Proof Syrup Reviews

undefined review of Traditional Proof Syrup image 1 out of 1

Marty D.

Was exactly what I was hoping for! Had a “Southern Comfort” old fashion when I was in my 20s at a famous Italian restaurant off Longboat Key in Sarasota, FL. Have often asked for one through the years but never had the exact taste till I used your Proof Syrup! Only problem is my cap broke the first time I screwed it back on.......

Emily C.

The traditional syrup makes a great old fashioned. It’s tastes good. I had placed an order that should’ve arrived prior to Christmas as was stated but didn’t receive it until weeks later!

Jil Z.

Never made an Old Fashioned before. This made it super easy and quite tasty! Better than ones I have had at my favorite bars.

Kim H.

First flavor of Proof that I have tried but will definitely be buying more varieties. Quick and easy way to make a satisfying drink.

Sarah D.

Delicious old fashioned at home! Tastes as good as my favorite bars. So happy to be making these at home now!

Marilyn C.

Really love Proof Syrup to make the perfect Old Fashion. Usually add an orange rind and cherry to ours, they are delicious.

Janet M.

This is the REAL DEAL! I Love a good Old Fashioned. This is as simple as choosing your favorite bourbon, pour and stir! Cheers everyone!

Maureen M.

Love this product so much it is a staple at all of my gatherings (bar settings). I’m now gifting it out as people fall in love with it!

Nick B.

Love it. Tastes excellent and makes it so easy to make one of our favorite drinks. Will definitely continue buying it.

Mike J.

I've used both the traditional and the pecan I like the traditional better and I'm always ready to share it with friends.

Johnnie B.

I purchased as a Christmas Gift for my Son. The Old Fashioned Master Set & Three Extra Bottles of the Traditional Syrup. He Loved 🥰 the Gifts 🎁

Dana M.

We have thoroughly enjoyed Proof. It makes the best Old Fashion. Makes it super easy and convenient. This is our third bottle.🥃😋

Glenn T.

This product is very very good I plan to use this product as long as I’m Leavin I love it. Thank You For this creation well done.

Amie S.

Simply amazing... key word being simple- so easy to make a craft cocktail... you don’t miss the crushed cherries or orange peel. This mixer has it ALL!!!

Theresa W.

After a holiday shipping hiccup, finally using my Proof!🥃 Old Fashion kind of weekend. Sooo easy & tasty with Proof!

Jessica M.

So good!!! We love Old Fashions at restaurants and now we make them at home. Highly recommend. Now we have friends ordering Proof too.

Mary M.

This is the most lovely tasting concoction ever. Makes the best old fashioned and it’s easy. I have the original and bought two others and look forward to them.

June L.

We absolutely loved Proof Syrup! I had never made an Old Fashioned at home before. We tried it and were delighted! Will definitely be getting more of this!

Tiffini P.

The Taste was amazing. We tried it in Knob Creek and Four Roses. The Best Old Fashion we have ever tasted! Five Stars 🌟

Bryan F.

I really ‘focused’ on enjoying an Old Fashioned tonight. Nothing better than ending a workday with this relaxing beverage. So easy and so perfect!

Gerren W.

Best OF ever. I’m a snob with them too. I normally send them back at bars, when they are terrible. Easy to make, no additives needed.

Nina E.

Loved it! Got it for my dad as a Christmas present and he uses it every week! Will be buying more.

Amy D.

I never knew I liked Bourbon so much, but I sure do! Thanks to Proof for making me see the light. 😎

Leo B.

Shipping took forever but the product is Fantastic. I love a good Old Fashion and Proof makes a good one.

Max N.

Makes an excellent cocktail. Just mix it with a large ice cube and a Luxardo Cherry and it tastes just like you’re at a fancy restaurant.

Phillip S.

I love my Proof old fashions. I have turned many friends on to them. I prefer them with even less than suggested full strength.

Nick S.

Really enjoyed the traditional cocktail mix! Shipping was backed up due to all the orders around the holidays. I will definitely order again. Can’t wait for the next bottle!

Jennifer T.

The PERFECT way to end my day. And without the work and worry about whether or not I have all of the ingredients? Score!

Brenda B.

Absolutely LOVE it!!! Makes the very best old fashioned drink I’ve EVER had!!! Definitely going to buy more! We are hooked.

Steve P.

I love this product. I make an Old Fashion with this on the rocks a slice of orange a dash of orange bitters and it is soooo smooth. I will always have a bottle or two around! Thanks

John K.

Love Proof for my Old Fashions...I was always scared to make them despite being relatively easy. When I use Proof, it tastes like an Old Fashion from a high-end steakhouse. Love it and will order again!

Matt T.

I'm the guy who muddles the orange with the bitters and just the right amount of sugar to make the perfect Old Fashion. I was hesitant about how this would compare. I was more than pleasantly surprise. This taste great, but the biggest plus is that you're ready to drink your favorite cocktail immediately. No mess, no clean up. Just pour and drink. I've tried it with Tin Cup, Bulleit and Four Roses. All taste great. My father-in-law saw me making a drink one night and had me pour him one. He love...

Justin S.

I have been trying to figure out how a favorite restaurant of mine makes such a good Old Fashioned. I cannot confirm it, but I believe your simple syrup is the key! It makes all the difference and I will not make another Old Fashioned without it! Thank you!

Joe T.

Really like this stuff. It makes quick work of what was a longer process before. I still cut the orange peel and add the cherry, but the rest of it is is much more streamlined. Shipping was amazingly fast, by the way! I will order again!

Brian B.

Proof is easy and delicious. Less Old Fashioned making, more Old Fashioned drinking! It’s a little on the sweet side and could use a bit more bitters, but great for a quick go-to.

Theodore P.

Send more! You might be able to find better old fashioneds - but it will be hard to do. We were pleasantly surprised by how good a bottled mix could be and we are definitely going to order more.

John B.

This stuff is very very good. The reason for 4 stars instead of 5 is simply because it is so expensive. It is every bit as expensive as the Woodford in this picture. Anyway, I’ll probably get it again or maybe give the competition a try at a significant price difference. Again, very good.

Michael K.

Love this syrup!!! Just half an ounce with your favorite bourbon and you have a smooth delicious tasting cocktail. I will continue to buy and look forward to trying the different flavors.

Greg P.

Have to say I was a skeptic. How good could this really be? But I am pleased to say I love it! Tastes as good as an Old Fashion I would make from scratch in terms of flavor. Seriously. And the really good news is I can be sipping my drink sooner. Give a try. I think you’ll be glad you did.

James B.

Great product, it’s so much quicker just pour mix and drink. I was surprised at how quickly it arrived here in Northern Pennsylvania, 4 days. Will be ordering again in the near future.

Proof Syrup ReviewsMore details