Proof Syrup Reviews

undefined review of Traditional Proof Syrup image 1 out of 1

Jennifer C.

I ordered all three syrups and they all taste great! It is so easy to just add the syrup and some ice you have a great cocktail! I’ve already gifted Proof syrup to my daughter, I will be including it in holiday baskets for friends. Great product!

Traditional Proof Syrup

undefined review of Pecan Proof Syrup image 1 out of 1

Joshua E.

Proof Syrup has thrown my go-to old fashioned into a whole new tier. Can hardly drink one without it now it’s so good! I’ve tried traditional, pecan and maple bacon so far. Pecan is my favorite but they are well made and put a perfect touch on those night time cocktails I enjoy.

Pecan Proof Syrup

undefined review of Orange Proof Syrup image 1 out of 1

Stacey M.

Absolutely perfect- we are old fashioned connoisseurs and I cannot believe how delicious Proof syrup is. I was so skeptical but after years of making out OF from scratch we have finally found the perfect mix!

Orange Proof Syrup

Kathleen C.

Always love the traditional and orange Proof. I noticed this week that Proof is now featured in our local Wine Beer and Spirits store in Omaha NE. I can now buy it on the run if need be!

Traditional Proof Syrup

Tim C.

I make old fashions and was introduced to proof syrups over Christmas by a friend who gave me them for a Christmas present. I have tried several but the pecan was quite good. My son and I enjoyed several over the holidays to include traditional and black walnut. I have to say we love the proof syrups especially for old fashions, they are great!

Pecan Proof Syrup

undefined review of Botanical Cocktail Master Set image 1 out of 1

Julie B.

This is my first time trying any of the Botanicals & I love them! The flavors are great & with SO many possibilities it’s tough to decide what cocktail I want to try next!

Botanical Cocktail Master Set

Matt B.

Have used the basil syrup as we purchased the botanical set. Basil has great flavor and goes with hibiscus. Also have the mini old fashioned and cocktail syrups. All have great flavor and enjoy making new cocktails with these syrups.

Botanical Cocktail Master Set

Van G.

This was my first time trying Proof Traditional Old Fashioned Syrup and I am pleasantly surprised with the taste. I really like having the ability to quickly make a consistently great great tasting Old Fashioned for friends and myself.

Traditional Proof Syrup

Steven B.

Having first been exposed to Proof products at a friends house, I was surprised at how good they tasted in an old fashion. I reminds me of the good old days of sipping on a well made drink with original ingredients.

Traditional Proof Syrup

undefined review of Citrus Sour Proof Syrup image 1 out of 1

Ryan W.

Absolutely can’t get enough of these Proof whiskey sours! Bulleit rye is our whiskey of choice. Mix up these with a big iceberg, plus a few Luxardo cherries and it’s perfect sipping for hot tub time!

Citrus Sour Proof Syrup

Dan D.

Proof Syrup is absolutely the Best!! It makes cocktail time easier and the end product is always spot on. I’ve shared it with friends and they’re now Old Fashioned devotees.

Traditional Proof Syrup

Charles C.

Been using Proof Syrup for over 6 months and loving it. It’s a perfect balance of bitters with a sweetness that makes this drink really smooth and enjoyable. With an orange twist and cherry and you’ve got a great old fashioned.

Traditional Proof Syrup

Denise M.

This makes our Old Fashioneds perfect! So easy! I feel so special. And we take them with us when we travel to our Michigan cottage. Nothing beats an Old Fashioned by the water!

Traditional Proof Syrup

Robert James V.

Here in the Torreon Golf Club, located in the White Mountains of Arizona, I have enjoyed introducing our friends to Proof Syrups. The one I enjoy the most is the Traditional Old Fashioned Syrup. It is especially fun experimenting with various bourbons. The one I am sharing with the Gorilla in the photo was crafted with Horse Soldier bourbon. An incredible drink!

Traditional Proof Syrup

Joshua E.

I started getting worried that I was too snobby. That I was too picky. That I was too obnoxious about ordering an old fashioned and it not tasting like I prefer it. I thought I may never find a place to always get the perfect old fashioned. Then I tried Proof. My girlfriend is my favorite bartender anyway. Now I’ll never go back! #perfectoldfashioned #everytime

Traditional Proof Syrup

Libby B.

Proof makes a delicious Old Fashion. I have tried many varieties but Pecan remains my favorite with Pomegranate a close second. I like to add a shot of club soda and a cocktail cherry with a bit of the cherry juice to the Proof and Crown Royal. Yum!

Pecan Proof Syrup

Adam B.

I have been using Proof syrup for the past year now and I absolutely love it! I like that it’s made fresh and stamped with date and it arrives in very high quality packaging and makes the best Old Fashioned!! I will continue to use Proof Syrup Traditional Old Fashioned Cocktail Mix.

Traditional Proof Syrup

Tyree C.

Yes, you can make a better or comparable Old Fashioned BUT you cannot beat Proof for the convenience!!! I've also tried 3 other syrups and Proof is EASILY the best when it comes to taste. It is worth every penny!!!

Traditional Proof Syrup

Arnold P.

Proof is a real difference maker when your desire for an Old Fashioned comes around. The simplicity it brings the process is great but, would be nothing without the product being absolutely spectacular. I've had Old Fashioneds at great Steak Houses and Restaurants and I can honestly say, the Traditional Proof is the best, most consistent.

Traditional Proof Syrup

Bruce D.

Orange-infused Old Fashioned mix adds a different & refreshing twist to a classic favorite. Also great for us who neglected to buy oranges or have run out and who are out of orange bitters, but still want the original Old Fashioned taste.

Orange Proof Syrup

Robert V.

I have bought around 4 bottles of the Traditional Proof Syrup and will be ordering more. I have always been a fan of Old Fashions but never wanted to put in the work to make them. The Proof Syrup Old fashion (I use Bulleit) is by far the best I have had.

Traditional Proof Syrup

undefined review of Old Fashioned Cocktail Syrup Mini Set image 1 out of 1

Vincent A.

Traditional Proof takes all the guess work from adding bitters to muddling a sugar cube for the perfect Old Fashioned. It's the an exceptional blend & definitely a time saver. I have the sampler & waiting to share these other flavors with friends soon.

Old Fashioned Cocktail Syrup Mini Set

undefined review of Maple Bacon Proof Syrup image 1 out of 1

David G.

Made Maple Bacon old fashioned with this syrup and even made some candied bacon! By far the most amazing Old Fashioned I’ve EVER had including a few Speakeasies that my wife and I love to visit. This was so easy and so delicious

Maple Bacon Proof Syrup

Joann F.

This is a concoction I made with Elijah Craig bourbon and Ginger Proof Cocktail Syrup, with a slice and squeeze of orange and a spritz of Perrier. Because I have run out of Proof Old Fashioned Syrup! I need to order more!

Traditional Proof Syrup

Rafael C.

A easy, delicious way to make my favorite cocktail. Whether with bourbon, whiskey or even 15 year old aged rum. I'm a customer for as long as Proof is available.

Orange Proof Syrup

Rahsaan J.

Proof syrup makes the best old fashions that I like to enjoy with a good cigar. So far I have tried the Maple Bacon and the Pecan. Both are superb! Better than a $15 old fashion that I ordered at a high end cigar lounge at my local cigar lounge

Maple Bacon Proof Syrup

Tyler G.

I have been a fan of Proof for awhile but never strayed from the traditional flavor, so I had to try the sampler set. I’ve already finished the Maple Bacon and Pecan, and I’m planning to try the Black Walnut next. The Maple Bacon was stronger in flavor than Pecan but both were very good. Looking forward to finishing them all!

Old Fashioned Cocktail Syrup Mini Set

Rick M.

Just a quiet afternoon in my office on my 65th birthday enjoying my favorite Old Fashion with proof syrup, a good rye, a Woodford bourbon cherry, and a twist of orange rind. You have to try this. I have converted a lot of persnickity bourbon drinkers. Happy birthday to me.

Traditional Proof Syrup

Stephen S.

Having tried the Traditional and Maple Bacon flavors, I moved on to the Proof Pecan Old Fashioned Syrup. Like the others, I really enjoyed the ease with which I could make a great-tasting Old Fashioned at home. I'll definitely be ordering again, and now have my eyes on the Black Walnut and Orange flavors.

Pecan Proof Syrup

Spencer T.

I went through a bottle of the original and recently used the maple bacon in this old fashioned… Maple Bacon is the bomb!!! I will be ordering more of it.

Maple Bacon Proof Syrup

Andrew K.

I love this syrup. I use the traditional 1/2 oz with 2oz. bourbon and mix it in a cocktail shaker with a lot of ice. Perhaps not traditional but the water helps cut the sweetness and my ice cold drink is perfect for a summer evening. Served with three rocks and no garnish (because who has time to cut an orange peel at home. 😊 I’m so spoiled I now prefer this in the evening rather than my straight bourbon on the rocks.

Traditional Proof Syrup

Ernest J.

Great products. I have three and swap around, Probably prefer the maple bacon but the pecan is wonderful and the Traditional is spot on. Saves me a bunch of time but not skimping on quality.

Pecan Proof Syrup

Ronald J.

Wow! Created a Benton’s Old Fashioned. Fat washed Four Roses Small Batch using Benton’s Bacon. 1z bacon fat to 12.5oz Four Roses. Benton Old Fashioned: 1z Fat Washed Bourbon, ,1oz non fat washed, 1/2Z Proof Maple Bacon. Orange twist.

Maple Bacon Proof Syrup

Patrice G.

I purchased the traditional and the maple bacon for my husband and sons for Father's Day! They loved loved loved it! We spend a lot of time making Old Fashions and now the process will be so much more simple! We WILL purchase again!

Traditional Proof Syrup

Kathy G.

Bought the set of three...used the Simple Syrup in a blueberry margarita and it was fantastic. Mixed the Maple Bacon in a wonderful old fashioned-very subtle smoky finish. Then tried the Pecan with a high end bourbon and it really enhanced the flavor. Loved all 3 flavors and would buy again.

Pecan Proof Syrup

Leona B.

Wow, definitely lives up to the hype. Got the traditional and maple bacon For my husband for father’a day, both are delicious! My husband loves both too! Delicious and worth it. Will keep ordering :). Enjoying our ol’ fashions at the beach!

Traditional Proof Syrup

David W.

This is our Terrace overlooking the ocean. Normally there would be two old fashions on the table but we ran out of Proof!! Our next order should be arriving in two days!! You absolutely positively made us believers! Love this product!!

Maple Bacon Proof Syrup

Joanne B.

Simply delicious! I watched my brother-in-law make Old Fashions from scratch for years & thought thay were too much work. Proof has made them one step and simply delicious.

Maple Bacon Proof Syrup

Terry R.

Wow the three amigo's have made old fashioned cocktail hour a breeze. These are super delish, and now guests can choose to enjoy what meets their tastes. I have worked long and hard to get just the right taste, Proof makes it as easy as can be.

Traditional Proof Syrup

Steve J.

Proof Old Fashion Syrups are the best mixers on the market. Must be a reason why most world-class and cutting edge restaurants and bars use Proof. What I love about Proof unlike most others is the balance of ingredients and belief in tradition. Have tried so many that are overdone with vanilla, cinnamon, or other ingredients that are not in a classic Old Fashion. Proof Pecan or Maple Bacon tells you on the front label what they are upfront so there is no surprise. Proof is a great product with g...

Maple Bacon Proof Syrup

Proof Syrup ReviewsMore details