Masters of Mystery Reviews

Masters of Mystery ReviewsSee store reviews

Customer photo review of Pirate Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit

Robin S.

We had the very best time! Loving on Fernandina Beach and sharing in the shrimp festival that takes place each year where pirates and shrimp run amuck! The murder mystery was the piece de resistance to end our weekend of fun and frolic- costumes were worn, accents were adapted, and the murder did get solved! Thank you for a delightful time !

Pirate Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit

Customer photo review of Christmas Murder Mystery Host Your Own Dinner Party Game Kit

Nicole T.

We had soooo much fun with this for our work Christmas party!!! I would totally recommend doing this with a close, fun, group of people. Everyone really got into their character and we laughed so hard.

Christmas Murder Mystery Host Your Own Dinner Party Game Kit

Customer photo review of Expansion Pack - Host Your Own 1980s Murder Mystery Game Kit

Michele H.

We all had a blast! Pretty big group- love thY we can play it again. This is the 3rd MM we have purchased from this company. Highly recommend. You can get as Far into character or just play for fun

Expansion Pack - Host Your Own 1980s Murder Mystery Game Kit

Customer photo review of A Christmas Crime Murder Mystery Game Kit

Cp&ea B.

We had 8 people, assigned roles, and really encouraged our family members to get into character. Almost all we're able to. The most difficult part was getting started and knowing WHAT to read, and thus created a short amount of confusion. Otherwise, lotsa laughs!

A Christmas Crime Murder Mystery Game Kit

Customer photo review of James Bond Spy Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit

Emily B.

This kit truly made my 30th birthday such a hilarious and wonderful ride. Everyone raved about their characters and it was super helpful to have the murderer randomly selected after all my guests arrived. In sum, treat yourself to the ease of having everything ready to go for you.

James Bond Spy Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit

Customer photo review of 1980s Murder Mystery Game Kit

Aimee R.

I go to a retreat every year for moms who have kids with Down syndrome. I usually find a haunted pub crawl in the town we are in but this year it was pretty remote so a couple of us said that we should keep it spooky with a murder mystery party. We had SO MUCH FUN! The script was a blast, everyone came in character and costume, and the game was mysterious enough that the person running it all was also playing! I cannot recommend this game enough!

1980s Murder Mystery Game Kit

Customer photo review of Expansion Pack - Midnight on the Orient Express - An Agatha Christie Themed Murder Mystery

Jeannine M.

We took the few suggestions for costume and went overboard! The questions and character traits were fun to play with. We were a little sad that it couldn't really be "solved" because all of us had motive and the murder was a random pick, but we quickly got over that because it was so much fun:)

Expansion Pack - Midnight on the Orient Express - An Agatha Christie Themed Murder Mystery

Customers playing the 1920s Murder Mystery Game Kit at a party, dressed in fun costumes and holding character sheets.

Amy C.

We did Murder Mystery as a going away party for my daughter and it was a HUGE success! Everyone had so much fun! Thank you for helping us make these fabulous memories!

1920s Murder Mystery Game Kit

Customer collage of nine people in elaborate Victorian costumes for the Sherlock Holmes Murder Mystery Game.

Kassondra B.

We got this for a milestone birthday party!! It was a huge success. One of our guests played the role as detective which really made it even better. Everyone acted their roles and we gave away prizes for best costume and best performer!! Worth every penny!! I loved The suggested food options and even the Spotify playlist. We had 19 active roles (1 being the detective) and only 2 guests did not dress up. Such fun. Highly recommend!!!

Sherlock Holmes Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit

Bria B.

sooo much fun! there’s a great variety of characters, all of my friends felt represented accurately by the character i picked for them. i love that the killer is randomized and the motives are solid. the detective recordings are a bit wacky but it added to the fun.

1980s Murder Mystery Game Kit

Donna E.

We brought the game on our family vacation, we all had our character assignment ahead of time so we could bring our costumes with us. It was a fun time for all!

Pirate Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit

A group of reviewers in costume posing together while playing the Ancient Egypt Murder Mystery Game.

Saleem A.

Our group thoroughly enjoyed the Death in the Desert game. With 12 characters playing, the directions and support materials made it easy to keep on track. The host was able to play one of the characters as well.

Ancient Egypt Murder Mystery Game Kit

A group of customers in colorful 80s costumes posing for a photo while playing the Murder Mystery Game.

Calli B.

This was a lot of fun. The guide was easy to follow. It was very costly to print out all the packets though. The guide does say the host or an assistant needs to know who the killer is. We did it without someone knowing. We did not pre assign letters and it was a blind Pull. Everyone knew if they forgot their letter they messed up the game for everyone.

1980s Murder Mystery Game Kit

Customers in masquerade masks and elegant gowns posing together while playing the Murder Mystery Game Kit.

Jane D.

We hired a house for my daughters birthday,the murder mystery game was brilliant we also hired a private chef and had a 3 course meal whilst playing the game.

Masquerade Ball/Carnival Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit

Customer's elegant party table set for the 1920s Murder Mystery Game, with gold chargers and a character name card.

Maria E.

We’ve never thrown a better party. I was so pleased with the ease of use with the digital files, I was able to print only what I needed. I appreciated the Spotify playlist that had been curated and included as well as the dinner recommendations. It was definitely the experience that I was hoping it would be. The characters and plot were not raunchy or crude, and everyone was able to enjoy. We had ten guests, all over 35. It was just the right size for us. It ended up taking 2.5-3 hours, includi...

1920s Murder Mystery Game Kit

Customer's clue board for the Circus Murder Mystery Game Kit, showing character cards connected by red string.

Karlien M.

It was the perfect theme for a Sweet 16 party! The bunch of teenagers' thoroughly enjoyed it and really surprised me throughout the whole game. It was fun and definitely would do another one.

Circus Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit

Customers play the Masquerade Murder Mystery game at a party, wearing fun masks and costumes around a decorated table.

Sara M.

Sweet 16 turned murder mystery- kids had a blast with the game- we amplified the process with custom notebooks and invites based on the script and items bought. The kids dressed up and had fun.

Masquerade Ball/Carnival Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit

Customer photo review of Halloween Murder Mystery Game Kit - Vampire Ball - 4 - 20 Players / English

Emma C.

We played The Vampire Ball murder mystery for my daughter's 18th birthday. It was definitely a hit! The guests loved dressing up for the vampire theme and the provided scripts made it easy for everyone to play. Having the short videos at the start of each round was great too. I would definitely recommend this murder mystery.

Halloween Murder Mystery Game Kit - Vampire Ball - 4 - 20 Players / English

Customer photo review of Wild West Cowboy Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit

Jodi O.

With only 6 of us at our family get together, I thought it would be challenging to play the game. However, it was AMAZING! It worked great for just 6 of us.....so much fun. We actually played it twice, with everyone picking a different character. So much FUN!! And super easy to follow the directions and to customize it to fit your needs!

Wild West Cowboy Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit

Lizzie C.

Great experience: I messed up my purchase and they were very quick and helpful in fixing the problem. Great fun, everyone loves dressing up and it made for a ridiculously fun time. Recommend!!

Expansion Pack - Host Your Own 1980s Murder Mystery Game Kit

Customer photo review of 1940s Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit

Valerie T.

We had a blast! Took about 2 hours - perfect party length. Other reviews gave the tip to read through your character's info in advance (even though the guidelines say not to), and we did that. Knowing the backstory in advance was helpful for understanding your character and really having fun with the acting. Had a great time - we'll do it again!

1940s Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit

Customer photo review of Masquerade Ball/Carnival Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit

Grace T.

This was so much fun! This is my second time buying from Masters of Mystery. It was really great except that too many people can get a bit confusing. Nevertheless, it was fun and I’ll definitely do it again!

Masquerade Ball/Carnival Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit

Reviewer's group of friends in fun costumes posing for a photo during the 1980s Murder Mystery Game.

Angie T.

This was such a fun night with good friends. All took a lot of interest in our characters. The food was awesome! 80’s menu; pizza rolls, man-which (which I always calling it mam-which!), tuna noodle casserole and pac man cupcakes. Going to do the trailer trash mystery camping this summer! Thanks for the fun time!

1980s Murder Mystery Game Kit

Customer's table with 1940s props for the Murder Mystery Game Kit, including a vintage phone and Oscar-style trophy.

Magda S.

We all had an amazing time together ❤️ Everyone really engaged with the role and we had such a incredible experience and of course at the end The Butler did it🤣

1940s Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit

Customer photo review of 1920s Murder Mystery Game Kit

Victoria M.

Fabulous night and experience, the pack and instructions were set up brilliantly so everyone knew what they were doing. It was helpful to have hints for what to wear, the props were a great touch. You can reuse the game over and over again as the killer changes each time. I was the host and still managed to play and didn't know who the killer was so it works really well. I had an issue and had to contact the team and they replied instantly and were very helpful. Highly recommend. ❤️

1920s Murder Mystery Game Kit

Customer photo review of Sherlock Holmes Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit

Daria C.

I planned this whole game for my dads birthday. His birthday came and we played it together. My big sister and her husband had to play it through zoom but we had a blast. I played the detective. my mom ended up being the murder. But we laughed and had alot of fun.

Sherlock Holmes Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit

Richard W.

I wanted to try a new game for our family nights. So, I sent out invitations in advanced, let my family know about the prizes, costumes, and fun, and threw a 1920's style dinner party. Everyone LOVED getting into character, dressing up, and trying to solve the murder! The characters were well developed, the concept was fun, and this game is something you can play again because the murderer can always change. If you are looking for a fun, new game, I HIGHLY recommend this!

1920s Murder Mystery Game Kit

Adam S.

Easy to implement and pretty well thought of. Great effort in planning and preparing the game. Good for a small and cosy group and of course everyone loved the dressing up part!

1920s Murder Mystery Game Kit

Customer photo review of Wizarding Murder Mystery Game Kit

Jennifer K.

Through my daughter a surprise party for her 18th. I played Host and School Elf Detective we all had so much fun. Everyone really got into their characters! The only thing I wish I had the other 6 characters to choose from. And their wasn't any female yellow house roles. But other than that we all loved it!

Wizarding Murder Mystery Game Kit

Miriam G.

It was so nice to find a murder mystery game that catered for four people. Thoroughly enjoyed it. We did this to celebrate a birthday. We usually go out for a meal, but this was much better, we had our meal whilst playing the game😊

1920s Murder Mystery Game Kit

Customer video review of Replay-able Cowboy Wild West Murder Mystery Dinner Game for Up to 20 Adults - Host Your Own Dinner Party Game Night - Cowboy & Wild West Theme - Cowboy Fancy Dress Dinner PartyV2

Rebecca M.

I used the kit for a social party and it is a great starting point with a lot of stories to springboard off of but I definitely had to modify for a social environment along with adding characters over 20.

Replay-able Cowboy Wild West Murder Mystery Dinner Game for Up to 20 Adults - Host Your Own Dinner Party Game Night - Cowboy & Wild West Theme - Cowboy Fancy Dress Dinner PartyV2

Sallyann B.

We had a great time but it did need a lot of organising. In the end I played the sheriff and hosted the event which worked out well. I laminated the evidence sheets which worked well too. Good fun despite no one working out the killer!!

Wild West Cowboy Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit

Customer photo review of Fantasy Medieval Themed Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit

Dawn E.

We had a group of 17 searching out the murderer, the group all got into their roles and the characters were a blast!! Everyone had fun , the odd quip here and there was great. We had one person play the role of the King too, they did not want to take part in the Mystery part, but they enjoyed reading out the information between the rounds, it made the event more interactive. Everyone enjoyed themselves, the costumes were amazing and some of the actors were great in their characters!!

Fantasy Medieval Themed Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit

Kristie S.

It was a great experience with all 20 roles filled! Gregor Greenbeard and Ryan Ville are not in the picture but a couple small pirates are in their place. It didn’t take near as long as I thought it would. We ate, did rounds 1 and 2 stopped for dessert, did round 3, voting and I gave prizes in 2hours. Guests with characters ages 10 to 55 all had a blast! 18/20 got really into costume and some went above and beyond! I gave prizes for best costume and best actor and small prizes for those who spok...

Pirate Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit

Yuvraj S.

If ur feeling hesitant about buying it… lemme reassure you. It’s nuts how fun this was! While there were some typos and some lack of info here and there, this is definitely the right investment for ur next party (as long as everyone stays in character and dresses up!) You’re welcome!

1980s Murder Mystery Game Kit

Frances C.

this was such a fun and easy party! we all went into it not knowing what to expect but it turned out to be a huge hit, we're definitely going to find any excuse to throw more murder mystery parties

Wild West Cowboy Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit

Customer photo review of Bridgerton & Jane Austen Themed Murder Mystery Game Kit

Janet S.

We played this at my granddaughter's 17th birthday party. It was a literary romance tea party. She and her friends dressed and acted their parts. It was amazing! The kids did a great job! Would highly recommend.

Bridgerton & Jane Austen Themed Murder Mystery Game Kit

Mikayla H.

We had such a fun time with this Harry Potter spin off mystery! Such a fun way to celebrate my 30th birthday! Even though only a handful of the guests were Harry Potter fans, everyone enjoyed playing the game and getting into character. It was also a fun way to have a party where not everyone knew each other beforehand. Would definitely do this again!

Wizarding Murder Mystery Game Kit

Louise D.

So much fun!! Highly recommend. Everything was provided, how to play the game was explained well and the characters were all described well. Everyone enjoyed dressing up and Everyone had a fantastic night.

James Bond Spy Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit

Jacqui G.

All together we have done about a dozen murder mystery parties over the years. We had such a fun time with this one and keen to order more from your website. This murder mystery is great because if people cancel it’s not a big deal. In todays day and age that is a real win. Only down side is if you are the murderer, The information about what to say was on the next page, so we had to be sneaky and pretend like we were looking on both pages so others didn’t know if we were the murderer. Absolute...

Sherlock Holmes Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit

Masters of Mystery ReviewsVisit store