Proof Syrup Reviews

Elisabeth M.

I really like this syrup a lot. I have tried several Old Fashioned syrups and this one is right up there. I find I like it better used with rye than with bourbon, but that is my personal preference. I do use an orange garnish and sometimes I will add extra bitters, both regular Angostura and sometimes orange, too.

Elizabeth C.

It took awhile to arrive (peak Christmas season when I ordered it)but it arrived the day before Christmas and I was SO excited to give it to my husband as one of his gifts. He opened it on Christmas morning and it slipped out of his hands and shattered ALL over cream colored carpet (it hit into a bottle of bourbon). I can’t speak on taste, but it smelled absolutely delicious. Bummed we couldn’t try.

David D.

it took almost 4 weeks to receive my order but when it finally arrived I must admit I really love it, I'm a little worried about ordering again due to the amount of complaints I see on FB I would like to try the sampler box

Alyson L.

I bought this for my husband for Christmas and he loved it! I bought a second bottle and will probably keep buying them! He says this makes the best Old Fashioned!

Stephanie K.

Absolutely delicious! Bought as a gift for my husband who loves an Old Fashioned but they’re tedious to make. This syrup is better than anything we’ve ever made. It’s also fantastic in a gin and tonic! We’ve already bought a second bottle.

Kathleen P.

I bought it this time for my son in laws for Christmas. The cap on one was broken. I notified customer service and a new bottle was shipped. Best customer service.

Chris B.

Ok so the best old fashion I ever had was at the Saint Regis..... now it is in my den. I love this stuff. You’ve hit a Home Run... Well done

Glenn F.

Delicious and so easy. I used less than you suggest because it is a bit sweet, but I do have family who prefer the sweeter taste. Will certainly try other flavors. So glad I found you!!

Ann B.

This makes a wonderful cocktail. Perfect when entertaining as it makes the bar run smoothly. My first bottle was broken in shipment and the company quickly responded and replaced with a new bottle and discount. I am happy to give a five star review!

Pete M.

Product is great -- your supply chain needs help. I'm sure its nothing that you don't already know but its taking weeks to receive orders. You are likely costing yourselves orders at this point.

Justin G.

Love this stuff. So easy to use, just one bottle has everything in it! Half oz is all it takes. I've bought 2 bottles and bought another as a gift.

David S.

I got Proof for my husband, he really likes his Old Fashions. He was skeptical but then impressed. He said it really is all you need to add to bourbon for a good Old Fashion. We’ll definitely continue our patronage.

Rob I.

The product is great. The taste is the perfect combination of sweet and spice, HOWEVER, the shipping has a lot to be desired. I waited over a month for an order in November and am still waiting for an order in December - it's mid-January now. They have a good product but need to step up production and shipping.

Ben M.

Been wanting to try an old fashioned for some time but didn’t want to have to go through all the steps lol. With 80 proof I usually just drink on ice. But I love using Proof syrup with 100 proof. Takes the edge off and I was surprised at the complexity of the flavor. And obviously easy to use and mix. After “Dry January” I plan to order more

Susan S.

I purchased 3 bottles: one for each of my sons, and one for me! I use Maker's Mark for my bourbon, so each of the boys got a bottle of that as well as 2 engraved short glasses (from Etsy). We opened my bottle and enjoyed it Christmas night. It was phenomenal!!! I will definitely try another flavor when we order again.

Robert J.

Bought as a Christmas gift for my wife who really enjoys Old Fashions. She said it tasted like it was made at a good bar - she really liked it! Great job on the recipe!

Nanci R.

I got Proof syrup for my husband as a Christmas gift because he loves old fashioneds. I mixed it with Woodford Reserve, added a orange twist, and it was fabulous!!! He has thoroughly enjoyed each and every one I’ve made for him!!

Susan C.

My husband and son in laws love it! Making an Old Fashioned was a process mixing everything together but you have simplified the process. We still put the glass over the smoking plank and add the orange rind but the process is definitely streamlined.

Bethany S.

My brother discovered it, asked for it for Christmas and I ordered him a bottle but it was placed on back order because they are a starter company for this patent formula and I forgot I ordered it and got my brother something different for Christmas so I ended up giving the bottle to my husband and we both loved it. Bottle number one is gone, about to start #2. Don’t worry we invite the brother over to try a cocktail or two.

Margeaux M.

Finally an all in one syrup for making an old fashioned at home with out making simple syrup and buying the bitters separately. I've already enjoyed the proof syrup in several cocktails. Will purchase again.

Jen A.

My husband LOVED this! He finished it in 2 nights (the second night he had help). When I asked if he'd like me to get him another, he replied, "um I'm going to buy a case!" I'm glad I could surprise him with something he likes so much.

Anita S.

Bought this as a gift for my husband who loves an occasional Old Fashioned cocktail. Unfortunately, he rarely gets one he thinks is really good and says no one knows how to make one anymore. I’m not sure he had high expectations, but he said this syrup makes a great drink! We were both happy! Thanks for a great product.

Susan S.

Love your products but not happy with your service. Ordered second bottle December 17 and have never received nor had a response to my inquiries as to the status which shows unfulfilled but paid.

Scott J.

Purchased Proof original Old fashion mix for the holidays. This is the finest Old Fashion that I have had and I have had many. I since have ordered the 6 bottle assortment pack. Waiting for it to be delivered. Highly recommend Proof to my friends and family.

Lisa H.

Love this amazing product! Making Old Fashions has never been easier! So delicious! Best of all I have time to be with my guests rather than mixing and muddling cocktails all night.

Ed M.

Second purchase of proof syrup old fashion. It tastes amazing and takes the guesswork out of adding other ingredients to the drink. An orange rind and a cheery and you have perfection,