Proof Syrup Reviews

undefined review of Traditional Proof Syrup image 1 out of 1

Dan C.

Extremely happy with this product! Bought the Traditional to give it a try - it makes a great tasting Old Fashioned in a fraction of the time than from scratch. Shipping was fast, took only 3-4days to get delivered, had no issues with receiving it. Will definitely be ordering more in the future!

Walter F.

I bought it to bring to the beach the week of October 4th. Spending time with my brothers at Pawleys Island. Only made it til September 23rd. Time to re-order

Connie M.

i loved using Proof with my Makers Mark and adding an extra slice of orange a couple of premium cherries a large ice cubes in my favorite Vietri glasses.. An evening made in cocktail heaven!

Eli G.

Great flavor, and extremely smooth. Have tried it with several bourbons, and even a spiced rum and it has been great each time. Easiest way to make an old fashioned at home without having to have all of the ingredients on hand or worry about mixing everything just right.

Gene A.

I’m new to drinking Old Fashioned(s). But the reviews don’t lie, Proof Syrup is tasty and easy. Will probably order again. I had confidence in the product and ordered three bottles and gave two as gifts. Not disappointed....

Robert James V.

I have become your biggest fan! Not having had an Old-Fashioned in years, it is now my refreshment of choice in my home, because of the Proof syrup! I use black cherries and a hint of black cherry juice, which accounts for the color in this photo!

Bruce N.

To put it simply, I am totally satisfied with your product. I'm making the perfect old-fashioned with my favorite bourbons, which at the moment are Woodford Reserve and my recent discovery Longbranch by Wild Turkey. I will be placing my second order very soon!

Dan G.

If this was the 1920's, I would say that this stuff is the bees knees, the flea’s eyebrows, the cat’s whiskers, the cat’s meow, the monkey’s eyebrows, the snake’s’ hips, the canary’s tusks... But it's 2020. So all I have to say is that this stuff is the best part of 2020, and you know that isn't a lie because, well... 2020. Absolutely delicious, super simple, and gives you the perfect mix for your old fashioned, every time.

John K.

I love an Old Fashioned but am no bartender, much preferring to keep my bar work simple and fast. My daughter is actually the one who turned me on to Proof Traditional Old Fashioned syrup and I thank her for the introduction! Makes a great drink with no additional additives, although when I'm feeling ambitious I might add an orange peel/slice for looks. Good value too (if anything better than expected, because I tend to use a little less of the syrup (or a little more of the bourbon!) when pour...

Lauralyn P.

An Old fashion is my go to drink when I’m out at a bar or restaurant but Proof makes it so easy to have the same thing at hope. Delicious!

Dale D.

Received my Proof Syrup Traditional about two weeks ago but waited on my son in law to come into town to try it. We both list old fashions as our favorite cocktail. Mixing the drink was fast and very easy. Topped ours off with an orange peel twist. We expected it to be good based on the reviews BUT were blown away with how good of a drink Proof Syrup made. I highly recommend and cannot wait to try some of the other flavors.

Todd B.

I love an Old Fashioned, but I don't like to take the time to make them from scratch (nor do I have all of the ingredients readily available most of the time). This Proof Syrup is the bomb! Making an Old Fashioned cocktail couldn't be any easier and more delicious! With or without the orange garnish, you will love this super-simple cocktail!

Elizabeth G.

We love your Syrups! We’ve tried them all and they’re all amazing BUT our favorite is the Pecan. It’s slightly sweeter than the rest which makes for an amazing drink. While my husband thinks it’s a sin to drink Blantons mixed, I think it’s a sin not to add Proof syrup! - A wife of a whiskey lover

Kelly J.

Had an Old Fashioned with a friend a while back. He sent me a bottle of your mix, and it’s fantastic! I am really enjoying these, and plan to get some more mixer very soon!

Becky E.

Until I tried Proof Original, ordering an Old Fashioned cocktail in a restaurant or in a bar was not very frequent. There are also bartenders who do not make one well. If I had a good Old Fashioned cocktail served to me, it was always a special treat. Now, with a simple bottle, I can enjoy my very own good Old Fashioned in the comfort of my home. And, it tastes great!

D A.

Was a little skeptical at 1st but I have to say, this proof syrup is exactly as advertised. You just pick your Bourbon, add a twist of orange and the perfect drink is yours!

Jess P.

It tastes great, it’s very easy and quick to make. The flavor is very consistent. You want it a little sweeter, pour a little more Proof in, not so sweet, pour a little less. I would definitely buy more. I’m excited to try the other flavors. The hardest part is choosing what whiskey / bourbon to mix it with.

Robert S.

Love Proof! It used to be too much trouble to make an Old Fashioned, now it’s so easy. I’ve even got Marsha to make them and hand me one as soon as I walk in the door. Let’s Rock!

Stacy F.

Love this syrup! I have both the Traditional and the Pecan. Both are delicious, but I’m partial to the original. Great product! Making an Old Fashioned is a breeze too!

Randall B.

Great, quick, easy, consistent and just damn good. Buy two bottles when you know you have family coming over. Get fancy with toasting an orange and large ice cube or drink like us, cup- ice-bourbon-splash of PROOF. Done. Damn good!

The H.

I love PROOF! I add just a splash of club soda to mine to make it a tad bit lighter but I love that I can taste the bitters. It's my favorite old fashioned mix by far!

Autumn T.

I got this to put in my husband's stocking. I only got one bottle until we tried it. Now that we have, we will definitely be ordering more! It is the fastest and easiest way to make a delicious Old Fashioned!

Shamus S.

The original is amazing! Shipping was much slower than I had hoped/expected but luckily, it arrived in time for an annual trip to the mountains that my wife and I take with some close friends. A group of “bourbon buddies” also approve!

Amy B.

So easy to make and tastes JUST like an Old Fashioned from a high end restaurant and/or bar. We are saving so much money by making these at home. Will definitely continue to order these!

Karen R.

Thoroughly enjoyed your product. This was a test run for Thanksgiving. A no nonsense Old Fashion. It was spectacular. No one bothered taking pictures of the final showing on Thanksgiving. They were too busy drinking. The Proof was in the glass!!!!

Vicki D.

I LOVE old fashions with a shot of amaretto! This picture is all I have left in tonight's drink! Poof syrup makes concocting these so easy, I enjoy them more than ever. Not having to make the simple syrup and get the bitters just right is a dream!

Bruce D.

Only got into Old Fashioneds a couple of years ago. Tried another syrup from the grocery store, but this stuff is so much better. We had to experiment to dial in our perfect ratio, but I think we have it down.

Melissa G.

Received my Proof syrup the day before Thanksgiving. We enjoyed many Old Fashioned's for the holiday! Im always in pursuit of the perfect old fashioned and this syrup helped me attain it! Melissa Billings, MT

Bill E.

I started with a bottle of Traditional and went through that in no time. Ordered Traditional and Maple Bacon. Both are amazing! Love the flavors and the ease of making a wonderful Old Fashion.

Lillian R.

Proof Traditional Syrup is so good! Makes an easy and tasty Old Fashioned. I can’t wait to try the other flavors and also some of the recipes found on the site.

Jarred G.

This stuff is amazing and provides a much simpler approach to making the same tasty cocktail time and time again. I’d say the proof is in the PROOF! Trust me, you won’t regret it!

Not savvy with the computer and sending Pictures but we are enjoying our cocktails with Proof. Our son received all 3 syrups and recommended them. We are started out with the Traditional. Glad we did. It is great to make a cocktail and with no fuss using the syrup. Would be interested in trying the other syrups soon. Vicki Kilbane [email protected]

Steve C.

Old fashions have been my go to bar drink for years. But they are too complex to make at home easily. Proof makes it easy and it tastes like my old favorite! Well done.

Marsha P.

My husband, Greg, loves drinking Old Fashions. So when I saw your product online, I had to order it as a surprise for him. I've now learned that I will be a frequent customer because he says Proof makes the best Old Fashion he's tasted. And I can attest to him having consumed many Old Fashions! Of course in the photo is our parrot, Paco, who goes everywhere with Greg because every rye whiskey drinker should have a wingman. We're thankful we found your product and look forward to a long and fr...

Jim M.

Used to enjoy my OF's from a bartender in So Cal with a buddy, but moved and can't seem to find anyone to make it the same, until now...ME! Perfect flavor! I put a torch under the orange peel, over the glass and the pours explode their flavors into the glass and provides a hint of smoky goodness. I had 3 the day Proof came in the mail, and forced to pace myself since...still have to get up and go to work. Can't wait to share with my family coming to visit. Proof will always be in my cabinet f...

Cindy S.

I am in love with Proof ! The classic Old Fashioned is so simple and delicious using the Traditional Proof, but it is delicious with other liquors as well. This is .5 oz proof, 2 oz. vodka and 1 oz cranberry. I am really enjoying craft cocktails at home with Proof, way more cost effective and using the amount of liquor that suits my taste. Excited to try the Pecan version this fall.

Eric O.

I love a great Old Fashioned and now that I can make an incredible one at home I do so a couple times a week. Thank you so much for creating Proof Syrup. It’s a game changer. Pro tip: add three Luxardo cherries on a cocktail skewer for some added luxury.

Casey B.

Truly perfect and well worth it (less than $1 per drink). No sugar cubes, bitters, orange peel, etc. Just pour 1/2 oz. in, stir, and you’re done for the perfect Old Fashioned.

David H.

Proof Syrop, Angles Envy and three fresh-picked blackberries that are gently squeezed to get a drop or two of blackberry juice in the mix . . . Life is very, very good!!!

Charles L.

During the COVID lockdown I have missed frequenting high end bars and drinking a hand crafted Old Fashioned. Attempts at home were unable to replicate the bar version. Proof syrup was the game changer. I have now equaled or surpassed the best Old Fashioned’s from my high end bar. I’ve even have giant cube and sphere ice cubes, a zester, and marinated cherries. I am now the designated bar tender in my small group of quarantine friends (I’m very good a following directions and measuring). I hi...

Proof Syrup ReviewsMore details