Arthur H.
Nothing else to say
Purchased item
Silver Compass Rose Earrings
"Look very expensive. Worth every penny"
MFST store reviewsSee product reviews
Jennifer V.
☀️
Purchased item
Atocha Emerald #95A-63291
"Excellent stones. Will share pics when I have..."
Samuel W.
The site is very easy to filter for the type of treasure you're looking for. The descriptions of each piece are very detailed so you have a great understanding of what you will be receiving when you order.
Purchased item
Tales of the ATOCHA - Atocha Re-creation Coin Pendant in Silver Mount with Emeralds
"This is for a May birthday present where emer..."
Stacy G.
Love it will be buying from again and I am even getting stuff for my friends and they love it to
Purchased item
The Treasure Diver's Guide
"I love your store hopefully you get more new..."
Ron H.
Very easy to order
Purchased item
Tales of the ATOCHA - Atocha Re-creation Coin Pendant in Silver Mount with Emeralds
"This was a birthday present for my wife and s..."
Bill F.
Great very helpful
Purchased item
Widow's Mite Coin with Hammered Silver Wrap
"Very good transaction"
Dennis S.
Mark made this very easy!!!
Purchased item
Atocha Coin G3 8R #85A-261551
"I worked with Mark in the showroom. I was ver..."
Harry S.
Fascinating history and story to relate
Purchased item
Margarita Coin G4 8R #82M-446-2
"Excellent experience. Knowledgeable staff."
Shannon L.
Knowledgeable and did not rush me. Would recommend.
Purchased item
14K Gold Hollow 060 Anchor Chain
"Beautiful anchor chain, great experience."
Jeri P.
Excellent customer service.
Purchased item
Tales of the ATOCHA - Atocha Re-creation Coin Pendant in 14K Gold Mount with Rubies
"I love my Atocha pendant. I've wanted one sin..."
James R H.
Great web site!
Purchased item
Atocha Re-creation Crucifix Pendant in Sterling Silver
"Perfect on my gold chain!"
Glen F.
THE BEST , GREAT PEOPLE TO DEAL WITH .
Purchased item
14K Mount #94A-0363-5M
"I HAVE PURCHASED SEVERAL INCREDIBAL PIECES OF..."
Paul H.
Great place George was very nice and knowledgeable!
Purchased item
The Atocha Odyssey, Hardcover
"George was awesome and recommended both books..."
Raffaela P.
The sales staff ( unfortunately l cant remember the girls name ). She was wonderful. Very helpful and very knowledgeable You could tell she loved her job
Purchased item
Margarita Coin G4 4R #82M-10944-1
"l wear it proudly when l go out
and l get..."
Billy D.
Zero sales pressure. Just information and the history behind each piece I looked at.
Purchased item
El Cazador Coin HR #EC-21460
"Absolutely love this store. The history is a..."
Mindy E.
Always knowledgeable and friendly.
Purchased item
Atocha Re-creation Coin Pendant 4 Reales Double Prong in Sterling Silver
"My husband wears it daily!"
David C.
They were very helpful people there, will visit again if I ever go to Key West again.
Purchased item
El Cazador Coin 8R #EC-34137
"Beautiful coin with a great history behind it..."
David M.
Was very impressed by the knowledge of the sales reps
Purchased item
Treasure Coins of the Atocha and Margarita Anniversary Edition by Carol Tedesco
"I love having a piece of the Atocha history"
Matt B.
World renowned
Purchased item
Atocha Re-creation Coin Pendant 8 Reales Double Prong in Sterling Silver CP-8R-DP
"I waited 15 years to get my coin I wanted to..."
Paula J.
Very helpful & knowledgeable!
Purchased item
Mel Fisher Expedition "Dare" T-shirt #TS-DARE
"Giving as a gift and I’m sure it will be a bi..."
Beth K.
Thank you!
Purchased item
The Search for the Atocha
"Amazing story, enjoyed the read very much!!"
Felicia D.
I love my piece just what I was looking for
Purchased item
Taffi Fisher Collection 8 Reales Atocha Re-creation Silver Coin Double Prong, Cross Side
"The experience was flawless"
Mark A L.
Enjoyed the experience
Purchased item
Atocha Coin G2 8R #85A-184135
"Great service. Knowledgeable, interesting and..."
Matthew D.
I live in key largo
I would like to know if I ever drive down to key west do you offer a cleaning at your store?
Purchased item
Sterling Silver 6mm Anchor Chain
"The chain was better than the photo
Made my A..."
Scott B.
Thank you!
Purchased item
Taffi Fisher Collection 2 Reales in 14k gold Single Prong, Shield Side
"Everyone loves it! Including me!"
Michael Q.
Bbs
Purchased item
Mel Fisher Baseball Hat "Today's the Day" on the side
"Perfect !!"
Patricia C.
I’ve bought several items and they have been very helpful with returns and exchanges. They have always been very helpful.
Purchased item
Sterling Silver Olive Blossom Ring Spanish Galleon Shipwreck Re-creation
"We bought these beautiful rings for wedding r..."
Megan B.
Mel Fisher, you have a great team leading your legacy!
Purchased item
Sterling Silver Anchor Chain
"We had the honor of meeting Captain Drake out..."
Mark D.
Arrived earlier than expected.
Purchased item
Atocha Re-creation Coin Earrings, 1/2 Reale in Sterling Silver, with green stone
"My daughter loved them."
Larry M.
It was nice to meet Mark S and great to have his guidance & knowledge.
Purchased item
Silver Decorative Ring
"Lost a wedding band snorkeling on the reef, n..."
Christine S.
Very nice.
Purchased item
Re-Creation Half Reale Coin Ring, Copper and Sterling Silver
"Had had compliments on it."
Adrian M.
Very nice people in the store and they explain with details all artefacts and coins.
Purchased item
Atocha Re-creation Coin Black Weave Leather Bracelet
"Great item and having a small piece of histor..."
Richard B.
The quality of the pendant was excellent, the shipping fast, good experience all the way around.
Purchased item
Tales of the ATOCHA - Atocha Re-creation Coin Pendant in 14K Gold Mount
"The quality of the pendant meet and exceeds m..."
Richard W.
Your customer service is great, your books, t-shirts, and especially the silver pendants, are awesome.
Purchased item
Taffi Fisher Collection 4 Reales Atocha Re-creation Silver Coin, Double Prong, Cross Side
"I purchased my first Atocha replica coin pend..."
Rossi L.
Friendly staff
Purchased item
Tales of the ATOCHA - Atocha Re-creation Small Coin Pendant in Silver Mount
"My daughter loves it !"
Michele S.
The gentleman who helped me was very kind
Purchased item
Silver Compass Rose Earrings
"My sterling silver compass rose earrings are..."
James S.
Great service at Mel Fisher’s Treasures. Very friendly people.
Purchased item
El Cazador Coin 8R #EC-25120101
"Very nice friendly service at Mel Fisher’s Tr..."
Bruce C.
They Try to describe what you can’t see over the phone in all honesty. A few items I purchased of the last two years have always been better than expected.
Purchased item
Admiral Gardner Coin
"They try very hard to ship things the same da..."
Tina H.
Susan is patient and a joy to work with!
Purchased item
Atocha Coin G3 4R #85A-189226
"Love my coin, but I would still like a Grade..."
Deborah M.
Skip is a great asset to your business. He’s knowledgeable and has been on treasure dives, so he was fascinating to learn from about the Mel Fisher history. He also has a friendly and welcoming demeanor. We enjoyed meeting him.
Purchased item
Taffi Fisher Collection Re-creation Silver Cross
"Beautiful workmanship.
Love the symbolism wit..."
MFST store reviewsVisit store