I was unable to get my dog to take it in. I've tried it in milk, lovely steak, soup, stews, sauces, even with a syringe directly into his mouth. I've ordered the peanut butter flavor as he loves peanut butter, and peanut butter flavored biscuits, etc. but after countless attempts, I gave up. He is a bulldog and loves anything he can eat except cucumber but unfortunately decided to rather go 2 consecutive days without eating but refused to eat anything with the Camelus. Sorry