Proof Syrup Reviews

undefined review of Traditional Proof Syrup image 1 out of 1

Geoffrey F.

This concoction is bad news. Too easy to make and too easy to drink. Seriously good stuff. I like mine with a Luxardo cherry and a touch of its syrup.

Traditional Proof Syrup

Eric G.

I've tried several of the different flavors but I keep coming back to the Traditional. It's as simple as mix with your favorite bourbon and it tastes as good as the expensive old fashioned cocktails that you'd get a nice restaurant bar.

Traditional Proof Syrup

Tammy B.

Honestly, I normally sip my whiskey straight but I have to hand it to this syrup. It's tasty! Enough so I might even try their other flavors. What I especially like is that a little bit takes you a long way. And it's all natural with none of that fake stuff. Yep. I do recommend.

Traditional Proof Syrup

undefined review of Maple Bacon Proof Syrup image 1 out of 1

Dan S.

I usually experiment with my our flavors and syrup but I decided to try Proof. I instantly loved it and use it regularly now. I would recommend it to anyone who love Old Fashioneds.

Maple Bacon Proof Syrup

David M.

I love drinking Old Fashioneds, and decided to give Proof Syrup a try. I love it! I’m also surprised at how many drinks (It’s a lot!) I can make out of the bottle. I’ll definitely buy some more

Traditional Proof Syrup

David G.

Just plain easy and tasty. I don't need to juggle and resupply everything I need for a quick, great drink. I go a little heavier on the whiskey than prescribed, and the result is just what the doctor ordered. I will definitely buy it again!

Traditional Proof Syrup

I used to make my Old Fashioned’s only from scratch and poo poo’d the mixes. PROOF is good enough for me to save a little time and enjoy my whiskey as much and maybe more than before. First tried PROOF during the holidays and there were some shipping mixups, but they went WAY out of their way to make better than right. I am hooked!

Traditional Proof Syrup

John M.

Tried several different mixes, including my own. Nothing compares to Proof Syrup. I have also tried many different Bourbons and Ryes with Proof Syrup. Basil Hayden Dark Rye and Proof is winning combination. Add a bit of Hickory or Apple smoke is a nice change once in a while as well.

Traditional Proof Syrup

Phil R.

Old Fashioneds have been my go to for 20 years. This is one of the most complete and flavorful syrups I've ever had. I got the 3-pack and all 3 flavors have very distinct notes. Awesome stuff, thanks.

Maple Bacon Proof Syrup

undefined review of Old Fashioned Cocktail Syrup Mini Set image 1 out of 1

Jerrod S.

Got the mini set as a Christmas gift (cuz I said I really wanted it). All of the flavors are fantastic. The Orange and Traditional are my favorites (just ordered a big bottle of the Orange). Looking forward to trying more. My Old Fashions are now perfect! Proof will now be a permanent part of my home bar. Love it and highly recommend it.

Old Fashioned Cocktail Syrup Mini Set

Walter F.

I bought it to bring to the beach the week of October 4th. Spending time with my brothers at Pawleys Island. Only made it til September 23rd. Time to re-order

Traditional Proof Syrup

Elizabeth G.

We love your Syrups! We’ve tried them all and they’re all amazing BUT our favorite is the Pecan. It’s slightly sweeter than the rest which makes for an amazing drink. While my husband thinks it’s a sin to drink Blantons mixed, I think it’s a sin not to add Proof syrup! - A wife of a whiskey lover

Traditional Proof Syrup

Beth S.

It is awesome. We are whiskey drinkers and are loving this addition. I use a twist of orange 🍊 peel and a maraschino cherry. Reminds me of the cocktails my Dad would make when he got home from work. Takes me back.

Maple Bacon Proof Syrup

undefined review of Pecan Proof Syrup image 1 out of 1

Jill V.

1part pecan Proof syrup 3 parts apple cider 1 part vodka 1/2 part lemon juice and dash of cinnamon The syrup adds smoothness and a touch of sweet to this drink that tastes like apple pie. Yum! Love PROOF syrup!

Pecan Proof Syrup

Helen C.

My husband loves Old Fashioned with Proof Orange Syrup. He likes the Traditional Old Fashioned Syrup as well but he really loves the aromatic hint of orange with his favorite bourbon. I used to subscribe every 3 months but changed to every 2 months. I love as well when do crave an Old Fashioned! He won’t make one without it!

Orange

undefined review of Old Fashioned Master Set image 1 out of 1

Ben H.

It's 5 o'clock somewhere, right?! I've tried each of the Old Fashioned Syrups and this is one of my favorites! You can't go wrong with any of them. Stop waiting...buy some already!!

Old Fashioned Master Set

undefined review of Citrus Sour Proof Syrup image 1 out of 1

Rich V.

I absolutely love the citrus mixer ! It makes fantastic margaritas. I also used it with Tito’s vodka , splash of Cointreau and about 5oz of club soda also fantastic! The picture is a chilled margarita!

Citrus Sour Proof Syrup

undefined review of Black Walnut Proof Syrup image 1 out of 1

Lanny S.

Very nice flavor, takes edge off strong whiskey but keeps it real. Recommend rye whiskey with this flavor as the walnut flavor combines with rye to create a smooth drink with a little heat.

Black Walnut Proof Syrup

Eric M.

I am a bacon lover so this was a no brainer. Kicked up my blended scotch whiskey to a whole new level. Now I can't go back to just drinking it plain. Will be ordering this stuff on a regular basis now.

Maple Bacon Proof Syrup

Bret B.

OMG. Absolutely me and my girl favorite mixer. It takes the complication out of a complicated drink while keeping it classic and classy. I want to order the whole collection. 😍

Traditional Proof Syrup

Johann K.

First timer here... I love Proof it's not too sweet like some other ones I tried. I just destroyed the entire bottle of Woodford thanks to Proof. I'm not sure if this is a good thing or a bad thing. I need to buy more Proof and maybe try a different flavor next time.

Traditional Proof Syrup

Stephen S.

I love the Pecan Proof Old Fashioned Syrup, so I was very hopeful that I'd like the Black Walnut flavor as much or even more. I guess I really like the nutty flavors, because I think Black Walnut is fantastic, too!

Black Walnut Proof Syrup

Spencer T.

My brother in east Texas introduced me to this syrup. It is the easiest best tasting mix I’ve used. I am in south east Florida and it is hard to get here. Thanks for sending it to my door.!!

Traditional Proof Syrup

undefined review of White Peach Proof Syrup image 1 out of 1

Martha K.

I would LOVE to show you my drink, but as you can see, it is almost gone! LOVE the White Peach Proof Syrup! Oh yum yum yum. Tonight I had it in a vodka tonic - splash of WPPS. Oh dear! SO good! I have loved every Proof Syrup we’ve bought - haven’t tried the Maple Bacon, Black Walnut, Honey, Orange. Feel free to send me the samples!! So excited your business is doing so well!

White Peach Proof Syrup

undefined review of Orange Proof Syrup image 1 out of 1

Randy W.

Proof Syrup takes the hassle out of measuring and mixing. There are so many other cocktails that I’d like to make, but I don’t want to buy multiple ingredients that will only be used once in a while. I’ll be sending the Sampler Pack to my daughter and son-in-law for Christmas.

Orange Proof Syrup

Lerinezo R.

I love old fashions! When my wife surprised me with the syrup. I didn’t think it would live up to it…I WAS SO WRONG!!! This is amazing!!! I have told many people about it. They too have purchased some already! The White Peach and Maple Bacon are amazing!

Traditional Proof Syrup

Bob P.

Love this so much we’ve already reordered! Our home bar is now well stocked with all the Proof products. They make home bartending so much easier so I’m not stuck behind the bar. So simple and easy and absolutely no sacrifice in quality. We love them all but the Maple Bacon Old Fasion is our favorite and our friends love them too.

Maple Bacon Proof Syrup

Jeff A.

I really love the products but the customer service was a bit lacking as my order was delayed. The service rep blamed it on Fed Ex but I did you choose them, Proof did. I shared this over 2 weeks ago and still no reply!!!

Traditional Proof Syrup

Andy R.

I’m hooked! Not only are the mixes exceptional, Custer Service has made me a Proof buyer for life. Go above and beyond. Mixes make the perfect Old Fashion in seconds. Highly recommend traditional, pumpkin spice, maple bacon, and black walnut. Deep flavors with a Smokey finish. PERFECT for any occasion. Rougie Shack Bar & Grill, Luling LA. Only use Proof mixes!

Old Fashioned Cocktail Syrup Mini Set

Steve C.

Old fashions have been my go to bar drink for years. But they are too complex to make at home easily. Proof makes it easy and it tastes like my old favorite! Well done.

Traditional Proof Syrup

Zak M.

I love this stuff! I bought the triple pack and let a buddy pick one bottle for a Bday gift. He loved it and is buying a triple pack for himself! Im buying more now!!!

Pecan Proof Syrup

David H.

Proof Syrop, Angles Envy and three fresh-picked blackberries that are gently squeezed to get a drop or two of blackberry juice in the mix . . . Life is very, very good!!!

Traditional Proof Syrup

John H.

I absolutely love Proof! I followed the directions and it came out great. Maybe just maybe a little sweet. Time will tell. I like it because it is a one stop shop. Very easy to make. No mess. Awesome.

Traditional Proof Syrup

Susan F.

The world has gone bananas but your drink doesn't have to. Having a classic has never been easier. Fire up your HiFi, slip into your smoking jacket, and toast to your health. (It can be our little secret if you make more than one... you'll definitely want to)

Traditional Proof Syrup

Brennon R.

This is hands down the best mixer I've ever had. I tell as many people as possible it's a must try. Don't be fooled by the price it makes lots of drinks and adds that smokiness and sweetness you're looking for in a mixer. 10/10

Traditional Proof Syrup

John P.

First time I’ve bought something based on a Facebook ad. Well, first time turned out to be a good decision! I started with the maple bacon. Then second time around, went for the Pecan. Normally pair them with a local Rye whiskey by Lazy Guy Distillery. Love this stuff! Try it, you’ll love it.

Pecan Proof Syrup

Daniel S.

I was skeptical about these flavors but wow was I wrong. Pecan and whiskey is wonder. My go to drink is maple- bacon Proof with Rye whiskey, sweet vermouth and a splash of soda water. You won’t be disappointed!

Traditional Proof Syrup

Jennifer C.

Proof syrup has arrived! Cracked it open tonight & both my husband and I are blown away - great stuff! Maple Bacon for the win!! Next order is definitely going to be the Pecan... Stay tuned.

Maple Bacon Proof Syrup

Laurie S.

When I have guests and cocktails are offered, this is the best! Easy to make, everyone loves it, and easy to garnish with a cherry or orange peel. I keep several bottles handy. Haven’t tried the citrus yet, that is next on my list.

Traditional Proof Syrup

Jerry C.

Just as the advertisement indicates, no need to spend tons of money on a mixed drink when you can make them at home for a fraction of the cost!! I will continue to purchase Proof Syrup!!!!

Traditional Proof Syrup

Proof Syrup ReviewsMore details