Buckeye Brownies Reviews - 9,015 Reviews | buckeyebrownies.com

Buckeye Brownies Reviews

Name: Buckeye Brownies
Rating: 4.7

undefined review of Order Protect image 1 out of 2

Antonio S.Verified

Brownies came in very nice, I liked all of the different ones, and the variety of flavors, I'm glad there was a "build your own box" because it allowed me to pick what I actually would like, and I loved all of them a lot, the Cookie Monster one was by far my favorite, I tried it with my family and we all had different favorites, so it's definitely great to share especially because it is a lot, I would say definitely worth getting again one day.

Order Protect

undefined review of The Classics - Peanut Butter Fudge Brownie Cups image 1 out of 1

Phillip D.Verified

Of the package I received, these cups were the ones I was really waiting for and man did they not disappoint!! Again, they weren't too sweet and just the right size to share with a friend. 10/10

The Classics - Peanut Butter Fudge Brownie Cups

undefined review of Build Your Box image 1 out of 1

Phillip D.Verified

Very good combination and my firends loved them too!! I took a few samplings of these dreamy brownies camping over the holiday weekend and nothing but praise. None were too sweet which I love.

Build Your Box

undefined review of Order Protect image 1 out of 1

Barbara H.Verified

I absolutely love these brownies. Every single one has been over a 10 in freshness and taste. The Carnival box was amazing. I had gotten it before, but this time, there was the chocolate in place of the animal cookie one. I was initially disappointed, as I am not a fan of just chocolate. I did not need to worry. My husband, who I hid the brownies from, found the chocolate, claimed it, and keeps checking the freezer to make sure that last piece is there. I have used the brownies for birthd...

Order Protect

undefined review of TED VELVET 4-Pack - CLOSEOUT - Will ship 8/21 image 1 out of 1

India E.Verified

This is definitely one of my favorite brownies from Buckeye Brownies. I try to get it any time it's offered. The cookie and white chocolate chips really complement the red velvet brownie. Highly recommend!

TED VELVET 4-Pack - CLOSEOUT - Will ship 8/21

Shaun N.Verified

These brownies are the only dessert I will order for the rest of my life lol. The continuous variety of new flavors, the texture and perfect amount of sweetness is second to none.

Build Your Box

undefined review of LIMITED EDITION CARNIVAL CRAVINGS BOX image 1 out of 3

Alan C.Verified

Buckeye bombshell was my favorite and the main reason I bought this box. The churro caramel cream surprised me because I thought it would be the one I liked the least and I absolutely devoured that one without snapping a pic. The other two were good but didn't blow me away but hey you cant win um all. I absolutely adore this company!

LIMITED EDITION CARNIVAL CRAVINGS BOX

undefined review of Limited Edition Back To School Box image 1 out of 1

Brandon N.Verified

Nothing beats eating these buckeye brownies after a long bodybuilding prep. So much delicious sweets all in one bite Buckeye brownies will always be my go to sweet treat. You are missing out if you have never had these yet. 100% will not regret getting these for yourself or a loved one.

Limited Edition Back To School Box

undefined review of COOKIE MONSTER 4-Pack - August Flavor of the Month image 1 out of 1

Nina M.Verified

These brownies are really good and i been want to try this flavor but i had to wait the flavor of the month to try them so last month they was available so i order them and i was excited to try them.

COOKIE MONSTER 4-Pack - August Flavor of the Month

Dallon M.Verified

One of the best boxes yet. The bombshell and double trouble was by far some of my favorite ones. Buckeye brownie has an amazing team and keeps coming up with new combinations.

Order Protect

Jesse R.Verified

It took a little longer than I expected........ but I do live in Maine, and it wouldn't have mattered if it took a month, it was worth the wait. It was packaged really well. Everything was fresh and delicious. Every brownie in the fall box was stellar and the s'more brownies and Buckeye bombs I can't say enough about so creative and so delicious! I'm just a normal regular dude from Maine not a paid actor🤣😂😁🥰 all jokes aside worth every penny! What are you waiting for don't hesitate, buy as much ...

Order Protect

Ann H.Verified

I ordered these for my son and his girlfriend. They received them this week and were obsessed! Their favorite was the peanut butter brownie. I was worried if they would arrive fresh, bc it shipped out of state. They were so fresh and tasty!

Order Protect

Barbara H.Verified

I love the build your box. I find it hard to narrow down just four, so I keep ordering new ones and old favorites. If you see something you like, get it. Some of my favorites are seasonal. I loved the hot fudge so much, and I am not a huge chocolate lover. I am thinking about my next order!

Build Your Box

undefined review of PB PERFECTION 4-Pack - CLOSEOUT - WILL SHIP 7/24 image 1 out of 1

Dustin V.Verified

This is an amazing PB brownie. The chocolate base with pb oreos and pb soft cookie dough in the middle is amazing. Warm it up for 40sec in the microwave and it becomes perfect.

PB PERFECTION 4-Pack - CLOSEOUT - WILL SHIP 7/24

undefined review of Buckeye’s Birthday Bundle image 1 out of 5

Randy B.Verified

Let me tell you the box was in mint condition. The brownies were an excellent condition the way that the packaging was all the way from shipping. The whole entire process was beyond amazing top it off. They are super delicious. Looking forward to my next order.

Buckeye’s Birthday Bundle

Laura M.Verified

Sent to my mother for her birthday party with friends instead of a cake. They loved loved loved every second of these brownies. The delicious churro brownie was the favorite of the group.

Build Your Box

undefined review of Rush Baking image 1 out of 1

Shaun N.Verified

Rush baking is so worth it! When you want your brownies I love this option. We had my mom coming to town and needed to get them before she arrived. The 4-packs are the perfect amount of variety and quantity to satisfy us, but also leaving us wanting more lol. Highly recommend if you love brownie’s and love getting them fast! Y’all did it again 🙏🏻

Rush Baking

Harrison B.Verified

You can never go wrong with Buckeye brownies!! I got the build your own box and every flavor was amazing as usual. Can’t wait to try the Cookie Monster 😮‍💨

Build Your Box

Dustin V.Verified

I did the 4th of July box, but replaced lemon with PB Smore's. Cheesecake brownie was best chilled out of the fridge and was over 1/2lb, making me love buckeye even more for large portions. Sundae was great except the fudge topping. Mighty muffin was the best overall after warming in microwave.

Build Your Box

undefined review of The Classics - S’mores Fudge Brownie Cups image 1 out of 1

Phillip D.Verified

I bought these to take on my camping trip but then decided to keep them for myself. I have not tried these yet but if they are anything like the brownies and fudge cups, I'm sure they will be good. I did try one of the Teddy Grams on top and it was soft. That I imagine, is to be expected.

The Classics - S’mores Fudge Brownie Cups

David K.Verified

Got these with the Reese cups. The cookie monster was good I like to try the limited flavors. I share these when I get them and people are like wow. Hopefully they do buy them also. Great Job Buckeye Team!!

COOKIE MONSTER 4-Pack - August Flavor of the Month

Dana A.Verified

The flavor so amazing, The best fo my Churros and PB jealousies I give it 10/10, The Oreo and cookie 9/10. The last one 8/10 because so sweet

Build Your Box

undefined review of COOKIE MONSTER 4-Pack - August Flavor of the Month image 1 out of 2

Ann D.Verified

OMG! Again another addicting brownie! My two favorite cookies in a brownie! Delish! Brownies never last long in my home. Having to take some time off from purchasing. Not long though, new flavors are out!

COOKIE MONSTER 4-Pack - August Flavor of the Month

Dallon M.Verified

They order protect is always a great standard to have in. My mind is at ease, knowing that my delicious brownies will arrive without any imperfections and or damages to the box and it makes the whole experience that much better when opening up to see the wonderful creations.

Order Protect

Jeffery K.Verified

All 4 of the brownies I got were amazing. The chocolate cheesecake brownie was my favorite but teddy velvet was a close 2nd. You couldn’t go wrong with any of the 3!

Build Your Box

undefined review of Limited Edition March Madness Pack image 1 out of 1

Shaun N.Verified

The March Madness pack might’ve been my favorite pack to date! The unique flavor combinations, the mouth watering formulations of cookie dough flavors and the light sweetness without the overpowering sugary taste are just a few things I love most about these bad boys. Oh, also did you know each brownie is a 1/2 pound! 👀 ⚖️ They’re HUGE! I’m a brownie fanatic and I can confidently say these are the best I’ve ever had (don’t tell my mom bc she makes some pretty elite brownies, haha). I will be o...

Limited Edition March Madness Pack

Jordan E.Verified

Great brownies high quality ingredients definitely lived up to the name a lot more sweeter than expected but after reaching my weight loss goal they were definitely a good treat

Order Protect

undefined review of Limited Edition Celebration Box image 1 out of 1

Trisha G.Verified

They were so good that I am rationing them! I ate half and saved the remaining in the freezer until I get back from my trip! This was the second box of Buckeye Brownies I ordered, and it is even better than the other one which was absolutely fantastic!

Limited Edition Celebration Box

Kristina G.Verified

I ordered a Build Your Own 4 pack and could NOT have been more pleased with my brownies! I took one to a bodybuilding competition and had so many other competitors ask if it was a Buckeye Brownie. And it was the perfect treat to have after the competition and share with my team!

Build Your Box

Cameron C.Verified

Everything was amazing I was expecting to eat the whole thing but it was a bit too sweet after 24 weeks of prep. Would love to see a protein packed brownie with 30-100g per brownie 🤞🤞

Build Your Box

Brittany W.Verified

Got the celebration pack for after my bodybuilding show. All the flavors were amazing. My favorite was fruity pebble, then blueberry, peanut butter recess cup then the cookie dough. Definitely gonna heat any of the ones with chocolate next time.

Order Protect

undefined review of LIMITED EDITION CARNIVAL CRAVINGS BOX image 1 out of 1

Amanda B.Verified

My family and I really enjoyed these brownies!! They are huge! Definitely worth the money spent. Cannot wait to try some More!! And they weren’t overly sweet. Which we loved!! Perfect!!

LIMITED EDITION CARNIVAL CRAVINGS BOX

undefined review of Butterfinger AF 4-Pack - CLOSEOUT - WILL SHIP 6/11 image 1 out of 1

Kyle C.Verified

Really, really tasty! The peanut butter and butterfinger infused cookie dough was amazing and the crumpled bits of Butterfinger and snack sized Butterfinger was an awesome touch as well! Would highly recommend!

Butterfinger AF 4-Pack - CLOSEOUT - WILL SHIP 6/11

undefined review of Limited Edition Fathers Day Box image 1 out of 1

Erica S.Verified

these brownies are out of this world! so gooey, NOT TOO SWEET, but very unique!!! i absolutely loved the father’s day bundle. the MVP- oreo one was incredible! also the apple one was amazing with vanilla ice cream!!!! i absolutely love each flavor and can’t wait to buy more. you can physically taste each bite of everything they add into these. and there massive so i can always have for multiple nights after dinner for a late night treat. 10/10 recommend

Limited Edition Fathers Day Box

undefined review of Pick Two image 1 out of 1

Braden A.Verified

Love the classic brownies snickerdoodle and chill, and Mr.buckeye. Gotten them quite a few times throughout the last 4 or 5 years and they are always super moist and delicious.

Pick Two

undefined review of Birthday Bash 4-Pack - MARCH FLAVOR OF THE MONTH image 1 out of 1

Adam M.Verified

I got the 4 pack, Birthday bash for the month of March. I put the brownie in the oven, how it was recommended. The flavor and everything was amazing, gooey and delicious!

Birthday Bash 4-Pack - MARCH FLAVOR OF THE MONTH

undefined review of The Classics - Fudge Cups Bundle image 1 out of 2

Ivan W.Verified

The fudge cups are one of the best things ever created by Buckeye Brownies. Never get rid of them. As you can see, I don't miss an opportunity to combine them with other Brownies. It's a fudge overload!

The Classics - Fudge Cups Bundle

Joe S.Verified

Always love the build your box my go to is always the snickerdoodle and chill, trying the almond crunch one bite was amazing, I love everything about these brownies absolutely nothing like them out there.

Build Your Box

Ava H.Verified

the best brownie i’ve ever had in my fucking life i’m deadass so sprung on this shit good god please make a box with like ted velvet cookie monster butter my Bischoff and either oreo cheesecake or the blueberry cheesecake one please GOD i’m yearning for more

Order Protect

Ivan W.Verified

I finally found my all-time favorite brownie. The birthday cake is my #1! Tasting chocolate fudge, white chocolate, vanilla cake, and cookies n'cream flavors all in one brownie was too addicting. Please bring it back Buckeye Brownies😭! Or better yet don't before I fill my freezer with them. I need to lose weight😅.

Birthday Bash 4-Pack - MARCH FLAVOR OF THE MONTH

Buckeye Brownies ReviewsMore details