I decided to give this a go and see if it was as good as my maybelline tatoo eyeliner for my Smokey eyes. I’m pretty impressed, it’s a really deep black, goes on well but I find I do need to smudge it straight away as it sets quickly into a hard line, but it does tell you that. I find it seems to last reasonably well too, all day but if I use it as a kohl it does wear off. I like it and overall it’s pretty waterproof. If it blended as well as my usual pencil it would have got 5stars.