Masters of Mystery Reviews - 1,412 Reviews | mastersofmystery.com

Masters of Mystery Reviews

undefined review of 1920s Murder Mystery Game Kit image 1 out of 5+4
Kelsey D.
Had a great time with 16 guests! I had a couple questions and emailed the support line with an immediate response and they were so friendly! Will purchase the next set from here for our annual murder mystery party!
1920s Murder Mystery Game Kit
undefined review of Halloween Murder Mystery Game Kit - Monster Mansion image 1 out of 2+1
Becky U.
I hosted a murder mystery dinner party for my birthday this year using the Monster Mansion kit. We had a big group playing -18 of us-and everyone had a blast. We let people pick their characters in advance and then had all other materials available when they arrived. Loved that it required minimal prep from participants and that the host could play as well. My friends are still taking about it! The game took us the full 2.5 hours from start to finish. Beware-it’s a lot of printing! I would absol...
Halloween Murder Mystery Game Kit - Monster Mansion
undefined review of Wild West Cowboy Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit image 1 out of 5+4
Krista G.
This was an amazing surprise for my husband’s 40th birthday party! We had him blindfolded and brought to a coffee house where we had the whole western saloon murder mystery party set up. It was so easy to learn and fun to play! Thank you for making his 40th extra special! (We had guests choose their character upon arrival, and that still worked out well!)
Wild West Cowboy Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit
undefined review of Masquerade Ball/Carnival Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit image 1 out of 5+4
Catherine S.
This was so fun! We played for my aunties 50th and initially I was panicking as the first round is basically reading and everyone looked a bit bored. However as we got into it and everyone knew their character a bit better, people started to improvise and really have a laugh with it. At the end, everyone was saying how much they enjoyed it! We teamed up characters and that worked too, I had one of the characters scripts as a host as the inspectors script isn’t the same and I was confused about w...
Masquerade Ball/Carnival Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit
undefined review of 1920s Murder Mystery Game Kit image 1 out of 4+3
Alisha L.
We had so so so much fun. A few people told me afterwards before the party they thought it was going to feel cheesy and forced but it wasn’t at all, everyone agreed. I think the mingling and rumor spreading everyone’s favorite part. We are planning the masquerade box for New Years! As the host it was really easy to plan. The best part was I could play and host and I didn’t even know who the murderer was. It was nice not knowing despite hosting. I’d say it was a 10/10
1920s Murder Mystery Game Kit
undefined review of Wild West Cowboy Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit image 1 out of 5+4
Alexandria S.
We had a fantastic time. The guide was easy to follow in creating a party plan, and the characters were hilarious. Everyone stayed in character. We added a few “side quest” games to keep the party going (poker tourney, award for pickpocketed money, etc).
Wild West Cowboy Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit
undefined review of Wild West Cowboy Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit image 1 out of 4+3
Ayla M.
We had the best time ever with this! I ended up assigning letters by having people draw them from a hat and then I drew a letter to assign the murderer that way no one had to know who the killer was. It was such a blast and all of my friends said they’d do it again!
Wild West Cowboy Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit
undefined review of 1980s Murder Mystery Game Kit image 1 out of 1
Pamela B.
We all had a great time! This was the second game we did and it was a hit! We had a lot of people dress up perfectly and had so much fun dressing up too! Looking forward to making this a usual thing we all do!
1980s Murder Mystery Game Kit
undefined review of Masquerade Ball/Carnival Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit image 1 out of 1
Wade B.
It was so much fun! We were very laid back about it, but it kept us engaged and very aware of all the rumors and going ons of our fellow guests. Even in such a small group we had a great time.
Masquerade Ball/Carnival Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit
undefined review of Pirate Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit image 1 out of 5+4
Denise C.
We decided to put on a Pirate Murder Mystery party for my husband's 60th bday. Thanks to Amazon, Spirit Halloween, and HalloweenCostume.com, we were able to re-create the village tavern and acquire costumes for all sizes. There were a total of 22 participants. I was the host and we made "Your Excellency Blasiou Fortuna (aka detective) part of the cast. Once we handed out the cast booklets, we also gave them a message in a bottle. This allowed them to mingle and act out to gain prizes. For e...
Pirate Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit
undefined review of Wild West Cowboy Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit image 1 out of 1
Karlie P.
Absolutely loved this murder mystery! Was so well done and so fun… can’t wait to do it again! Lots of good detail and everyone said it was one of the best murder mystery parties they had been too!
Wild West Cowboy Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit
undefined review of 1980s Murder Mystery Game Kit image 1 out of 5+4
Venessa J.
Wanted to throw a murder mystery party but had noooo idea where to start. I quickly realized it was outside of my range of effort, so I ordered this kit and it was great! It had all the info I needed and the guide was easy to follow- everyone had so much fun and asked about us doing it again next year!
1980s Murder Mystery Game Kit
undefined review of Halloween Murder Mystery Game Kit - Monster Mansion image 1 out of 5+4
Kyla C.
We hosted our murder mystery as a Halloween party. We created a FB event and let our guests decide whether to participate or not. Some opted to come as outcasts and enjoyed watching the rest of us play the game. Was a hit!
Halloween Murder Mystery Game Kit - Monster Mansion
undefined review of 1920s Murder Mystery Game Kit image 1 out of 1
Caitlin S.
We really enjoyed playing the 1920's murder mystery for my husband's birthday party! The game was well thought out and we all really enjoyed it! I wish we hadn't all sat down in a circle to play the game as it made the rumours round quite tricky but we know for next time! Looking forward to our next game!
1920s Murder Mystery Game Kit
undefined review of Wild West Cowboy Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit image 1 out of 1
Lauren B.
So much fun!! The way the murder is picked allows many times played. I had a problem with the amount of people coming to my party and needed to purchase an expansion, and the team was eager to help me. Highly recommend.
Wild West Cowboy Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit
undefined review of Pirate Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit image 1 out of 4+3
Christina L.
We had so much fun! There were 18 of us that joined in the fun! At the beginning of the night a few were shy but by round three everyone was was fully embracing their character! At the end of the night, only one person got the murderer right!! It was a blast! I can't wait to host another event!!
Pirate Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit
undefined review of 1920s Murder Mystery Game Kit image 1 out of 1
Kristen H.
This was my first time throwing a murder mystery party, so I knew absolutely nothing about the guidelines. Using the packet and instructions was sooooo easy! Everything went perfectly. We had a blast! It took us about 2 hours to complete the game.
1920s Murder Mystery Game Kit
undefined review of Exorcism & Asylum Halloween Murder Mystery Game Kit image 1 out of 5+4
Stacey B.
What a fun night! Everyone enjoyed it, it was easy to follow and we all got into our characters really well. The guides were super helpful and the game flowed so well! The group are looking forward to the next one!
Exorcism & Asylum Halloween Murder Mystery Game Kit
undefined review of A Wine Tasting Themed Murder Mystery Game Kit image 1 out of 1
Kristi O.
Had an absolute ball with this murder mystery. Most of us participated for the first time ever! Love the fact that I can reuse this game using different characters and a different murderer every time. Definitely worth buying the experience for up to 20 players.
A Wine Tasting Themed Murder Mystery Game Kit
undefined review of Bridgerton & Jane Austen Themed Murder Mystery Game Kit - 4 - 8 Players / English image 1 out of 1
Fiona B.
It wasn’t as easy as getting one of these games in a box as it is all done on computer etc, however once we read it having drank a fair bit of wine we thought it was great will order another one for chrimbo
Bridgerton & Jane Austen Themed Murder Mystery Game Kit - 4 - 8 Players / English
undefined review of 1920s Murder Mystery Game Kit - 4 - 14 Players / English image 1 out of 1
Customer
We had a fabulous 1920s Murder Mystery Sweet 16 Dinner Party! I’d share a dozen pictures if I could. (It only let me select 1) 7 girls total and I (mama) was their host Jay Glittersby. Our guests arrived dressed for the occasion. We had a photo shoot at our balloon arch, mingled and then sat down for dinner. We did a fancy table set up. I made the cloth napkins & floral arrangements myself, already had cute glasses and black cloth tablecloths. I borrowed my moms China and my friends sequin table...
1920s Murder Mystery Game Kit - 4 - 14 Players / English
undefined review of 1920s Murder Mystery Game Kit image 1 out of 1
Pamela B.
This was our first Mystery game and we had so much fun! Everyone dressed to the nines! Decorating was so fun for this one! We all played our parts so well. Very fun!
1920s Murder Mystery Game Kit
undefined review of Wizarding Murder Mystery Game Kit image 1 out of 1
Corinne H.
The students at our teen center loved the game. (I have more photos I could share). I was impressed at how well they were able to follow the clues…and how excited they were about their certificates. Thanks!
Wizarding Murder Mystery Game Kit
undefined review of 1920s Murder Mystery Game Kit image 1 out of 1
Nicole H.
Such a great birthday surprise! The hostess planned who would be each character but the rest of us just showed up and jumped straight into the game. Everyone really went for it and we had a blast. The 1920s theme was great for costume options. Altogether a great option, especially if you're looking for little prep time.
1920s Murder Mystery Game Kit
undefined review of Masquerade Ball/Carnival Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit image 1 out of 1
Keeri L.
This was such a great game! I LOVE hosting parties, and I could not have expected a better way to celebrate my 30th birthday. I have already bought a Halloween game for this year and can't wait to buy even more!
Masquerade Ball/Carnival Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit
undefined review of Masquerade Ball/Carnival Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit image 1 out of 1
Alisa A.
When I realized the murderer was drawn out of a hat, I was afraid it was going to be a disappointing game, but it turned out to be really interesting and fun. I love that we can play it again with a different ending next time! The instructions were clear and easy to follow as were the scripts. It’s a very hassle free game!
Masquerade Ball/Carnival Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit
undefined review of Pirate Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit image 1 out of 1
Kristie S.
It was a great experience with all 20 roles filled! Gregor Greenbeard and Ryan Ville are not in the picture but a couple small pirates are in their place. It didn’t take near as long as I thought it would. We ate, did rounds 1 and 2 stopped for dessert, did round 3, voting and I gave prizes in 2hours. Guests with characters ages 10 to 55 all had a blast! 18/20 got really into costume and some went above and beyond! I gave prizes for best costume and best actor and small prizes for those who spok...
Pirate Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit
undefined review of Wild West Cowboy Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit image 1 out of 2+1
Kaitlin R.
We had a great experience with the High Noon @ Dead Mans Saloon! We had 20 players. The instructions were very easy to follow. I made sure I read everything all the way through prior to hosting. We played the game during a Thanksgiving dinner - it’s a perfect opportunity to use for Round 1!
Wild West Cowboy Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit
undefined review of Wild West Cowboy Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit image 1 out of 1
Samuel B.
31st birthday party and I had the best time!! Perfect for those who want to get drunk and have a laugh but also can’t bear to go clubbing anymore! Takes maybe an hour longer than estimated if you’re adding drinking games between rounds! You’ll regret it if you don’t buy. Never thought I’d be hosting a murder mystery but hey… on to the next one! (80’s)
Wild West Cowboy Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit
undefined review of Expansion Pack - Independence Slay/ BBQ Themed Murder Mystery Game Kit image 1 out of 1
George D.
Family trip of 14, ages 9-70 played and had a blast. This was a great activity for our dinner night and convenient theme for a beach Fourth of July celebration.
Expansion Pack - Independence Slay/ BBQ Themed Murder Mystery Game Kit
undefined review of Circus Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit image 1 out of 5+4
Leianne B.
Was such a great theme, we did a horror circus for Halloween went really well there was 16 players and we did it in around 3 hours including a 3 course meal. The only negative is that is only a download pack so there is a lot printing involved.
Circus Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit
undefined review of A Wine Tasting Themed Murder Mystery Game Kit image 1 out of 1
Laura C.
what an amazing activity to do with friends. I did this for my birthday! I had everyone dress up as their character and come dressed up in suits and floor length dresses. what an experience!!! we had wine and cheese (and some grape juice hahah) This activity took about 2 hrs and we were about 15 people. We had everyone's documents printed! finally for the end we had the best acting and best dressed win little statues like the oscars. if you are hesitating, don't just get it, honestly I think it ...
A Wine Tasting Themed Murder Mystery Game Kit
undefined review of 1920s Murder Mystery Game Kit image 1 out of 5+4
Cindy A.
We had a wonderful time, taking a step back in time. This mystery was a true mystery as we opted to do a random drawing to select murder. This game is so well put together and easy to follow. It was a rip roaring good time.
1920s Murder Mystery Game Kit
undefined review of Monarchy & Royal Family Coronation Party Themed Murder Mystery Game Kit image 1 out of 5+4
Kimble M.
Thank you! Thank you!! Thank you!!! This was months in the planning, as I began my list of potential suspects in May, but on Friday, October 13th, mayhem, murder and fun ensued, MUCH to everyone's delight! I secured a Lord Marshal, who took over our house as each suspect arrived at the palace, which you can see in the photos! I also had a butler added to the cast (Jay Guarr) who worked as an undercover Deputy Marshal!! I also devised a new way to randomly pick the murderer, so NO ONE would...
Monarchy & Royal Family Coronation Party Themed Murder Mystery Game Kit
undefined review of Wild West Cowboy Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit image 1 out of 1
Alyson D.
Bought for my Mam’s 70th Birthday. Had a great night and was able to send invites in advance so everyone could get in the spirit (which they did!) EXCEPTIONALLY quick response when I sent an email query after purchase - felt really pleased and would buy another game in future 🙂 thanks!
Wild West Cowboy Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit
undefined review of A Wine Tasting Themed Murder Mystery Game Kit image 1 out of 2+1
Mrs A.
I used this as a basis of my birthday party. There were 6 players and me! The game started slowly as I got used to instructions and timings. However once people got over their bemusement and got into their individual characters (given out randomly as they arrived with their alphabet letters starting with Z and working backwards!) they relaxed and started having fun together even though they didnt know each other to begin with! I LOVE the fact that the games are repeatable, adaptable to the g...
A Wine Tasting Themed Murder Mystery Game Kit
undefined review of Monarchy & Royal Family Coronation Party Themed Murder Mystery Game Kit image 1 out of 5+4
Sherri F.
This is the first time my family has ever done a murder mystery. This was an absolute blast. Everyone had a great time and the characters were so much fun. I absolutely love that you can play it again.
Monarchy & Royal Family Coronation Party Themed Murder Mystery Game Kit
undefined review of 1980s Murder Mystery Game Kit image 1 out of 1
Yuvraj S.
If ur feeling hesitant about buying it… lemme reassure you. It’s nuts how fun this was! While there were some typos and some lack of info here and there, this is definitely the right investment for ur next party (as long as everyone stays in character and dresses up!) You’re welcome!
1980s Murder Mystery Game Kit
undefined review of 1980s Murder Mystery Game Kit image 1 out of 1
Hannah C.
So much fun! Script was fun and easy to follow. Not too obvious, only one person guessed the killer. We played with only 5 people and it worked perfectly. Would definitely recommend adding in some karaoke like we did, such a great party :)
1980s Murder Mystery Game Kit
undefined review of Wild West Cowboy Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit image 1 out of 1
Frances C.
this was such a fun and easy party! we all went into it not knowing what to expect but it turned out to be a huge hit, we're definitely going to find any excuse to throw more murder mystery parties
Wild West Cowboy Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit
Masters of Mystery ReviewsMore details