Cardholder C.Verified
Getting the package actually shipped took a bit long, but was quick in the shipping, and arrived before the holidays
Purchased item
coffee & smut t-shirt
"Girl I bought it for loved it"
probably smut store reviewsSee product reviews
Amy L.Verified
Na
Purchased item
personalization
"My husband bought a me the largest amount of..."
Kimberly M.Verified
No
Purchased item
monster sticker pack special
"I wish these had a little bit more design ele..."
Rayann S.Verified
Absolutely enjoyed
Purchased item
shameless sticker pack special
"Absolutely love I made a phone case out of th..."
Judy I.Verified
I wasn’t able to track when they would be arriving otherwise it was a good experience
Purchased item
romantasy sticker pack special
"I love the stickers! Just haven’t figured out..."
Rayna S.Verified
N/A
Purchased item
book girlie sticker pack special
"The stickers were exactly as pictured!"
Carrie K.Verified
Excellent
Purchased item
dark romance sticker pack special
"Loved them all"
Ashley L.Verified
The shipping takes a long time. I wish I could get my book the month of the book club, I often get my book the beginning or even middle of the following month and it's disappointing to get my November book half way through December, for example.
Purchased item
good girl book club subscription
"I enjoy the stories, but the cover designs an..."
Jessica F.Verified
s
Purchased item
cowboys for christmas sweatshirt
"Arrived quickly and was the perfect fit. Love..."
Ana G.Verified
.
Purchased item
Bride & Mate Overlay Art Prints [NSFW]
"Never disappointed with PS subscriptions.
Qu..."
Jessica Y.Verified
Love my orders from ProbablySmut!
Purchased item
monster why-choose
"Love these books so much! ProbablySmut always..."
Heaven H.Verified
Great company!
Purchased item
Bride & Mate Overlay Art Prints [NSFW]
"Very lovely set. They scandalized my mom!"
Leigh L.Verified
I love this subscription and all their product!
Purchased item
good girl clear phone case
"Super cute! Fits my phone great and I just l..."
Rebecca F.Verified
Everything was good
Purchased item
checkered books and heart knitted cardigan (pink)
"Got lots of compliments on this cute cardigan..."
Alexia S.Verified
Love the option to skip if need be.
Purchased item
good girl book club subscription
"Great prices and great covers! I real love wh..."
Joshua L.Verified
👍
Purchased item
book club sticker pack special
"👍👍"
Kelly S.Verified
First box was so awesome
Purchased item
good girl book club subscription
"I loved my first box so much that I put my na..."
Taylor B.Verified
Probably Smut is great I love the interactions and the kindness recived any time I've had a issue with an item not showing properly in my orders. The way the company promotes themselves and allows others in the book community to come together is awesome!
Purchased item
introvert hoodie
"I got another one of these for my mom aa she..."
Grace C.Verified
Very nice service and options for books! My only negative is the waiting time! I wanted the books to be here the next day!
Purchased item
mafia rom-com
"This book was a slow burn and so very nice!!"
Danielle D.Verified
Fast shipping and super communicative!
Purchased item
what are you reading/PS logo sweatshirt
"This is the most comfortable sweatshirt I own..."
Jennie H.Verified
Love probably smut for all my bookish accessories!
Purchased item
romantasy sticker pack
"Love these stickers! They are perfect to give..."
Tiffani M.Verified
The whole pick your own book box was underwhelming. I preordered 3 books, $30 each essentially and they have cute covers, came in a cute box, but that’s it. No printed edges, no extras, no bookmark, nothing. Packed nice but not worth $30/book. I bought this as a Christmas present for myself and it wasn’t worth it.
Purchased item
hockey romance
"Book was good, cover was cute. Very predictab..."
Ana G.Verified
Love the concept, the emails and obviously the books!!
Purchased item
dark ballet
"Review more of the books that are being selec..."
Lauren V.Verified
Love everything PS - the packaging was beautiful, quality of the books and extra details and communication from start to finish getting the whole set of books.
Purchased item
taboo romance
"Dark and steamy! Definitelyyyy check TW but I..."
Melanie F.Verified
So happy I found this subscription!! Love the community that comes with it ☺️
Purchased item
good girl book club subscription
"Love this subscription!! Beautiful book and w..."
Bethany S.Verified
Great customer service, detailed tracking, and everything arrived well packaged!
Purchased item
good girl book club subscription
"I was super impressed with everything I recei..."
Kasey D.Verified
I can’t wait for my next order
Purchased item
small town cowboy
"I love the book I got and I was very pleased..."
Jennifer V.Verified
Amazing experience and products!
Purchased item
griffin antiquities sweatshirt
"Cozy perfection in a sweatshirt ✨️"
Rebecca R.Verified
Great stickers. Cool sayings. Awesome gifts.♡♡♡♡♡☆☆☆☆☆
Purchased item
feminist sticker pack special
"My gal pals love these!!! And I will be purch..."
Joanne S.Verified
Quick shipping, high quality products.
Purchased item
you do not yield vintage hat
"Super cute hat, exactly as pictured. High qua..."
Amanda H.Verified
Great site and always helpful and friendly service!!
Purchased item
happiness is a book embroidered sweatshirt
"Great quality and soft sweatshirt, love it!!"
Shawnice K.Verified
Nope :)
Purchased item
book tree sweatshirt
"Cozy, comfy, and so cute. Wore it to work (th..."
Michelle E.Verified
False advertising
Purchased item
single dad X nanny
"Very disappointed in Probably Smut. The book..."
Hailey S.Verified
You guys are absolutely amazing!!!
Purchased item
good girl book club subscription
"I love this book box! You guys are the best a..."
Patricia G.Verified
Nope!
Purchased item
good girl book club subscription
"Love the sub and price overall but would love..."
Jillian A.Verified
Great stickers
Purchased item
sticker advent box 2025
"Great stickers and no duplicate stickers!"
Leslie R.Verified
I have looked and wanted to buy so many things over the last year ans finally just did it. Will def be getting more in the future
Purchased item
drink coffee read smut be happy sweatshirt
"Love it"
Lisa C.Verified
Fun! Fun! Fun!
Purchased item
all i want for christmas is books/book tree t-shirt
"Great shirt! Fit well"
Nathan B.Verified
Great store
Purchased item
greatest hits sticker pack
"Wife loved the stickers. A little small but m..."
Cara C.Verified
I already experience shipping issues and timely deliveries with multiple subscription boxes.
I don’t want to deal with even more and was hopeful that PS would be different.
Purchased item
good girl book club subscription
"It is December 27th. I’m still waiting for th..."
probably smut store reviewsVisit store