Masters of Mystery Reviews

Masters of Mystery ReviewsSee store reviews

Customer photo review of The Art of Murder - An art Heist Murder Mystery Game Kit

Heather S.

Very well written murder mystery. We are experienced in the genre and thought this was the best one we had seen. Multiple story lines and activities for participants. The highlight were three hilarious movies produced for the game. There was quite a bit of prep work, but was worth it. Made for a very memorable and fun party!

The Art of Murder - An art Heist Murder Mystery Game Kit

Customer photo review of 1920s Murder Mystery Game Kit

Betty M.

Great evening! Costumes, decor and food was amazing. Recommend with food if your playing or hosting have it catered or outsourced. Would be great if Chartier scripts could be printed in booklet style. Can’t wait to do it again with my daughters 29 birthday party!

1920s Murder Mystery Game Kit

Customer photo review of Replay-able Cowboy Wild West Murder Mystery Dinner Game for Up to 20 Adults - Host Your Own Dinner Party Game Night - Cowboy & Wild West Theme - Cowboy Fancy Dress Dinner PartyV2

Marlene R.

Our 40 Something Cowgirl equestrian group played and everyone had a great time. Feel free to go to my Facebook page and see all the pictures and videos. I have to say it was a huge hit and everyone really got into it.

Replay-able Cowboy Wild West Murder Mystery Dinner Game for Up to 20 Adults - Host Your Own Dinner Party Game Night - Cowboy & Wild West Theme - Cowboy Fancy Dress Dinner PartyV2

Customer's large family group posing in cowboy costumes for the Wild West Murder Mystery game.

Kim E.

We had a great family evening and everyone dressed up for the occasion which made it more fun. The game and instructions were all good and easy to follow along. As the host I joined in with the game trying to determine who murdered Deputy Drinkwater!

Wild West Cowboy Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit

Customers in 80s costumes playing the Murder Mystery Game Kit around a long decorated table.

Wendi M.

Absolutely loved the 80’s themed murder mystery for my birthday party! I got a private room at a restaurant to eliminate any catering stress, and it was so fun and different. Everyone played along and dressed up and laughed all night long! Super easy for beginners - I had never hosted a murder mystery before and everything was planned out perfectly. (You will need a printer, though! Lots of things to print out - I just used my work printer lol) Thanks Masters of Mystery!!

Expansion Pack - Host Your Own 1980s Murder Mystery Game Kit

Customer photo review of 1980s Murder Mystery Game Kit

Hannah J.

The pack was super easy to use. I printed off everything and put it in envelopes. I added in some puzzles that had to be done to reveal the evidence. Everyone got dressed up and really into it. They all had a blast. It was my 38th birthday party and I swear was my best party since childhood. Good, clean fun! I had ten people over and I just moderated the evening. It was perfect. I gave out awards at the end, and like I said everyone had a blast. I've already bought another murder mystery for nex...

1980s Murder Mystery Game Kit

Customer photo review of Bridgerton & Jane Austen Themed Murder Mystery Game Kit

Abigail S.

We loved the Bodgerton game! I bought the game for a sweet sixteen and we had 14guests. The teens really got into it and I know they enjoyed dressing for the party! Prefectly appropriate for our purposes.

Bridgerton & Jane Austen Themed Murder Mystery Game Kit

Chloe T.

My daughter and friends had a brilliant time at her 80’s themed birthday murder mystery party!! This game is absolutely worth every penny, brilliantly created, easy to follow and so much fun! It took around 2 hours to complete but really cool having the videos to play in between which added something different we’ve not had before at other murder mystery parties!! Would definitely recommend!!

1980s Murder Mystery Game Kit

Chelsea B.

We had a blast. The 80s pack was so much fun to dress for and the slag was fun too. My group was committed to their customers and characters. 3/7 of us guessed the correct murderer. We would buy another pack. Pro tip: I made a slide show to help me keep the game flow moving and I embedded the videos and evidence with instructions for each round. It helped me relax into my character rather than focusing on hosting.

1980s Murder Mystery Game Kit

Customer photo review of Wild West Cowboy Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit

Shanin A.

This was a lot of fun! Everyone came ready to play their character. The different rounds flowed perfectly. Everyone had their scripts on their phone or tablet for easy game play. We had a fun evening of laughs and great food!

Wild West Cowboy Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit

Customer photo review of Wizarding Murder Mystery Game Kit

Danielle F.

We love Masters Of Mystery! We’ve used them for two years now and have loved how organized everything is. Everyone gets into the theme and the storytelling is so fun. Will definitely do it again.

Wizarding Murder Mystery Game Kit

Customer's close-up of a piece of orange farm machinery on the ground.

Timothy R.

It went great, however, I purchased the 4 -14 player version but only received 13 character files. Those that I did not receive were: Buffalo Bob, Shuffle N Cut, Songbird Lil, Tiny Musack, Waylin Strum, Wellesley Fargo and Yella Rose. It seems that I should have received one of these.

Wild West Cowboy Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit

Customer video review of Halloween Murder Mystery Game Kit - Vampire Ball

Alexandrea C.

We had an absolute blast . The game came with food, drink,music,and even costume suggestions! It was perfect for halloween! What a great way to get a group together and laugh all night ! We're doing another in a few months for another friends birthday ,just because we had so much fun!

Halloween Murder Mystery Game Kit - Vampire Ball

Reviewer dressed in a 1920s costume with suspenders and a fedora for the murder mystery game.

Kailee G.

Such a fun way to switch things up at party. The more people dress up and get into character the more fun it is to play. Would definitely host a murder mystery party again.

1920s Murder Mystery Game Kit

Customer photo review of Replay-able 1920s Murder Mystery Dinner Party Game for Up to 20 Adults - Host Your Own Dinner Party Game Night - 1920s Speakeasy Gatsby Theme - 1920s Fancy Dress Dinner Party(V2)

Carol M.

My friends really got into character and went all out on costumes. We had a blast. Guessing the murderer is really all in the acting. We had 4/14 guess correctly. Everyone had so much fun.

Replay-able 1920s Murder Mystery Dinner Party Game for Up to 20 Adults - Host Your Own Dinner Party Game Night - 1920s Speakeasy Gatsby Theme - 1920s Fancy Dress Dinner Party(V2)

Customer photo review of Pirate Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit

David K.

We had a great time from beginning to end. All the characters were expertly described in the materials. I was able to do a decent job bringing Blasio Fortuna to life. The participants got into the costumes big time. We also had a professional do some great pira te decor. Thank you for the great game.

Pirate Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit

Customers playing the Wine Tasting Murder Mystery Game at a fun, candlelit birthday party.

Rachel W.

Very fun and lots of room for improv!! We got so into our characters it took 4 hours to get through, I’m sure if you’re focused it’d go much quicker. But everyone had a great time and the characters were funny

A Wine Tasting Themed Murder Mystery Game Kit

Victoria T.

What a fantastic evening! We had the wine and cheese murder mystery and it was soooo much fun! The instructions were super easy to follow and everyone had a good time! Thankyou! 🙏🏻😁

A Wine Tasting Themed Murder Mystery Game Kit

Customer's garage transformed into an Egyptian temple for the murder mystery game, with a long decorated table.

Chelsey M.

This was such a fun kit! Everyone had such a good time and are looking forward to the next great murder mystery. We needed some help from the company and they were so quick to respond and extremely kind. I would 100% recommend them! I also loved that they had food suggestions, music suggestions, and decor suggestions. It made planning so much easier. We transformed the garage into an Egyptian temple and it was the perfect setting and mood for an amazing night!

Expansion Pack - Ancient Egypt Themed Murder Mystery Game Kit

Customer photo review of Midnight on the Orient Express - An Agatha Christie themed murder mystery

Claire M.

We’ve played a lot of murder mysteries, but never one like this.we were on holiday and decided to do this with the kids. The audio files and evidence are great (we’ve only played old school murder mysteries) and the game itself was just the right time for the kids. We’re going to buy another for Christmas. I love that this can be reused over with a different murderer.

Midnight on the Orient Express - An Agatha Christie themed murder mystery

Jennifer B.

The packet was easy to use it was really fun seeing everyone get into character. We did the 9-14 and was a cool introduction to throwing murder mysteries. Won't be this groups last.

Pirate Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit

Customer video review of Expansion Pack - Host Your Own 1980s Murder Mystery Game Kit

Allison S.

I purchased this game for my Husband's surprise 40th Birthday party. He loves gaming and is also a big fan of puzzles (escape rooms and those brain teaser puzzles you have to take apart). Since he was born in the 80's and didn't like people saying "Happy 40th Birthday" I made the party an 80's gaming theme "Level 40 Unlocked". We only ate food available in the 80's (bummer for the gluten free peeps) put on the best 80's jams and spoke the lingo. The murder mystery was the coup de grace. Even tho...

Expansion Pack - Host Your Own 1980s Murder Mystery Game Kit

Victoria B.

Did a Western Murder Mystery for my 31st birthday to enable friends who had never met before to be able to mingle with less pressure! I served KFC, veggie chilli, corn bread and Mac n cheese alongside. Everyone had a great time and thanked me for a fun weekend. No one could be bothered to get changed before going out on the town so we descended upon the bars in our costumes and it was a hit!

Wild West Cowboy Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit

Customer photo review of 1940s Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit

Brianna S.

This was so much fun! For most people attending, it was their first murder mystery dinner party and everyone said how great it was! So much laughter, and was just the right amount of challenging, too! Highly recommend this! We will be doing another one in the future!

1940s Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit

Kelsey Z.

The whole night was magical! We transformed the whole house into Toad-wart School (a Harry Potter movie). We even had a whole feast! The game was so much fun and getting into the characters was even more fun!

Wizarding Murder Mystery Game Kit

Tiffany N.

My family and I did a pirate themed murder mystery! And we had an absolute blast!!!! This was our first time so we do look fwd to getting some of the kinks out for the next go round! Only one person guessed right so we are impressed that we were fooled! lol! Very well done!!!

Pirate Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit

Customer photo review of James Bond Spy Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit

Kimberly P.

We had a blast. It was the best party ever. Celebrating my son’s 21st birthday. Everybody wants me to host another. The best part was it’s all inclusive so we didn’t have to figure anything out. All we did was execute. Kudos.

James Bond Spy Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit

Angela H.

We did a 40s theme party for my 40th birthday and It was soooo much fun. I liked that I could lead the game and still participate. Instead of sending out the secret letters in advance for the drawing to choose the murderer we did a drawing that night. Everyone drew a letter and then put it back and then I pulled out the murderer’s letter. My only advice is that handwritten letters like H and I look like each other depending on the angle! So we sort of messed up the game (my fault!) but it was st...

1940s Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit

Joseph F.

What an amazing experience! The package was perfect and Everyone loved the 80s theme. Both adults and kids alike enjoyed the party. The links on the website helped me with decor and food ideas. Such fun. Highly recommend!

1980s Murder Mystery Game Kit

Evelyn R.

So much fun! With a small group, it does not take much time but all of my friends loved it. Make sure you get info out about it quickly so people have time for costumes!! I'm so happy with how it turned out!!

1920s Murder Mystery Game Kit

Sarah L.

Such a fun night! Loved that it was a complete mystery as to who did it. Really easy to follow and a fun story line. Love that characters can be male or female. Would probably give characters out in advance next time. Thanks!!

A Wine Tasting Themed Murder Mystery Game Kit

Isaac M.

Our Crew had the best time with the "Murder at a Wine Tasting". We made lots of delicious food, I was the host and still got to play in the game! We will very likely get another one to do in the future!

A Wine Tasting Themed Murder Mystery Game Kit

Cindy S.

17 friends showed up out of 20 invited—hubby and I took parts. Unable to get sheriff’s part to play on computer so read it myself. Six people guessed the muderer correctly.

Wild West Cowboy Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit

A reviewer's child in a fun pirate costume with a large beard for the Kids Murder Mystery Game Kit party.

Ashley S.

My daughter had such a fun 11th birthday with her friends. Her friends understood the assignment. They came dressed in character and ready to solve the mystery at the museum.

Kids Murder Mystery Game Kit - Mystery At The Museum

Erica G.

We had so much fun! We ordered this package for a Work event and everything was perfect! We ordered the download version, was able to print everything out easily and use the videos for extra fun! Will definitely do this again! I recommend for everyone, so easy and so fun!

1920s Murder Mystery Game Kit

Customer photo review of Independence Day / BBQ Themed Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit

Michael H.

We had a great time playing and everyone participated. I took pictures of each guest with the skewer. At the end I revealed murder by casting it on the tv. Not sure how you could incorporate stations to folks to review evidence. The q&a was great but a couple of folks found a pattern in the responses that allowed them to accurately pick out the murder. We look forward to playing the next one. If you have suggestions for a slightly more difficult murder mystery please let me know.

Independence Day / BBQ Themed Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit

Donna W.

After some initial downloading issues, which were eventually sorted I managed to download several files for the up to 14 people game. We played the 80’s murder mystery for 9 of us, we all got into character, with some slight personal tweaks on the costumes. It was a fabulous evening and despite some confusion on what to read, play, listen at the various stages, we all had an amazing time, Just to point out some of the character files were differently laid out, again this created some delays in...

1980s Murder Mystery Game Kit

Frank B.

This Bond/Casino theme was great! We purchased some props and everybody was very creative with their characters, making it a lot of fun. Everyone caught onto the flow of the game easily and everyone stayed in character (most of time). It was a great game and we plan to do it again next summer (different theme). Give it a try!

James Bond Spy Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit

Customer photo review of Masquerade Ball/Carnival Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit

Lisa P.

The group of teens had a lot of fun! It was great and the game was easy to follow. Everything you need is provided ie. Scripts for each character, costume ideas, tips on playing, etc. and the BEST part is it can be played over and over again using different characters (I also bought the extension package for up to 15 players)! I’m going to buy another game for us adults to play!! Highly recommend!

Masquerade Ball/Carnival Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit

Danielle L.

This game was awesome! I purchased it for my aunt's 60th birthday and everyone got so into it! I was concerned that no one would guess who the murderer was but someone figured it out - but it wasn't too easy, which I was also worried about. Easily one of the best parties I've ever hosted!

Pirate Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit

Masters of Mystery ReviewsVisit store