Mark M.
Salesman was very helpful and knowledgeable!
Purchased item
14K CUPID TOOTHPICK PEND #410-C
"Great addition to my necklace."
MFST store reviewsSee product reviews
Kevin C.
Excellent!!
Purchased item
Atocha Coin G2 4R #85A-198412
"Excellent coin necklace for my wife's 30th we..."
Donna B.
The associates were so knowledgeable and their stories were fascinating
Purchased item
Atocha Recreation Pendant 2 Reales Double Prong in Sterling Silver
"Love the idea of having a piece of history!..."
Amy M.
Great shop. When back in Key West I will make a point to stop back in!
Purchased item
Widow's Mite Coin Earrings
"Loved the shop and customer service. Pleasan..."
Kenneth L.
Great experience. Item arrived on time.
Purchased item
14K Gold Olive Blossom Ring
"Nice ring. Like the fact that it has some all..."
Jeffrey D.
This is my 2nd coin and purchase through Mel Fishers and I love both of them! There is not a day that goes by that someone dosnt ask about my jewelry or compliment it!
Purchased item
Custom Mount - JJ
"Kristin Fischer did an amazing job helping me..."
Dawn Shuman S.
Staff was extremely friendly & knowledgeable!
Purchased item
Tales of the ATOCHA - Atocha Recreation Small Coin Pendant in Sterling Silver Mount
"Loved your store! Love the pendant!"
Shanna G.
We had a great time visiting with the staff and hearing stories about the wreck.
Purchased item
Tales of the ATOCHA - Atocha Recreation Small Coin Pendant in Silver Mount
"I love my Atocha Pendant! I've wanted one for..."
Chris N.
Great people to work with.
Purchased item
Atocha Emerald #95A-63000
"Great experience."
Benjamin M.
Great experience all around in the store in Key West and online! Thank you Mel Fisher!
Purchased item
Tales of the ATOCHA - Atocha Recreation Coin Pendant in Silver Mount
"Great experience all around in the store in K..."
Timothy D.
They recognized me when I came in six months prior, having purchased a necklace from them.
Purchased item
Tales of the ATOCHA - Atocha recreation coin set in Sterling Silver Ring
"Love where it. I get compliments all the time"
Janet G.
Superb customer service!
Purchased item
14K Gold Cable Chain
"Outstanding, well crafted piece. Beautiful ch..."
Shannon W.
Great
Purchased item
Limited Today's the Day T-shirt #TS-TodaysTheDay
"Love the items"
Arnold B.
Very helpful and knowledgeable! Really made the experience enjoyable
Purchased item
Atocha Coin G3 4R #85A-135116
"Love this treasure!! So cool to own such a be..."
Renee W.
The staff were extremely knowledgeable and helpful in selecting our pieces.
Purchased item
SS/14K Mount #95A-63012M
"Love the piece. It’s amazing to think where..."
Kristin H.
Loved seeing everything in the store!
Purchased item
Tales of the ATOCHA - Atocha recreation mini earrings in Sterling Silver Mount
"I love these earrings so much! Having a piece..."
Judy D.
Sales associate was very nice and honored the spring sale discount for me. I was very pleased.
Purchased item
Tales of the ATOCHA - Atocha recreation mini earrings in Sterling Silver Mount
"I had purchased the pendant two years ago and..."
Christian M.
So much fun at this shop
Purchased item
Admiral Gardner Coin
"I love having a small piece of history in my..."
Lora C.
A beautiful treasures! The jewelry is gorgeous and the staff is amazing. They are so knowledgeable and we’re able to tell us the story of Mel Fisher. It was so interesting. In fact, we went back again about three weeks later and bought a few more items. I’m sure we will be back again to visit.
Purchased item
14K Gold Anchor Chain 060
"This is a beautiful chain and great quality...."
Lemuel S.
All online.
Purchased item
Atocha Emerald #95A-62934
"My wife Evelyn’s favorite sea creature is a s..."
Stephen C.
My salesperson was awesome!
Purchased item
Tales of the ATOCHA - 24K gold museum-quality recreation escudo with a 14K mount
"It was great! I bought two. One for my wife..."
Derrick B.
Awesome!
Purchased item
Today's the day! T-shirt
"My new favorite shirt!!"
James C.
Very friendly, knowledgeable staff.
Purchased item
Widow's Mite Coin Earrings RE-39W
"A nice piece of history, good detail, lovely..."
Ford D.
Very helpful.. enjoyed the experience.
Purchased item
Treasure Coins of the Atocha and Margarita Anniversary Edition by Carol Tedesco
"Great tteasure. Was in Key West when he foun..."
Sam W.
Easy and the salesperson was very informative
Purchased item
Tales of the ATOCHA - Atocha Recreation Coin Pendant in Silver Mount
"Have followed the Fisher’s and the Atocha sto..."
Kevin S.
Purchased 4 items now, very good quality. Will definitely be back for more.
Purchased item
Sterling Silver Rope Chain 2.8mm AZ-2213
"Excellent service and shipping. Top quality p..."
Matthew K.
Amazing
Purchased item
Recreation "Key Largo" Coin Ring, Copper and Sterling Silver
"We are Locals and loved the knowledge from th..."
Van S.
Great staff.
Purchased item
Custom Mount - JJ
"John was very knowledgeable. Took a coin I’ve..."
Daniel L.
Skip was truly wonderful. Amazing experience all around. Top notch.
Purchased item
The Search for the Atocha
"We stopped in on St Pattys day 2026, and work..."
Brian J.
Thank you,
The website made the purchase process simple.
Planning on trip to Key West to visit the store in person
Purchased item
Taffi Fisher Collection 1/2 Reale Earrings
"This was my gift to my wife on our 25th weddi..."
Nickolas W.
Great experience!
Purchased item
Sao Jose Coin G2 8R #05SJ-000068
"Since I was a child I wanted a coin from Mel..."
Jeff H.
Outstanding
Purchased item
Atocha Recreation Copper Ingot Pendant in Sterling Silver
"Wonderful staff and store."
Doug D.
Great selection of historic items. Fast delivery.
Purchased item
14K Mount #95A-63394M
"Cool way to hold history with a designer made..."
Loretta D.
Very helpful, And
Informative
Purchased item
Un-Cut Colombian Emerald, SM Mounted in Sterling Silver, with 20" Sterling Silver Chain
"Love my new piece! I also have a coin that I..."
Bruce B.
Great staff. Really took the time to explain everything.
Purchased item
14K Mount #85A-146514M
"We had a great visit to Mel Fisher's Treasure..."
Gary E.
Loved tge young kady attending me. Very knowledgeable on history, pieces of eight, , treasure , costs and with a delightful personality.
Purchased item
14K Gold Heavy Anchor Chain 4MM
"Love it. Wanted one sll my life. Not much lif..."
Chris S.
Salesman ? (sorry forgot his name 2 weeks later!) was very knowledgeable, courteous and not a hard sell.
Purchased item
Atocha Coin G4 8R #85A-168809
"Awesome to own such a beautiful artifact that..."
Geoffrey B.
Easy Peasy, just ordered it on line, and it was exactly as displayed in the picture
Purchased item
Authentic Colombian Emerald, 6 CT in Sterling Silver Turtle Mount with 20" CHAIN
"Beautiful piece, my wife loves it.
In compan..."
Lorri S.
It was great. I’m proud to wear a piece of treasure history.
Purchased item
Tales of the ATOCHA - Atocha Re-creation Coin Pendant in 14K Gold Mount
"I was very intrigued by the treasure history...."
Arthur H.
Nothing else to say
Purchased item
Silver Compass Rose Earrings
"Look very expensive. Worth every penny"
MFST store reviewsVisit store