Proof Syrup Reviews

Richard B.

It is great. Just add Whiskey and you are done. Cleaner and faster than doing everything else the "old fashioned" way. Though there is a time and place for that, but other times you just want to streamline things.

Don H.

Proof was on my Facebook, Old fashion is my wife's favorite but she hates to make them. I ordered a bottle and she fell in love. I ordered 3 more bottles for gifts. I will be telling everybody about Proof.

Michael G.

I’ve been locked in my house for 5 months. Proof syrup has literally gotten me through the pandemic. I cannot stress enough how vital this stuff is to proper whiskey and rye celebration. It’s awesome!!! BUY IT!!! TONS OF IT!!!

Carey M.

LOVE this! Got the original flavor and it literally is the best - better than some restaurants I've gotten drinks from. I've already recommended it to several friends. Awesome customer service too - bottle unfortunately was broken upon arrival and they sent a replacement out super fast. Will always have it stocked at my house now

Harris L.

Absolutely amazing product! So easy, so perfectly mixed, so applicable to the fast paced environment to ease an individuals attempt to slow it down. My colleagues have growth to appreciate the product as well; referred internally as Angel Tears sweeten our fire water. Looking forward to the end of the day, as now a perfectly apportioned Old Fashion awaits the burdened soul.

Kimberly W.

Absolutely LOVE every flavor we buy. I have given as gifts too and my friends are all hooked. I had issues at first w delayed delivery and they did an AMAZING job with customer service and making up for it. I will ABSOLUTELY continue to order!!

Brandi B.

Hands down the easiest and best tasting Old Fashioned I've ever been able to make at home! Proof Syrup is amazing! Beem trying to make a good Old Fashioned at home for years with no success. This syrup made it possible!! Will definitely be buying more in the future!

Janis C.

My Hubby is the Bourbon lover. I ordered the Traditional to maybe make it a little easier to make an Ol'Fashion. It was delish. He just thought a but too sweet with recommended amount. So a little less next time. We hope to try other syrups too.

Brian H.

I have been using Proof Old Fashioned Mix Syrup. It is awesome. I throw in a cherry and add an orange garnish and my guests and I just suck 'em down!

Charles F.

Great stuff makes it easier to make my Old Fashioned I use a lil less than what it calls for so to make it a little less sweet so even better cause it’ll last longer!

Joanie S.

I bought this for my son for Christmas because he loves to drink old fashions and he said how much he loves it! It makes it much much easier to just add bourbon to this mix..he’ll definitely be purchasing more of it!

Arryn H.

I gifted two of these, one to my husband and one to my brother in law. My husband is a cocktail snob and said it’s the best old fashioned he's ever had.

Amy D.

I gave this to my dad for Christmas- he said it's great! Only problem is my mom now like Old Fashions with Proof Syrup so his bourbon supply is running out quicker.

Terry N.

Proof Traditional Syrup was the best tasting Old Fashioned mix we have ever tried. It was also very simple to make a tasty cocktail with this product. Will be reordering.

Gerardo P.

I bought it for my son and he loves it. The only disappointment was that I spoke to a guy there and he said to let him know when I ordered and he would put a recipe book in my box. I emailed him back when I ordered but he did not enclose the recipe book. Big Disappointment!!!!

undefined review of Traditional Proof Syrup image 1 out of 1

Sheri B.

Almost too simple of a syrup. This is a very traditional old fashioned, I drink them neat all the time which you cannot fool me with. Along with that, I have found with Proof that it upgrades the bourbon so I like to use even better bourbons for my Old Fashion now rather than the swill I used to because of the enhanced flavor.

Kathleen F.

I ordered it for my daughter who loves Old Fashions but it arrived too late. So I made a cocktail for myself with Jameson & an orange squeeze. I enjoyed it and will definitely have it again. I will order another & send directly to her!

Todd L.

Love this idea of a pre-mix for standard drinks.....my bottle did arrive partially open and leaked some although the plastic seal was still on the lid. Otherwise I love this!!!

Cindy S.

I absolutely loved this product and will get more before my bottle runs out! It made the best old fashioned and was so much easier than the "old fashioned" way of making them. Cheers!

Mccall M.

I purchased this as a gift for my husband (Okay... and for myself) and it was SUCH a hit! It makes the most delicious Old Fashioneds and now they are quick and easy to make (not to mention fool proof). We just add a curl of Orange rind and both feel like we're having a fancy cocktail at a restaurant.

Michelle S.

Definitely makes a great old fashion. We love a hand crafted cocktail but sometimes it's just too much work and this syrup gives you that taste without all the extra work.

Lillian B.

I was a little skeptical but am so glad I went for it! It was so good and exactly what I wanted out of this product! If you’ve been thinking about it, just go ahead and add to cart. You won’t be disappointed!

Christina B.

We absolutely love the proof syrup for Old Fashion....we have tried several timea to make it with all the ingredients but it always slightly missed the mark.....not after buy the syrup...it is the best Old Fashion every single time!! Love it and need to buy more immediately.

Steve R.

I've only a couple old fashioned in the past, but I have to say that the syrup is fantastic. I tried it with both Canadian Club and Glenmorangie Scotch. Delicious with both.

Kyle B.

Ordered traditional old fashion flavor and loved it. I was with a group of guys on a hunting trip and we finished it quickly. Ordered two more bottles, one with a black walnut flavor that I just waiting to be delivered.

Debra D.

I love this syrup. Mix a bit with a good bourbon and it's a perfect end to the day -- every day. Yes, a bit of a wait while it's freshly, batch made, but very well worth it! I will definitely buy this again!

Thomas S.

second order. first great second 1 bottle damaged but immediately was replaced and just received replacement in less than a week during Thanksgiving none the less cant wait for more flavors

Alan D.

It was an excellent mix. Shared with friends and family and all loved it. The Only problem is I ordered 3. 2 traditional and on pumpkin spice only received 1 Traditional. Need someone to contact me. Asap, need Christmas presents

Mark R.

I make what I call the “Bullet Proof” old fashion. I use Bullet Bourbon with Traditional Proof and an orange peel for garnish! I can never get an old fashion made the way I want (the right way! Haha). And to make them from scratch isn’t always ideal. Now every one I make, I use Proof. Recommend for anyone who loves real old fashions!!

Bruce E.

I must admit, I was skeptical that my Old Fashions would taste the same with the Proof syrup. I was proved wrong in a big way. The flavors in Proof are spectacular and the ease of mixing my drink was so simple. Thanks for a great product!

Richard A.

I haven’t drank Old Fashioneds since my brother-in-law used to make them. This mix duplicates his to a “t”, without the fussy business involved in making them from scratch.

Michael E.

The Old Fashion mix was excellent with both whiskey and with brandy. I drink lot's of Old Fashions when we travel to Wisconsin (it's the state official cocktail) and this mix of bitters and flavor is as good as I have had in WI.

William K.

You really know how to enhance an old fashioned! The proof mixtures make delicious old fashions. Easily the best mix on the market! Keep up the production! Customer for life. Will K.

Robert G.

The day it arrived I could not wait to make an Old Fashion. It did not disappoint. It is definitely the finest product I have ever used to make an Old Fashion and better than any of the homemade versions I have done. Recommend highly !!

Michael P.

Tastes like a $15 dollar old fashioned! Love the idea of making a cocktail in my house and sitting on my patio and enjoying the same deliciousness I’d get at my favorite bar! You won’t be disappointed!

James M.

I love this stuff! My favorite is mixed with vodka, tonic water and lime. Is also great as an Old Fashioned, but I don’t use as much as you recommend.

Charles K.

My wife loved it. She's been looking for a way to make a good Old Fashioned for a while. She says its a keeper. Will reorder when this firs bottle is gone.

Chris R.

I've been making my own Old Fashioned cocktails for years, well before the hipster renaissance. Sometimes I hit a delicious home run, sometimes its a bitter swing and a miss. Technique is everything when it comes to making the perfect Old Fashioned and admittedly, I'm inconsistent. So far, every PROOF Old Fashioned has been on point. Convenient and superb taste. Giving some bottles out for Christmas. Great product!

Ray H.

Kudos! With this syrup, I am now making the best Old Fashioned cocktails that I have ever made. Broke out the bottle of traditioanl Proof this weekend with some guests and it was a huge hit! Thank you!

Ronald C.

I love it. Now i can sit at home and have Old Fashions as I like and do not have to worry about the Police and a DUI arrest. Plus the Old Fashion made with Proofs and my favorite whiskey is far better then my favorite lounge can make one.

Proof Syrup ReviewsMore details