Susan L.
Clerk was helpful but not pushy. Happy to answer any questions and was very knowledgeable.
Purchased item
Widow's Mite Sterling Silver Pendant adjustable 16"/18" silver chain
"I love it! I wear it all the time and hardly..."
MFST store reviewsSee product reviews
Lauren Y.
Quick shipping and beautiful quality!
Purchased item
Atocha Re-creation Coin Pendant 8 Reales Double Prong in Sterling Silver
"Beautiful replica! It came and was even bigge..."
Kevin U.
Enjoyed talking with the salespeople
Very knowledgeable and interesting
Purchased item
Admiral Gardner Coin
"Turning it into a necklace for my grandson’s..."
Linda P.
Easy to navigate the website. Quick shipping! I don't like waiting too long for my purchase and they did not disappoint!
Purchased item
Silver Compass Rose Earrings
"I LOVE these earrings! This is my 3rd piece f..."
Sharon F.
Easy to work with online and on the phone
Purchased item
Small Silver Anchor Chain
"Beautiful jewelry"
Marsha P.
Customer service was professional
Purchased item
14K Y/W Gold Compass Rose Earrings with Sapphire and Diamonds
"Lovely"
Jennifer K.
Mel Fisher’s representative was knowledgeable, friendly, and very helpful. She helped us make the right decision for us, without any pressure to make the sale. 5 stars!
Purchased item
Atocha Coin G1 8R #85A-141426
"My husband had been looking at Atocha coins o..."
Fletcher T.
Awesome experience! Thank you!
Purchased item
14K Gold Anchor Chain
"Awesome experience! Thank you!"
Kelly M.
Always helpful and friendly
Purchased item
Widow's Mite Bracelet Size Large
"Always a pleasure to do business with these f..."
Paul V.
Such nice folks working here
Purchased item
Admiral Gardner Coin
"Great store"
Janet V.
Easy and fast.
Purchased item
14K Mount #85A-155253M
"So as I mentioned, this was a birthday presen..."
Matthew R.
I had a question and had to call the store. Received great CS and easy purchasing through the website.
Purchased item
Tales of the ATOCHA - 24K gold museum-quality re-creation escudo with a 14K mount
"My wife absolutely loves this piece. She had..."
Dewey C.
It was a true museum tour!
Purchased item
Coins of the Lost Galleons
"I have seen the documentaries and heard the s..."
Jamie T.
Super easy thank you for making shopping a breeze!
Purchased item
Taffi Fisher Collection 8 Reale Atocha Re-creation Silver Coin Double Prong, Cross Side
"Husbands 40th birthday present seemed fitting..."
Georgane C.
Easy purchase and super fast shipping!
Purchased item
Tales of the ATOCHA - Atocha Re-creation Coin Pendant in Silver Mount
"Beautiful pendant! Awesome birthday gift!"
James H.
easy and shipping was fast
Purchased item
Tales of the ATOCHA - Atocha Re-creation Coin Pendant in 14K Gold Mount
"Second piece, wife loved it!"
John F.
The website is extremely easy to navigate. Ordering was simple and easy.
Purchased item
Un-Cut Colombian Emerald LARGE, Mounted in Sterling Silver, Including an 20" Sterling Silver Chain
"Great piece! I have been looking at it for aw..."
Christina M.
Great
Purchased item
Tales of the ATOCHA - Atocha Re-creation Coin Pendant in Silver Mount
"As advertised. Great quality"
Lani N.
Very smooth transaction.
Thank you again.
L.N
Purchased item
Mel Fisher's Treasures Visor w/ "Today's the Day" on the side
"I absolutely love my tshirt and visor.
The..."
Larysa K.
Smooth and easy! Thanks for excellent experience!
Purchased item
Land Cob #LAND-COB2R
"What a beautiful piece of history! Love my tr..."
Kaela R.
Always stop in when we visit Key West
Best little shop ever !
Purchased item
"The World's Greatest Treasure Hunter" Mel Fisher
"Great book beautiful pictures
Love Mel Fishe..."
Christine B.
great!
Purchased item
Tales of the ATOCHA - Atocha Re-creation Coin Pendant in 14K Gold Mount
"always wanted it and it looks great with ever..."
Ray O.
Very easy to find what I was looking for, and to purchase.
Purchased item
Taffi Fisher Collection Re-creation Silver Cross
"My wife and I have been diving for many years..."
Justin R.
Fast and easy
Purchased item
Sterling Silver Heavy Anchor Chain
"Listed as “heavy” it’s actually tiny"
Paul A.
Shopping was fine just disappointed in product.
Purchased item
Sterling Silver Olive Blossom Ring Spanish Galleon Shipwreck Re-creation
"Ring is very detailed but disappointed that i..."
Bret N.
Everything from the packaging to the delivery and updates was top notch.
Purchased item
"The World's Greatest Treasure Hunter" Mel Fisher
"Mel Fisher's story is one that every boy drea..."
Jesse D.
GREAT SERVICE AND COMMUNICATION
Purchased item
14K Mount #96A-14252M
"AWESOME PIECE!"
Paula A.
Super nice and very well informed staff.
Purchased item
The Search for the Atocha
"What a great read!! So fun to visit the Mel..."
Jeffrey B.
I have bought a few pieces of jewelry from MFST. Each piece was great quality & looked fabulous. I live in GA; items were carefully packaged when shipped & were received ~1 week from time of order.
Purchased item
Un-Cut Colombian Emerald LARGE, Mounted in Sterling Silver, Including an 20" Sterling Silver Chain
"The large sterling silver octopus holding an..."
Matthew F.
Awesome
Purchased item
Un-Cut Colombian Emerald, SM Mounted in Sterling Silver, with 20" Sterling Silver Chain
"Fast shipping, beautiful necklace."
Jill H.
Staff was very helpful.
Purchased item
14K Y/W Gold Mini Compass Rose Pendant with Emerald and Diamonds
"Lovely pendant with a nice sparkle. I work wi..."
Edward A.
Amazing customer service, and phenomenal products, thank you :)
Purchased item
Atocha Copper Ingot Slice #85A-C3234-2
"Amazing Customer service as always and phenom..."
Scott R.
Our shopping experience was very pleasant.
Purchased item
Atocha Coin G2 2R #85A-150374
"The coin is beautiful and we are so pleased w..."
Kathleen D.
Perfect!
Purchased item
Small Silver Anchor Chain
"As usual, the jewelry from Mail fishers is th..."
Palmer T.
Easy online system. USPS was extremely slow for some reason.
Purchased item
The Atocha Odyssey, Hardcover
"I doubt I will make it to Key West and the mu..."
Ryan L.
Everything I have ordered or bought in person has been awesome. Love to see the packages in the mail.
Purchased item
Today's the day! T-shirt
"Such a cool shirt. Son loves it"
Tom H.
Great selection.
Purchased item
Margarita Coin G3 8R #82M-7868-1
"Had a great time speaking with sales represen..."
Chris N.
Really like my purchase !!
Purchased item
14K Gold Mount #85A-187330M
"All is good !!"
Jeff S.
Beautiful store!!
Purchased item
Sterling Silver Anchor Chain
"Great quality….such a shine to the chain."
Gregory K.
Courteous, knowledgeable service.
Purchased item
Atocha Re-creation Coin Pendant 8 Reales Double Prong in Sterling Silver
"Love my copper coin pendant. Very unique."
MFST store reviewsVisit store