tastes great, perfect sweetness to the spirit ratio. Can't wait to try the other flavors!

Kimberly A.

Purchased the original and maple bacon syrups for a friend who loves old fashions. She loved them so much that she ordered 3 more bottles! She is looking forward to trying the pecan and pumpkin spice.

Paul Y.

My wife makes me an Old Fashion almost every evening and is better than the restaurants! A cherry and orange slice make it perfect! Especially with the Covid and not being able to being OUT as much as we want, I love the Proof old fashioned spirits along with my bourbon to make a Perfect Old Fashion! Appreciate your product, the ease of ordering it and efficient delivery! Thank you, Paul Young

Mick Z.

Bottles broke upon delivery. Wasn't Proof's fault but I told them the packaging was suspect and that they should be aware of that issue. They sent me new bottles anyway. The product is absolutely delicious and makes life simple for the Old Fashioned maker like me. Hoping for a manhatten Proof product in the future.

Tim W.

Went to a friend's house for some cocktails and one of the attendees brought a bottle of Proof syrup and w made Old Fashioneds using bourbon for some and rye for others. Proof worked well in both styles. Liked it so much had to get some for myself.

Kelly P.

I got the traditional, maple bacon & pecan. Love them all and the service was top notch. I unfortunately had one of the bottles arrive broken from shipping, proof syrup sent a replacement with minimal questions asked and they were super friendly through the process. I will be ordering more as soon as these are gone, or earlier as its a great gift idea!

Gail S.

My son in law introduced us to Proof and we really enjoyed the taste and ease of fixing a drink. I then introduced it to my friend who ordered from you. Tasting and word of mouth is the best testament to of this great product.

Lisa M.

I'm sorry I didn't take a photo...it was a beautiful thing! We enjoyed Brandy Old Fashioned Cocktails on the patio with friends. Everyone loved the drinks. Easy, delicious ....will be ordering again and again!

Donald M.

The recipe for an old fashioned is right on. I find it too sweet so I’ve cut the volume of syrup in half and still enjoy a nice old fashioned. My wife likes the recipe quite weLl. I have to say we’ve travelled to many places and it’s a drink we try at everyone of them. This mix gives you the top 80% of them all. Good!

Vaughn S.

I have tried other premixed old fashion syrups and have went the homemade route with simple syrup and bitters and I would say Proof is the best. Easy to use, with only a small amount required to make the bottle last a long time. I would purchase again.

Proof Syrup ReviewsMore details