Amy W.Verified
Simple and easy but so much to choose from
Purchased item
Order Protect
"Amazingly good, I ate them before I could tak..."
Buckeye Brownies store reviewsSee product reviews
Glynis B.Verified
Ordering a build your own box would be easier if there were descriptions of the brownies on that page. The time from ordering to receiving was good.
Purchased item
Build Your Brownie Box
"The brownies were not to my taste."
Austin H.Verified
Great. I live a few states away from their location, even though it took longer than I thought, but that was due to really bad weather. I would 100% get buckeyes again, their products are excellent, for a bakery it was good delivery and nothing was damaged nor bad tasting. Wish I got more lol!
Purchased item
Blackout Oreo Cookie Cake
"We loved this Oreo cake, especially when u wa..."
Shannon T.Verified
Easy to order and quick shipment
Purchased item
Order Protect
"Everything is great and I highly recommend!"
Courtney K.Verified
I had such a great shopping experience! Everything was smooth from start to finish, and I really appreciated the attention to detail. The products were exactly as described, and you can tell a lot of care goes into what they offer. I’ll definitely be coming back again!
Purchased item
Order Protect
"I tried the Buckeye Brownies and wow… they di..."
Brian B.Verified
No
Purchased item
The Classics - Cookies and Cream Fudge Brownie Cups
"No"
Jason K.Verified
Easy to order
Purchased item
March Madness Bundle
"Good but missing something"
Michael L.Verified
Great quality product can’t wait to order again loyal customer for life.
Purchased item
Order Protect
"The family was very happy with the order it w..."
Ann F.Verified
The brownie was good, but the icing on top was too sweet and seemed to take away from the brownie.
Purchased item
Pistachio Graham 4-Pack - CLOSEOUT - WILL SHIP 3/16
"My husband and son both loved the Pistachio b..."
Ralph K.Verified
Great
Purchased item
Order Protect
"Great"
Kim C.Verified
The website was easy to navigate and the build a box option was a win!
Purchased item
Build Your Brownie Box
"They were delicious and were devoured within..."
Matthew P.Verified
Great experience from start to finish
Purchased item
The Classics - Peanut Butter Fudge Brownie Cups
"Absolutely delicious"
Sharletha E.Verified
Way too sweet and too many oats
Purchased item
Build Your Brownie Box
"Very mushy seemed raw still"
Andrea M.Verified
Everything I’ve ordered has been amazing!
Purchased item
Blackout Oreo Cookie Cake
"I love everything that I’ve ordered from Buck..."
Angela B.Verified
Very helpful and responded quickly with questions!
Purchased item
Order Protect
"Brownies were just as described! Purchased th..."
Sara D.Verified
The best brownies! If you haven’t tried what are you waiting for? Definitely ordering again to try different flavors!
Purchased item
Order Protect
"The best brownie around! I couldn’t believe h..."
John M.Verified
The variety of baked goods and easy shopping experience was great.
Purchased item
Build Your Brownie Box
"The brownies were delicious and I was impress..."
Terrell H.Verified
Marketing team is doing their job well. Once I saw the ad I couldn’t stop thinking about them. So yeah not “brainwashy”, just the right amount of curiosity
Purchased item
The Classics - Cookies and Cream Fudge Brownie Cups
"Definitely my favorite part of my order. Hope..."
Jovanta M.Verified
Overall easy experience
Purchased item
Limited Edition March Madness Pack
"I don’t know if it was the batch but it just..."
Sinead O.Verified
Underwhelming
Purchased item
The Classics - Cookies and Cream Fudge Brownie Cups
"Get better quality ingredients"
Mindy M.Verified
I had an order mistake and they made it right immediately. Couldn’t ask for better service or a better brownie!
Purchased item
Scout’s Favorite 4-Pack - March Flavor of the Month
"Soft and perfectly sweet!! Fresh brownies"
Ryan N.Verified
The packaging was nice and the experience with the site was perfectly fine, but the product itself was not at all like what I read in all the reviews.
Purchased item
Order Protect
"I simply didn't like the product, and for wha..."
Douglas S.Verified
Easy to select. Easy to love
Purchased item
No Bake Buckeye Bombs
"They came, we ate, bellies were filled, and t..."
Lauren E.Verified
Horrible taste. I had three people refuse to eat them. Waste of $70 don’t buy.
Purchased item
Order Protect
"I bought $70 worth of items. Absolutely horri..."
Kim L.Verified
Very dry
Purchased item
Order Protect
"Everything was super dry"
Jamie B.Verified
Ordering was a dream and they were delivered quickly.
Purchased item
Order Protect
"I'm not done tasting all the brownies but so..."
Teresa L.Verified
Awesome, very delicious. Purchased as a gift, daughter took it work and was devoured...
Purchased item
Order Protect
"Ty"
Carol B.Verified
The brownies were ok. Not great like advertised and for the price.
Purchased item
Order Protect
"Arrived in a timely manner"
Ann S.Verified
Please see previous
Purchased item
Order Protect
"The last email I got said they were just bake..."
Daniel D.Verified
Heavy and delicious
Purchased item
No Bake Buckeye Bombs
"Super sweet other than that they were good."
William D.Verified
.
Purchased item
Order Protect
"."
Robert H.Verified
Amazing
Purchased item
Order Protect
"The cookies and dream might be the best flavo..."
Debra S.Verified
Excellent product and customer service!
Purchased item
Order Protect
"I’ve ordered multiple times when we are havin..."
Dominique S.Verified
The brownies were all soft and delicious. I will definitely order again.
Purchased item
Order Protect
"My order arrived and everything was in place..."
Kristin S.Verified
It was fun to try the classic flavor 4 pack. My first time having these and it was great!
Purchased item
Order Protect
"Each of the four flavors was delicious and fr..."
Samantha R.Verified
Dull dry brownies. Like glue that crumbles but sticks together when ate. Had to order two orders and was never reimbursed for the first that didn't come
Purchased item
Order Protect
"Very dry and dull taste. Plus I had to make t..."
Raytez S.Verified
website was easy to use and brownies arrived in a timely manner
Purchased item
Build Your Brownie Box
"Absolutely delicious flavors, tasted the best..."
Jeff S.Verified
Impressive process
Purchased item
Order Protect
"Ordered the Fantastic Four Package and If I a..."
Richsrd B.Verified
Easy to order, shipped very quickly, and missing items replaced in a timely manner.
Purchased item
The Classics - Peanut Butter Fudge Brownie Cups
"Ordered multiple delicious treats which were..."
Rebecca C.Verified
Was easy to purchase but not worth the money at all
Purchased item
Order Protect
"Too dry, seems like tried to put too much int..."
Buckeye Brownies store reviewsVisit store