Karen T.
Helpful and friendly staff.
Purchased item
Atocha Re-creation Copper Ingot Pendant in Sterling Silver
"Wonderful pendant and experience at Mel Fishe..."
MFST store reviewsSee product reviews
Ernest M.
Almost too simple.
Purchased item
Sterling Silver Anchor Chain
"More beautiful than I anticipated."
Carolann C.
Received really nice shirt super quickly. Will wear all the time. Thank you!
Purchased item
Today's the day! T-shirt
"I was there in 1985 in Key West with my paren..."
Gregory Q.
Thanks for the coin!
Purchased item
El Cazador Coin HR #EC-HR-NGC-B
"Thanks for the coin!"
Gregory K.
Great experience. John Petzold has been excellent to work with.
Purchased item
14K Mount #05SJ-000038M
"Excellent piece. Received lots of envious com..."
Jacob F.
Great !
Purchased item
Taffi Fisher Collection Re-creation Silver Cross
"Love the pendant !"
Stacy B.
Customer service was excellent!
Purchased item
Re-Creation Half Reale Coin Ring, Copper and Sterling Silver
"Love my ring just a great piece of history !"
Kathi H.
Fun
Purchased item
Atocha Coin G4 4R #85A-172420
"I love my new Coin, The people were very nice..."
Brittney L.
Always courteous, quick, and informative. Will keep ordering pieces for my husband and I.
Purchased item
Atocha Re-creation Coin Pendant 8 Reales Double Prong in Sterling Silver
"What a beautiful piece of jewelry. My husband..."
Samantha L.
Easy and fast
Purchased item
Atocha Re-creation Crucifix Pendant in Sterling Silver
"Beautiful piece!"
Matthew S.
Great description and super fast delivery
Purchased item
Atocha Re-creation Copper Ingot Pendant in Sterling Silver
"My wife loved it. Thank you."
Jay H.
Was ok
Purchased item
Tales of the ATOCHA - Atocha Re-creation Coin Pendant in Sterling Silver Mount
"Beautiful pendant but one of the four clasps..."
William D.
Easy to order. Shipped quickly.
Purchased item
Re-Creation One Reale Coin Ring, Copper and Sterling Silver “sea king”
"Goes with the Atocha coin already owned"
Walter S.
😊 Loved it
Purchased item
Tales of the ATOCHA - Atocha Re-creation Coin Pendant in 14K Gold Mount
"Love it…always wanted one !!!"
Rocky C.
Cheers!! Love your museum and store.
Purchased item
Sterling Silver Heavy Anchor Chain
"Great Chain! Wish I had purchased while in Ke..."
Travis J.
Great place full of history of the ultimate shipwreck
Purchased item
Sterling Silver Heavy Anchor Chain
"Was a great experience visiting the ultimate..."
Mark J.
Quick and easy with timely delivery.
Purchased item
14K White and Yellow Gold Compass Rose Pendant with Diamonds
"Had some questions so I called them. Exceedin..."
John W.
Fast shipping much appreciated
Purchased item
Taffi Fisher Collection 1 Reale Atocha Re-creation Silver, Double Prong, Cross Side
"The shopping couldn’t have been easier, and t..."
Jeffrey D.
Jam up!
Purchased item
Tales of the ATOCHA - Atocha re-creation mini earrings in Sterling Silver Mount
"They are beautiful and look great with neckla..."
Joseph G.
Quick/prompt service, speedy delivery 🚚
Purchased item
Today's the day! T-shirt
"Always been a Mel Fisher fan, meet him briefl..."
Matthew R.
z
Purchased item
14K Vermeil Gold Overlay Sterling Silver Chain
"."
Hawes A.
Informative, pleasant, polite,
Purchased item
Treasure Coins of the Atocha and Margarita Anniversary Edition by Carol Tedesco
"Extremely pleasant and informative"
Susan J.
My pendant was delivered quickly and it is lovely
Purchased item
14K Y/W Gold Compass Rose Pendant with Emerald and Diamonds
"I love this pendant!"
Mallory Scott V.
Easy
Purchased item
Today's the Day! The Mel Fisher Story by Wendy Tucker
"Beautiful"
Carol C.
Excellent service!! Very knowledgeable employees.
Purchased item
Tales of the ATOCHA - Atocha Re-creation Coin Pendant in 14K Gold Mount
"The pendant is really gorgeous!!"
Keith R.
Always fast and easy
Purchased item
Silver Compass Rose Earrings
"My wife loved the earrings, she is a big fan..."
Jai M.
Seem less they helped
Purchased item
Tales of the ATOCHA - 24K gold museum-quality re-creation escudo with a 14K mount
"The gift was very appreciated by our special..."
Michael G.
John is our salesman!
Will be back!
Mike
Purchased item
14K Gold Compass Rose Earrings with Emerald and Diamonds
"John helped me out and I also purchased more..."
William K.
Quick shipping - Awesome piece - Easy
Purchased item
Un-Cut Colombian Emerald, SM Mounted in Sterling Silver, with 20" Sterling Silver Chain
"My wife loved it!"
Pat G.
The staff at this store were so helpful and pleasant! Awesome!
Purchased item
Taffi Fisher Collection 1 Reale Atocha Re-creation Silver Coin Earrings, Shield Side
"These are superbly made and look so nice on...."
Debra L.
Shipping was quick and the packaging was nice.
Purchased item
14K Lace Ring with Amethyst #MF-14KLARA
"A beautiful ring . The quality is very nice...."
Brian J.
Great people and knowledgeable
Purchased item
Atocha Coin G3 4R #85A-172442
"Always a pleasure going here."
Lisa E.
Very knowledgeable staff,very helpful in picking out right pendant in my price range
Purchased item
Atocha Re-creation Copper Ingot Pendant in Sterling Silver
"Love my copper and silver pendant.Very unique..."
Linda F.
awesome
Purchased item
Atocha Re-creation Coin Pendant 1/2 Reale Double Prong in Sterling Silver
"i’ve added it to my travel medals to remind m..."
Joe F.
NOT THE FIRST TIME I HAVE MANY THINGS THAT I HAVE GOTTEN IN KEY WEST
Purchased item
Tales of the ATOCHA - Atocha re-creation mini earrings in Sterling Silver Mount
"SHE LOVED THEM. GAVE ON MOTHERS DAY"
Rachel M.
It’s always a pleasure shopping at the store great people great products.
Purchased item
Tales of the ATOCHA - 24K gold museum-quality re-creation escudo with a 14K mount
"Always the best experience dealing with this..."
David L.
Susan was fantastic!!!
Purchased item
Atocha Coin G3 8R #86A-135974
"Susan Rampello was a true professional. Answe..."
Jerold D.
The ordering procedure was very simple and the item was shipped and received quickly. Very satisfied.
Purchased item
Silver Compass Rose Earrings
"These were a gift for my wife to match her co..."
Lucien M.
Fast shipping, no hassles.
Purchased item
18K Mount #PC17-31580M
"Awesome coin!!!!!!!!"
Michael P.
Fast shipping
Purchased item
Atocha Re-creation Coin Pendant 8 Reales Double Prong in Sterling Silver CP-8R-DP
"I love it it's exactly what I wanted"
MFST store reviewsVisit store