Proof Syrup Reviews

undefined review of Traditional Proof Syrup image 1 out of 1

Roy L.

I was skeptical about Proof producing an amazing Old Fashioned. It is one of my favorite drinks but had not been successful replicating old fashioned’s I ordered at my favorite cocktail bar. But I was blown away by how perfect my first drink made with Proof turned out. So impressed, I have sent a bottle to three friends and will be ordering a couple more bottles for my self. A believer!!!

Traditional Proof Syrup

undefined review of Maple Bacon Proof Syrup image 1 out of 1

Aaron S.

I bought the original to try it out and loved it. I was very intrigued with the maple and bacon, but was scared to pull the trigger in case I didn't like it. I now wish I bought it sooner because I LOVE it! There is more maple than bacon flavor but I don't mind because I enjoy it sweeter. I have been using it with the Penelope Bourbon I also recently purchased, which pairs very well. It is so tasty and goes down so easy, this is now my go to drink. I will be purchasing more as soon as this gets ...

Maple Bacon Proof Syrup

Leona B.

Phenomenal, my husband is impressed too! He doesn’t usually like maple flavored anything but this didn’t have a deep maple taste and he loves it! I got both traditional and maple bacon, both are delicious, but I’d say the maple bacon is a touch sweeter.

Maple Bacon Proof Syrup

undefined review of Orange image 1 out of 1

Tom G.

Absolutely love this syrup. Made it for guests this weekend who raved about it and became new customers. My only criticism is how you offer additional discounts on adding to the order and when we do you charge additional shipping as if it is a separate order. Don’t care for that so much.

Orange

Richard F.

I initially order the Traditional just to experience the quality of Proof’s products. I was so impressed that I soon order their Traditional Master Set. The pic was taken when we had dinner guests. They loved the Traditional Old Fashions and ordered their own. But it gets better. A week later I made Maple Bacon Old Fashions for friends and OMG, they said it was the best mixed drink they ever had.

Traditional Proof Syrup

undefined review of Old Fashioned Cocktail Syrup Mini Set image 1 out of 1

Teresa S.

This delectable drink was made with Black Walnut and Woodford Reserve in my new glass that reads, "Call me Old Fashioned" that I got for Christmas! I LOVE Proof syrup and give the sample bottles as gifts!

Old Fashioned Cocktail Syrup Mini Set

Amber C.

This was our first time trying Proof Syrup and it will definitely be a staple in our house from now on! Smooth flavor with just the right blend of ingredients makes this the perfect pairing with any favorite bourbon/whisky. Highly recommend!

Traditional Proof Syrup

undefined review of Old Fashioned Master Set image 1 out of 1

Melanie R.

Loved having a cocktail with my mom and sister. Now my mom is gone my sister and husband and brother in law have a cocktail in her memory. Old Fashion for me please.

Old Fashioned Master Set

Tracy B.

I'm still learning my bottle Proof and what I can do with it, but the Old Fashioneds I've concocted thus far have been simply delightful. Two bar spoons (iced tea spoons) of Proof, two shots of a simply marvelous Larceny barrel pick, and two Filthy cherries is just the most marvelous and fruity after-dinner/dessert cocktail I could possibly hope for! I look forward to trying it with the Elijah Craig barrel pick I have, and seeing how it goes in the not-far-future with my bottle of Courvoisier an...

Traditional Proof Syrup

undefined review of Citrus Sour Proof Syrup image 1 out of 1

Brian R.

Proof makes margaritas easy and delicious. 2 oz very good quality Tequila 2 oz Proof Citrus Sour 1/2 oz Cointreau Salt for Rim of Glass (Optional) Lime for Garnish Wet glass rim with lime wedge and dip rim in salt Combine ingredients with ice in shaker and shake Pour into salted rim glass Enjoy

Citrus Sour Proof Syrup

Virginia M.

We love the Proof syrups! So far we have tried all the Old Fashioneds and most of the cocktail syrups and have enjoyed all of them. We have a sampler of the botanicals to give to my mom as a birthday gift and will try those at the end of the month! Great gifts and great cocktails!

Old Fashioned Cocktail Syrup Mini Set

Teri G.

I love Proof so much that I bought it for Christmas for my friend who is new to Old Fashioned's. She made herself a cocktail as soon as she got home and sent me this picture! She loved it too....and so did the rest of her family!

Traditional Proof Syrup

Wendy G.

We couldn't get our Old Fashioned quite right, so when I saw a Proof ad, I knew I had to order a bottle for my boyfriend for Christmas. Proof is exactly what was missing! Can't wait to try some of the other flavors! Cheers y'all!

Traditional Proof Syrup

Steven O.

My father in law loves brandy old fashions. I fixed him one with the Proof Traditional Old Fashion syrup and he loved it. He said it’s as good as any one he’s had in Wisconsin.

Traditional Proof Syrup

Kathleen C.

I go back and forth ordering between Traditional and Orange. Last time I ordered a bottle of both. Now I can try whichever one I feel into. Always a great Old Fashioned.

Traditional Proof Syrup

Walter L.

Started using Proof for my Old Fashioneds about a year ago and now, everybody I know loves “Roger’s Old Fashioned”. But, I’ve been right out front from the beginning with what my secret was… Proof Syrup! I’ll never go back. Thanks!

Traditional Proof Syrup

Jolie B.

This is our second fun with Proof Syrups in two days (but it is New Years!). This photo shows the Manhattan. Best ever! You have wonderful customer service and a super product!

Traditional Proof Syrup

undefined review of Traditional image 1 out of 1

Rodney M.

Kids turned me on to Old Fashions awhile back during a family gathering, drink them ever since. Friend in Ohio turned me on to Proof Syrup will not use anything else. Highly recommend these products.

Traditional

Dave S.

Great as always just wish I had a store close to me to get some more. I hate running out after a party and my friends try proof syrup and drink me dry. 😁

Old Fashioned Master Set

Kirk N.

Have purchased over 20 bottles to date. Absolutely love it. Now have at least 10 friends buying it, who have also recommended to their friends. I actually carry a small flask of it with me when I go out so I can add to my whiskey. Highly recommend it.

Traditional Proof Syrup

Glen F.

My partner gave this to me as a Christmas gift and i absolutely love it! I would not have been able to tell that the Old Fashioned was made with a syrup. it tastes like I am drinking a cocktail from an old cozy, Southern bar and I'm loving every sip.

Traditional Proof Syrup

Francie R.

Proof Syrup is the best that I have tasted for an old-fashioned. I have not tried the other varieties than traditional as yet, but I plan to do so asap! I am interested in several flavors. I already know that the bottle is too small, can you please make bigger bottles?

Traditional Proof Syrup

Nancy S.

Own a innovative creative American Restaurant 0n Cape Cod, I am the 3rd generation. I feature your product at the restaurant and my Facebook page! Sold out of maple bacon (4bottles) in 3 weeks! Nancy Smith

Maple Bacon Proof Syrup

Robert James V.

It is dark outside. It is cold outside. The trees of the forest are banging against the treehouse. At an elevation of 6,345’, that might be a hint that snow is on the way. Inside, the treehouse, all is well. The fire in the fireplace has been lit. Evening news has just started. And most, importantly, an Old Fashioned with Proof Traditional Syrup has just been introduced to Noble Oak Bourbon. I think they will get along just fine!

Traditional Proof Syrup

undefined review of Orange Proof Syrup image 1 out of 1

Don H.

Always enjoy a ball game or sitting on the patio much better with my proof syrup used to make the best Old Fashioneds. Especially fond of the Traditional and Orange syrups.

Orange Proof Syrup

Michael N.

1/2 oz. Maple bacon proof syrup 1/2 oz BlackBerry juice 2 oz Basil Hayden Bourbon Mix in a cocktail shaker w/ice Pour into glass with single ice cube

Maple Bacon Proof Syrup

Shilpi N.

Amazing! I really enjoy a well made old fashioned, my husband would never ever order one. Bars rarely made them well so I never ordered one when out. Not only is the traditional proof perfect for me but now my husband loves old fashioneds! But he will only drink the ones we make at home with proof. Thank you!

Traditional Proof Syrup

Sheena J.

I can now make an Old Fashioned at home better than 75% of bartenders! All I do is add bourbon, orange peel and Luxardo cherries. Done! It's so easy and delicious!

Traditional Proof Syrup

Raul H.

I’ve been using proof for over a year. Along the way I’ve tried other similar products, but so far I’ve come back to proof!! On top of that their customer services is awesome. Had an with one of my deliveries, and they responded accordingly. This year I purchased a mini set, that I’m gifting. Love your product.

Traditional Proof Syrup

undefined review of Pumpkin Spice image 1 out of 1

Angela W.

I have not had a bad flavor yet!!! Pumpkin Spice is my absolute favorite. I love the pumpkin spice margarita that came in my email. I love to receive new recipes. Keep them coming. Proof Syrups hands down is the best!!!

Pumpkin Spice

Sherrill O.

We can't keep enough Traditional Proof Syrup in our pantry! We have (the three of us) an Old Fashioned during the cocktail hour every evening. We use a cherry 🍒 as our garnish of choice. We LOVE it!

Traditional Proof Syrup

Robert James V.

The new Orange is a hit in our mountain home. Recently I ordered a competitive product from Amazon. I wanted to do a comparison with Proof Traditional. Please to say, that Proof is in a class by it-self. Time to place a new three bottle order with Proof.

Traditional Proof Syrup

Stephen S.

Having tried Proof Traditional Old Fashioned Cocktail Syrup several times, this evening I moved on to the Maple Bacon flavor. As I expected, the Old Fashioned I made with Wild Turkey bourbon was very good, but I wish the maple and bacon flavors were more prominent. Maybe I need to throw a rasher of bacon in the glass instead of those Luxardo cherries.

Maple Bacon Proof Syrup

Edward L.

I love the traditional Old Fashioned Proof. I have been a bourbon guy for years and this adds a nice touch to some of my favorite aged bourbons. Just trying Wolcott for the first time and I must say it’s quite pleasant. I am a bit of a traditionalist but might try some of the other Proof syrups to broaden my horizons. Great product and I’m glad I discovered it!

Traditional Proof Syrup

undefined review of Classic Grenadine Proof Syrup image 1 out of 1

Libby B.

I am really enjoying Proof in my Old Fashions. It makes it so easy to make a delicious cocktail. Pomegranate has a lovely taste. There are so many flavors and it’s nice to mix it up. Yum!

Classic Grenadine Proof Syrup

Libby B.

This purchase was a great way to try several flavors. I like the taste of all of them but do have a favorite - Pecan. They make a delicious Old Fashion!

Old Fashioned Cocktail Syrup Mini Set

Larry W.

I have tried so many different mixes trying to perfect an "Old Fashioned" and I have to say, Proof Traditional Syrup does the trick for me. The attached picture shows two jars of what I call "Old Fashioned Soaked Cherries" I simply soak some fresh cherries in my Old Fashioned. I'll let you know how they turn out. I'm sure they will be delicious.

Traditional Proof Syrup

Ms K.

A good ole’ old fashioned made with Proof Old Fashioned Traditional Syrup trumps a glass of wine any day! It’s as simple as this….your favorite bourbon, Proof Old Fashioned Traditional Syrup, ice, and your favorite glass. Sip and enjoy!!

Traditional Proof Syrup

Deborah A.

I had been on the fence about buying such a big bottle, but boy that maple bacon sure looked good. When I saw the other flavors, I really couldn’t make up my mind. Was so happy to see the sampler pack for sale. Now I want them all. So good and so easy! We’ve shared with friends and they are all pleasantly surprised and wanting their own bottle. These will be in regular rotation in our house for sure. Great product!!

Old Fashioned Cocktail Syrup Mini Set

Jp L.

Very impressed with how easy it is to consistently make a delicious old-fashioned with these syrups. I also love how economical it is, just half an ounce with your bourbon means you've got a long lasting supply of cocktails. I chose the Maple Bacon, and while it tastes phenomenal, I'd like to find more bacon notes, I catch some on the nose but neither me, my wife nor friends have tasted any bacon flavor. Even Still, I'll be ordering again, cheers!🥃

Maple Bacon Proof Syrup

Proof Syrup ReviewsMore details