Proof Syrup Reviews

undefined review of Ginger Proof Syrup image 1 out of 1

Josh D.

I am really enjoying the Kentucky Mules and my wife loves the Moscow Mules. Great stuff. Just placed our 2nd order and plan on Proof being a permanent item in our refrigerator.

Ginger Proof Syrup

undefined review of Traditional Proof Syrup image 1 out of 1

Chris P.

I’ve had three flavors so far...Maple Bacon by far the favorite and then the original. Pecan good too but wouldn’t get it again simply because of my preference of the Maple Bacon. Amazing

Traditional Proof Syrup

undefined review of Maple Bacon Proof Syrup image 1 out of 1

Jeremy B.

I love proof syrup and so do many of my friends that come over to visit! Would be happy to help spread the good word on Proof Syrup to all!

Maple Bacon Proof Syrup

undefined review of Black Walnut Proof Syrup image 1 out of 1

Juan A.

The syrup is amazing and we love it. Unfortunately we are trying to order more and the site is telling me that you don’t deliver to Alaska, so I can’t place another order. Would love to purchase several more bottles

Black Walnut Proof Syrup

Nichole D.

Got this as a gift for my husband and he LOVES it! He is very picky about his drink and has no complaints. We will be ordering more, thank you!

Maple Bacon Proof Syrup

Christine C.

We had Old Fashioneds to celebrate our 16th anniversary, noshing in front of a fire. It was a lovely evening with great companionship and luscious beverages. Cannot wait to try the sour mix, too.

Traditional Proof Syrup

Melissa S.

My son makes Old Fashioneds for my husband when he comes home from college. I bought syrup to see if it would be even close to his recipe and he was kind of mad how good it was! He had thought about how much time he had wasted to measure and muddle and have all those different ingredients— all those steps that one bottle, one pour perfectly had mastered!!

Traditional Proof Syrup

Barbara W.

I love it! I too want sugar free, but it is worth 2 WW points every time! Unfortunately the alcohol counts as 3, so it’s a five point drink. Can’t wait to order the citrus, and maybe the Pom...we’ll see.

Traditional Proof Syrup

Ashton P.

Our house is where people come to have old fashions. Friends and family love ours but they’ve said how they can’t replicate them at their house. Now this is all we serve and everyone loves them. I bought some for family members and they turn out just as good at their house as they do it ours! We all love these.

Maple Bacon Proof Syrup

Jared C.

I'd been seeing ads for Proof Syrup for months and finally caved recently. I wish I'd bought some WAY sooner! I plan to try nearly every bottle available at some point. My go-to evening drinks are old fashioneds and this is an A+++++ option. The recipes on the Proof website are also worth the deviation from your "norm" too!

Maple Bacon Proof Syrup

undefined review of White Peach Proof Syrup image 1 out of 1

Kim H.

We love all flavors, but white peach is my favorite! It pairs so easy with Prosecco and you honestly have the flavor in the glass after you are done with your drink!!! It is a brunch HIT!!!

White Peach Proof Syrup

Gary G.

Ok so new to Proof Sent the Master Set to a good friend, he went crazy said it was the best stuff he has ever had. So I had to grab my bottle of Maple Bacin and see if he was correct, he was.... However I did one up on him, I added a frozen orange juice ice ball in my drink. Wow is that good, now I need to order the Master Set and continue my journey

Maple Bacon Proof Syrup

Grant S.

I had purchased 3 bottles of the original Proof Syrup and gave one to my son, one to his buddy and kept one for myself. For my birthday my son and the rest of the kids gave me a $50.00 Proof gift certificate! Ready to purchase more. Thanks!

Traditional Proof Syrup

undefined review of Citrus Sour Proof Syrup image 1 out of 1

Christine L.

I bought these for my husband's birthday. We have tried the maple bacon and wanted to try more flavors. We made a margarita with the citrus and it was like I got it from a restaurant.

Citrus Sour Proof Syrup

Nick D.

Proof syrup helped create the best old fashioned I’ve had. The perfection of the syrup allows you to keep the recipe as simple as possible. Just garnish with the cherry and orange peel, mix Proof and bourbon, and your in for a hell of a good time.

Traditional Proof Syrup

undefined review of Old Fashioned Master Set image 1 out of 1

Roxanne B.

Best darn old fashion for an old fashion girl! Easy to make and even easier to drink! So easy I don’t have to ask my husband to make it! I love all the syrups and best of all to guess work! EASY PEASY!!!

Old Fashioned Master Set

Chris D.

I have been using proof with my smoked old fashioneds for a while now. There is nothing that taste better then an old fashioned with whiskey barrel smoke with bullet rye bourbon and walnut proof syrup garnished with a cherry and orange peel. Cheers friends 🍻

Old Fashioned Master Set

undefined review of Subscription Box image 1 out of 2

Fernando D.

The best mixer to make the perfect old fashion! Prefer the Traditional flavor the best. Have shared with many of my friends and they love it!

Subscription Box

Stephan L.

I first tried the Maple Bacon Proof syrup in an Old Fashioned at a local gastro pub in Blue Ridge, Georgia (Chester Brunnenmeyer's Bar & Grill). I loved it! I had to buy a few bottles for myself. Highly recommended. Credit: The picture is from their web site.

Maple Bacon Proof Syrup

undefined review of Rosemary Proof Syrup image 1 out of 1

Matt B.

My wife bought the mini old fashioned and classic cocktail syrups. They have good flavor, so we deuces to get the botanicals. Rosemary has a ton of flavor and makes a great cocktail. It’s great trying new cocktails with these syrups.

Rosemary Proof Syrup

undefined review of Traditional image 1 out of 1

Robert P.

Delicious! I've been using Proof syrups for some time and they've never disappointed! A little goes a long way, but a smidge more...yum!

Traditional

Vicki D.

I LOVE old fashions with a shot of amaretto! This picture is all I have left in tonight's drink! Poof syrup makes concocting these so easy, I enjoy them more than ever. Not having to make the simple syrup and get the bitters just right is a dream!

Traditional Proof Syrup

Heather B.

Love it! Bought some for my husband for Christmas. It was a big hit! So I got some for my dad for his birthday, another big hit! Will definitely be trying some of the other flavors soon.

Traditional Proof Syrup

Paul P.

My nephew loves old fashioneds so Proof was his gift... but I also bought one and it’s great....better and less sticky than home made... mine is made with a different “twist” as my wife ate my Friday orange :)

Traditional Proof Syrup

Lindsey M.

My husband and I absolutely LOVE Proof Syrup! The night we received our first bottle we made ourselves a drink and within minutes we purchased 5 more bottles! We definitely have plans to purchase more in the very near future. Makes for great gifts also!! Give this a 10/10!

Traditional Proof Syrup

Megan R.

My husband LOVES this stuff. I was initially skeptical about buying something from an Instagram ad.... but it’s SO good! You won’t regret it! Can’t wait to try other flavors!

Traditional Proof Syrup

Garrett H.

Blown away! Way better than I even expected and I’ve had a lot of Old Fashioneds in my day. Couldn’t be easier to make. Can’t wait to try them all! Instead of wine, my wife and I are giving out Proof Syrup as housewarming gifts from now on.

Traditional Proof Syrup

Aisha P.

We love this! I ordered the original syrup for my fiancé’s Christmas gift and let’s just say that it hasn’t lasted long! It simplifies making his favorite drink. We can’t wait to order more!

Traditional Proof Syrup

Alice A.

Love this so much. First time I used it I didn’t realize how sweet it is so I just cut back on it and squeezed half of an orange in it, topped it off with a cherry and good to go!

Traditional Proof Syrup

Chris G.

I bought a Master's Kit and loved it so much, I bought five more as Christmas gifts. These kits have incredible syrups, but the presentation as a gift makes it unstoppable. Can't recommend enough.

Old Fashioned Master Set

Matt C.

Not the best shot but I do love it. I think the directions make it a bit sweet so I just double the whisky and it's great. Thanks for making old fashioneds so easy!

Traditional Proof Syrup

Rick C.

Amazing taste and eliminates the guesswork or the need for multiple bottles of different ingredients. Would be nice if Proof included a half ounce cap to use when mixing to ensure the right amount! I’ll order again! -Rick

Traditional Proof Syrup

undefined review of Maple Bacon image 1 out of 1

Jeremy B.

Proof Syrup adds the perfect touch to any bourbon! Maple Bacon is my favorite, but I look forward to branching out and trying more flavors!

Maple Bacon

Tom O.

So good I have to make two. My wife loves the old fashions I make. I put it in a shaker with a splash of water! Shake vigorously and the awesome begins!

Traditional Proof Syrup

Mark G.

This photo was taken during the Texas rolling blackouts of the February winter storms of 2021. And we passed the time by making the best no fuss old-fashioneds with Proof Syrup. Soooo goood!

Traditional Proof Syrup

James M.

Love the taste, quality, and simplicity of Proof syrups. My first was with a great whiskey from the Belle Meade. Lately, I’ve been pairing the syrup with Knob Creek Smoked Maple to amp up the smoke (and the maple goes great with bacon)! Can’t wait to try more varieties of Proof Syrup!

Maple Bacon Proof Syrup

Amanda H.

Delish! I’m typically not a fan of pre-made mixtures but this one tastes as though it was made from scratch. I’ll definitely be purchasing the other flavors. Money well spent.

Traditional Proof Syrup

Michael P.

What a relief! Proof Syrup is a Godsend! We used its religiously during the holidays to speed up the drink making process during holiday gatherings. The taste and quality is exceptional. Has none of that "commercial, conveyor belt" taste. As a result, we created several new Proof customers. Add to it, your customer service is amazing. Congratulations on your success!

Traditional Proof Syrup

Randi A.

After discovering a love for Old Fashioneds late in life, I soon discovered a distaste (laziness??) for making them from scratch. Was so glad to discover Proof! I hardly order them out any longer, because having them at home is so much better. The consistency has always been there. Thank you.

Traditional

Jay J.

I was wasn't sure about this syrup at first. However, I made the Maple-Bacon Manhattan and it was excellent. I even fried up a bacon strip like the recipe called for as a garnish and I was surprised. Making them all the time now!

Maple Bacon Proof Syrup

Proof Syrup ReviewsMore details