Proof Syrup Reviews

Matthew A.

I've used a few different Old Fashioned syrups or mixes in the past, and they've all been ok. This one is head and shoulders above all of them. No matter what Whiskey or Bourbon I use with it, it's always deliciously enjoyable and smooth! My only complaint? It's so good I'm running out too fast! Buy a bottle or like 3!

Traditional

Joel H.

I was skeptical about the old fashioned syrup but after trying it, I was pleasantly impressed. It’s definitely worthy of pairing with my favorite brandy. Excellent!

Traditional Proof Syrup

undefined review of Orange Proof Syrup image 1 out of 1

Kevin S.

Old Fashioned with a twist of orange. One of my favorites! So easy and delicious with Proof. The "Proof" is in the taste.

Orange Proof Syrup

Bill B.

I’ve fallen in love with Proof old fashioned! I’ve ordered two flavors: maple and orange and will try new flavors on my next order.

Orange Proof Syrup

Lewis W.

Proof Old Fashioned Syrup and Baby Saz Rye is a perfect combo. Until I found Proof my cocktails were inconsistent. Now they are perfect every time.

Traditional Proof Syrup

Timothy H.

Love the traditional, it makes it so easy to make an Old Fashion, no mess and the flavor is better than adding all the ingredients.

Traditional Proof Syrup

Michael M.

I have tried almost all your syrups. I liked the Traditional,Orange,Black Walnut,Citrus Sour,And Ginger the best for my Bourbon and Vodka.

Traditional Proof Syrup

Hector G.

Best Old Fashioned cocktail syrup ever! Perfect Old Fashioned every time! I've tried similar products but nothing compares to Proof. Worth every penny.

Traditional Proof Syrup

Jeremy P.

I really enjoyed it, I will be ordering more! Makes a really good old fashion, comparable to any good old fashion I've ever drank. Would highly recommend.

Traditional Proof Syrup

Charles C.

This is truly a great and easy way to make a classic Old Fashioned. Proof Syrup has not disappointed at all.

Traditional Proof Syrup

Daniel B.

I have shared the Proof Syrup with family and friends and they love it!!!! The Traditional Proof Syrup is my go to for an Old Fashioned. Highly recommend!!!

Traditional Proof Syrup

Mark R.

We are a big fan of old fashioned cocktails but don’t always have the time to do traditional prep. This mix works great. Easy and great tasting!

Traditional Proof Syrup

Kurt S.

I absolutely love Proof Syrup! I am currently enjoying the Maple Bacon. But I‘be tried a lot of them so far. Talk about a great tasting Old Fashioned!

Traditional Proof Syrup

undefined review of Ginger Proof Syrup image 1 out of 1

Jill M.

My absolute favorite. Traditional Proof Syrup and Angel's Envy Bourbon with an orange twist. Note the glass with an etching of Man O' War. Tastes better in that glass!

Ginger Proof Syrup

undefined review of Proof Gift Card image 1 out of 1

Joe P.

Incredible deal! I don’t know many companies that would offer 50% gift cards (especially not around the holidays). One of the best mixers around.

Proof Gift Card

Michael W.

Original flavor proof syrup is my favorite. Everyone I make an old fashioned for with this stuff loves it too. Plan on being a customer for a long time. My only gripe is the price of shipping, its a bit high but i understand its a heavy liquid.

Traditional

Mary M.

I LOVE the Ginger syrup. You can tell it is made with fresh ginger. It has a nice "bite" without being hot. Ginger and Bourbon is my new "go to" drink. I already bought 2 more bottles!

Ginger

undefined review of Whiskey Sour image 1 out of 1

Kera W.

The Whiskey Sour is one of my favorites! I added an egg white and it was amazing! I have already needed to reorder a bottle.

Whiskey Sour

Bob S.

I have become a huge fan of Old Fashion cocktails because of Proof Traditional syrup. So easy to mix without muddling or messing with a lot of ingredients. Best cocktail I have ever had. And I make it myself!! Love Proof

Traditional

undefined review of Bulk - 12 Bottle Case image 1 out of 1

Christopher P.

My wife got me my first bottle and I’ve been a disciple since. I bought a case + 1 for friends this year!

Bulk - 12 Bottle Case

undefined review of Maple Bacon image 1 out of 1

Dana L.

I was very hesitant to try Proof syrup. My only regret is that I didn’t try it sooner. It makes the best Old Fashioned’s, hands down.

Maple Bacon

undefined review of Manhattan Proof Syrup image 1 out of 1

Bruce D.

Very good & so easy to mix. I use 3 to 1, bourbon to mix ratio. And I add a dark cherry or two to finish it out to the perfect Manhattan.

Manhattan Proof Syrup

Paul C.

As the picture show’s it’s a Manhattan on the rocks for me. Have mixed with three different bourbons and enjoyed them all. This mix is outstanding!!

Manhattan Proof Syrup

William R.

I absolutely love this product !! The "Original" proof makes the best Old fashions hands down. It doesn't get any easier than just adding this to your bourbon of choice and your done. I recommend this product to anyone who wants a great tasting drink.

Traditional

undefined review of Black Walnut image 1 out of 1

Ethan Z.

My go to is the Smoked Old Fashioned with white oak chips, Buffalo Trace Bourbon, and the dark walnut proof syrup. Perfect everytime!

Black Walnut

undefined review of Clear Ice Molds image 1 out of 1

Nick M.

Makes a nice clear ice sphere. I especially like how long the sphere lasts so it doesn’t dilute my drinks like regular ice cubes do.

Clear Ice Molds

Annette T.

Love Proof! I bought 7 bottles of proof original old fashioned for my daughter’s wedding. I turned the bartender onto it and will now be a staple at his bar. Thank you for an excellent product!

Traditional

Terry P.

I’ve had dome good Old Fashioneds at some really good bats.....but proof syrup and my favorite bourbon was as good as any of them!

Traditional Proof Syrup

undefined review of Maple Bacon Proof Syrup image 1 out of 1

Paula L.

Oban Single Malt Scotch Whisky- MacLeans Maple Bacon Proof- Old Fashio cocktail syrup Orange peel Brown sugar, cayenne pepper bacon stir

Maple Bacon Proof Syrup

Greg R.

Absolutely amazing! My friends and I (made the mistake of letting them try it)went through a bottle of bourbon in record time! Highly recommend

Maple Bacon Proof Syrup

Ronald B.

Could not get my old fashion to taste like I get in bars. That is till I tried Proof! Love it!

Maple Bacon Proof Syrup

Shawn D.

The. Best. Old. Fashion. Period. I consider myself a connoisseur and this is second to none. It’s making me drink every night now.

Traditional Proof Syrup

Cory M.

Huckleberry mule 1/2 oz of traditional proof 2 oz of Huckleberry flavored vodka Ice Cock n bull ginger beer

Traditional Proof Syrup

Michelle B.

Love this . We have been through 4 bottles in the past 4 months and ordering more . Old fashions taste great with traditional proof syrup

Traditional Proof Syrup

Michael B.

Die hard beer drinker that never could find an enjoyable way to drink bourbon. Proof syrup changed that. My favorite is enjoying an old fashioned traditional flavor.

Traditional Proof Syrup

Anthony A.

maple bacon proof with bulleit bourbon and who doesn’t like a little extra bacon as a garnish am i right?!?

Maple Bacon Proof Syrup

Beatrice G.

Absolutely amazing! Better than any high end restaurant! The best part is I get to make them exactly how I like my Old Fashioned drink every time! Lifetime customer!

Traditional Proof Syrup

Brett E.

I have tried a few of the Old Fashioned mixes and I really like Maple/Bacon. It has become my go to.

Maple Bacon Proof Syrup

Richard W.

I am actually shocked at how good this old-fashioned is. I have been a fanatic in making my own but this may change my mind.

Traditional Proof Syrup

Kevin N.

I tried the Maple Bacon Proof Syrup and I loved it! Very tasty and so simple to make a great Old Fashioned every time!

Maple Bacon Proof Syrup

Proof Syrup ReviewsMore details