Proof Syrup Reviews

undefined review of Traditional Proof Syrup image 1 out of 1

Ann K.

Although I purposed all the syrup choices, I’m kind of stuck (so far) on the traditional ... LOVE IT! I can make my own expert cocktail - don’t have to wait for the hubby to desire an old fashion - I just do it myself!! On a whim! So easy, so delicious - I’m my own expert mixologist - you made it so simple. LOVE IT!!

Traditional Proof Syrup

Mary M.

I purchased the Traditional syrup. Absolutely fantastic product. Takes the guesswork out of making THE perfect Old Fashioned and eliminates the needs for a bunch of different ingredients. If you can pour liquid, you too can make a great drink in record time. I'm sure eventually I'll try out some of the other drinks you can make with this syrup, maybe with my next bottle!

Traditional Proof Syrup

Derrick W.

I usually make my old fashioned using Maker's Mark which I found to be a good mix however I experimented and tried Basil Hayden's. It's a Caribbean Rye with a rum finish that gives my old fashioned a nice twist simply delicious.

Traditional Proof Syrup

undefined review of Pumpkin Spice Proof Syrup image 1 out of 1

Chris D.

These are hands down the best mixers on the market. After trying so many other brands, I was about to give up and go back to making them the old fashioned way. I'm so glad I found these and gave them a try. Worth every penny!

Pumpkin Spice Proof Syrup

Michelle P.

The traditional made the perfect old fashioned! Everyone took a drink and another and we all agreed, “This is good. This is really good.” Now my friends are each getting one for themselves.

Traditional Proof Syrup

Bryan S.

I really enjoy a well made Old Fashioned. The problem is I rarely get one that is well made. But this syrup is amazing! Consistently the best Old Fashioned and I make them myself at home. It's brilliant.

Traditional Proof Syrup

Marcia F.

I have to say that I was skeptical, but we’re big Old Fashioned fans in my house, so I figured we’d give Proof a shot to make the process a little quicker, neater, and easier. I’m happy to say that we are HOOKED!

Traditional Proof Syrup

Mary R.

One word to describe these...Delicious! I'm piticular when it comes to drinking. Cocktails have to taste good, very good! These Proof syrups give my Old Fashions 5 star status! I purchased the Traditional and Pecan. Love them both! I use Wild Turkey 101. Can't wait to try the Pumpkin next! Will order more for Xmas 🎁 Ordering/Shipping was fast and no broken bottles. Thank you Proof!! Happy customer

Traditional Proof Syrup

Jonathan F.

Love the traditional in old fashions with several of my bourbons and thought the pecan would be better with them too but, it isn’t near as good as the traditional. I love trying new bourbons and will try using the pecan with a few other ones in addition to some cooking recipes. That’s another hobby of mine.

Traditional Proof Syrup

Kevin L.

So good even Don Draper would make his Old Fashioned with Proof Syrup! Consistency is one of the keys to making good drinks and that’s exactly what you get with this mixer. Perfect drink every time.

Traditional Proof Syrup

undefined review of Maple Bacon Proof Syrup image 1 out of 1

Steve M.

The syrup gives me a nice break from my usual Black Manhattan - allowing me to make an easy, consistent and tasty Old Fashion. (Tip - the proper ratio of Proof Syrup to Bourbon is 1 Tablespoon of syrup to 1/4th of a cup of Bourbon.)

Maple Bacon Proof Syrup

Linda W.

This is the best Old Fashion I have ever made! In fact, its better than most bars make. I love the syrup, and I've sent a bottle to my sister for her birthday. Cheers@

Traditional Proof Syrup

Celeste P.

Maple Bacon is absolutely delicious!!!! We love it. I gave a bottle to both my sons, husband and friend. It’s smooth and is perfect as a winter drink with Bourbon. We will be ordering another bottle soon. It’s going to be a long cold winter!

Maple Bacon Proof Syrup

Tyler C.

Wow, I didn’t expect a “cocktail in a bottle” to taste like it was made at a bar. I have to give credit to Proof because they have perfected it. Much easier than making it with bitters and sugar, trying to get the right balance of proportions. Sometimes for a little different twist, I like putting 4-5 drops of orange bitters in mine to tone down the sweetness just a bit and add a little more depth of flavor.

Traditional Proof Syrup

Bob Fig N.

We are so happy with your product! So far just the original flavor but plan to try more. Always wanted to make GREAT Old Fashions and now I DO! Thanks, FIG NEWTON

Traditional Proof Syrup

Derik H.

I was surprised at how much I loved the taste of the Traditional Syrup. I am a former bar/restaurant manager and bartender and I’m a bit of a traditionalist when it comes to my Old Fashions...the ceremony of mixing, top shelf ingredients, etc. However, life is much busier and crazy these days this is exactly what the Dr. ordered. Quick, easy and tastes great! I can’t wait to try the other flavors and it gets colder and the seasons change.

Traditional Proof Syrup

Joe L.

I have been looking for a good drink and never really found one I really liked. Took a liking to Woodford Reserve but it needed something else to spice it up. Decided to give your product a try and I am hooked. I have never tasted anything so good. I will be honest, at my country club, well, they came close but failed when compared to how I make an Old Fashion using Proof Traditional Syrup. I also purchased Maple Bacon but have yet to try it. Once I do, I will let you know. Joe LaBelle

Traditional Proof Syrup

Jason N.

I tried Proof Syrup for the first time buying three bottles (Bacon, Pecan, and Traditional). I opened the Bacon first and love it! Using Proof Syrup makes a PERFECT Old Fashioned...every time in seconds! I am looking forward to sharing my discovery of Proof Syrup with my friends and family. I highly recommend trying Proof Syrup. Great job developing this amazing product. You have a fan here in the military in North Carolina!

Traditional Proof Syrup

undefined review of Pecan Proof Syrup image 1 out of 1

Matt H.

Proof syrup is absolutely amazing! My wife and I love to have an occasional cocktail or two, and the old fashion is by far OUR favorite and always go to drink of choice! Proof syrup makes this possible for us with not only phenomenal taste, but also with a lot less steps for prep than prior “PROOFless” nights. I’m forever thankful for discovering this product!

Pecan Proof Syrup

Jeff W.

I’ve had the pleasure of sharing the Maple Bacon with some of my co-workers. I didn’t tell them it was made with a cocktail syrup and they wondered how I mixed them up so quick.

Maple Bacon Proof Syrup

Brian G.

Couldn’t be happier, having tried Proof just on a whim off of an ad I saw. Great product, real flavors, nothing that tastes artificial in any way. Looking forward to trying more in this line. ✌🏻❤️🥃

Maple Bacon Proof Syrup

Adrian C.

It makes a really tasty cocktail but it doesn’t have any maple or bacon flavor at all. Just a standard old fashioned. I almost wonder if the bottle was mislabeled.

Maple Bacon Proof Syrup

Robert C.

Thirty seconds from heaven! I am a huge pumpkin fan and the pumpkin beer seems a little thin this year, so I tried this. So happy I bought three bottles of the stuff from the get go. The pumpkin flavor is just enough to know you are not drinking a normal Old Fashion. Highly recommend and I will be a repeat customer for this stuff!

Pumpkin Spice Proof Syrup

Paul M.

Hi, A 1to4 mix makes a delicious drink. My wife bought this deally-bopper for mixing salad dressing, (it was in the way and NEVER used, now it is in the way and ALWAYS being used)ice-shake and pour. Proof bottle went empty pretty fast so ordered more. Thank You, Paul

Traditional Proof Syrup

Tim S.

Shipping took forever (Not quite Proof’s fault, mail’s a mess right now) but it was worth the wait. The easiest, best tasting Old Fashioned I’ve ever had! Perfectly balanced, seems like it was made for Bulleit but I’d imagine it blends just as well with others.

Traditional Proof Syrup

David H.

Proof Syrup takes all the guesswork out of making a perfect Old Fashioned! 1oz of this magic stuff into a glass with your favorite bourbon and you are ready to enjoy! I can't wait to try the other flavors!

Traditional Proof Syrup

Aurora C.

All I can say is wow! I can’t get enough of this. I Love old Fashions and this mix is perfect! Had a friend try it and he ordered all three flavors. I will definitely be re-ordering. Cheers!

Traditional Proof Syrup

Paul R.

Easiest, best and most consistent way to make an Old Fashioned. I use a bar spoon of Maraschino cherry juice along with a cherry to top mine off. Great product!

Traditional Proof Syrup

Chau P.

What a nice way to end stressful work day by having an old fashioned that tastes just as good if not better than at a bar. This has been a daily staple and can’t wait to get another bottle!

Traditional Proof Syrup

Victoria E.

Proof Syrup is great! Such an awesome alternative for having to either make an old fashioned myself (read: do a terrible job) or go to a bar (which COVID has me scared to do). Makes great drinks and really get the bang for your buck! I started with Original but can’t wait to try the other flavors.

Traditional Proof Syrup

Ronda B.

Bought the Proof 3 pack as a Fathers Day Gift. It was a hit and he LOVES all 3 flavors. He said the old fashioned drinks he made were so good that it’s dangerous.

Traditional Proof Syrup

Charlie M.

I’m so glad I stumbled across Proof Syrup ads on social media. I injured my back recently, and my wife was sweet enough to mix up an Old Fashioned for me for my “medicine”. Wow, so good!

Traditional Proof Syrup

Joe D.

Proof Syrup was better than I expected. I go back and forth between Rye Whisky and Bourbon but 1/4oz of Proof Syrup does the trick! It's the perfect balance for sure.

Traditional Proof Syrup

Ryan B.

Can’t beat the simple perfection of a well done old fashioned. Proof does it right and makes it easy. 1/2 oz Proof, 2 oz bourbon, slice of orange. Enjoy!

Traditional Proof Syrup

Alex A.

As you will see in the photo, I was prepped to make my drink. What I wasn't ready for, was how much I was going to love the Pecan cocktail syrup. I am a old fashioned fan, and I think that goes without saying if I purchased these syrups. I was just so blown away how much it elevated my drink. I have my great whiskies (bourbons, rye and Irish), but the way it transformed Bullit Rye was just AWESOME! I absolutely will be purchasing the Pecan flavor over and over for my liquor cabinet.

Pecan Proof Syrup

Bonner C.

I have tried so many times to perfect the Old Fashion at home, I could never get it to taste just right like I experience from a drink professional. Proof Syrup has perfected it and makes entertaining the boys with Old Fashion’s effortless. Customer for life!

Traditional Proof Syrup

Nina F.

My husband is not much of a whiskey drinker. He prefers vodka. But he had enjoyed a maple bacon whiskey drink in a local restaurant once last year. He kept wishing he could buy some somewhere. When I saw your syrup online, I knew I had to get it for him. He mixed it in with some bourbon and really liked the flavor. I'm going to buy more for him for sure. Highly recommend.

Maple Bacon Proof Syrup

Jacob W.

This definitely lives up to the hype! I love a good Old Fashioned, but rarely made them myself due to the process. However, this is not only extremely quick and easy...it also tastes better than most Old Fashion drinks I get when I’m out to dinner.

Traditional Proof Syrup

Ayesha M.

the proof is in the pudding! or in this case - a delish old fashioned- so easy and always available at my home bar!! one less thing to mourn during Covidera

Traditional Proof Syrup

Enrico C.

I’ve paired the Proof Traditional Flavor, with Four Roses, Koval, and Evan Williams (all single barrel bourbons). I’m definitely a fan and already purchased my 2nd bottle. My only complaint is how long it takes to receive the order. All the more reason for me to order 3 bottles at a time, I guess. Proof Traditional Flavor gets two thumbs up from me!

Traditional Proof Syrup

Proof Syrup ReviewsMore details