Beloved Cheesecakes Reviews

Beloved Cheesecakes ReviewsSee store reviews

Donald F.Verified

Having spent the 1st part of my working life in marketing in NYC, (Pepsi) id rate your Customer Service as high as your product! . NY is a tough mkt, as you know, we have several world famous cheesecake bakers. I suspect you got their recipe, because your cheesecakes are as good as theirs, maybe better. Thank Jan for starting Beloved, while raising 3 boys, I've done both, its not easy. The Lord has guided you, your are an example of what faith & grit can accomplish!👏👏👏👏🌹🌹🌹God Bless, Don Fitch,ms...

Ultimate Cheesecake Sampler

Jeffrey P.Verified

You guys are so bad, I seen all the fancy pictures. However, I wasn't prepared for this Cheesecake experience. So there won't be any pictures this time around, as My Cheesecake is already gone. Thank you so much for everything, it was definitely worth the wait.. ~Jeff

Salted Caramel Cheesecake

Lauren G.Verified

The owners called when they were concerned that it may take longer than I expected for the cheesecake to arrive (I live on the other side of the country). They waited until I confirmed I was good with the arrival date before finalizing the order. Cheesecake was delicious! Definitely worth the wait.

OG Cheesecake Sampler

Karen S.Verified

The white chocolate raspberry cheesecake with the gluten free crust was a huge hit for our family's dual birthday celebration 🎂 We have also had the keto strawberry and keto key lime which were absolutely incredible!! Beloved Cheesecake is our go to for our sweet treat!

White Chocolate Raspberry Cheesecake

Nathan T.Verified

The wait was slightly longer than expected, however I believe there was a trememendous amount of orders and a growth spurt which is understandable for small family owned businesses. I will be a repeat customer and highly recommend their products. The taste was amazing. My wife and I enjoyed every flavor even our less desired ones were a treat.

Ultimate Cheesecake Sampler

Merridee D.Verified

I ordered the variety cheesecake for my husband. It arrived yesterday from Oregan, to ElDorado, Arkansas yesterday.Wednesday, March 25th. The dry ice was melted, but the cheesecake was still very cold, and beautiful. My husband ate TWO pieces when he finally got off work(ER nurse), around 10:30pm. He tried the chocolate mint and the raspberry. He LOVED both slices. I ordered it because I loved your story.We are soooo proud of your strong faith, and wish you much co ntinued success. I have told s...

Ultimate Cheesecake Sampler

Phil P.Verified

The cheesecake came wrapped to the max and protected in the box very well. It was fresh and ready to eat right out of the box. Very smooth with a great taste. No complaints only complaints.

Salted Caramel Cheesecake

Kimberly M.Verified

When I ordered, I was a little surprised that it would take a month before I would receive my order. But it was worth the wait. I shared the cheesecake sampler with my coworkers, having each chose the flavor they wanted. EVERY SINGLE one LOVED it! Thank you so much!!! K. Merritt. Parkersburg, WV

Ultimate Cheesecake Sampler

Kenneth A.Verified

Hello, I ordered the OG Sampler for my wife’s birthday. She was pleasantly surprised and shocked that I thought about anything other than a traditional birthday cake. ( We have been married 50 years). We opened the box and tried a bite of each style. My favorite was the Salted Caramel and she loved the Key Lime. Best Cheesecake Ever ! The grandkids loved it and they don’t like anything ! Will order again. Thanks, Ken

OG Cheesecake Sampler

Dewana B.Verified

I haven't cut the cheesecake yet but I wish I would have got it pre-cut it looks delicious and I'm saving it for Thanksgiving but as soon as I get it cut and eaten up I will send you another review My husband loves cheesecake

Salted Caramel Cheesecake

Bridget T.Verified

I ordered in support of this business and received possibly the best cheesecake I've ever tried. The sampler was beautiful. I was able to try 2 different flavors before my coworkers devoured the rest! Thank you for a wonderful cake, but more importantly for your stand in this crazy world we live in.

Ultimate Cheesecake Sampler

Kathy F.Verified

I received a call from the owners that my order might be a bit delayed due to an overwhelming number of orders but was my cheesecake for a special occasion and needed right away. Mine was just to try so I had no problem pushing my order out. Who does that anymore? Calls to check if needed right away! Such wonderful customer care. And of course we chatted a bit. Then I received my cheesecake! It is delicious! Really delicious! Many more to come for sure!

Seasonal Cheesecake - Marionberry

Tracy B.Verified

The cheesecakes were delicious! Creamy, full of flavor! OMGoodness 🥰 And I thank you for the personal call I received advising on the status of my shipment and the handwritten note! I will be ordering again for sure! May God continue to bless your company and employees with peace and success! Tracy Brown, Arizona

Cheesecake Sampler

Mary B.Verified

Thank you for the best Birthday Cake ever! It actually was the Marion-Berry and purchased! I shared it widely and brought smiles to many friends. I also got a free birthday slice of the Pumpkin 🎃… also delicious! You and your staff do a first class job! God Bless you. 🙏🏼 and God Bless America. 🇺🇸

Seasonal Cheesecake - Pumpkin

Russell M.Verified

Came across a social media post claiming to be the best cheesecake. I ordered out of curiosity and I feel like I’m somewhat of a cheesecake connoisseur. This cheesecake really is worth the hype. It is heavy in the box and feels like it’s going to be dense but you put your fork in and you get this airy, fluffy and incredibly delicious flavor. The fruit topping on top was so good. Not too sweet or processed tasting. Just spend the money get this cake and watch everyone indulge with pleasure. Highl...

New York Style Cheesecake

Stacy D.Verified

My husband made a chocolate , peanut butter cheesecake for my birthday every year before he died and this cheesecake was a beautiful walk down memory lane. Very light and creamy with a great peanut butter taste. Loved it.

Peanut Butter Butterfinger Cheesecake

Greg R.Verified

I was a little skeptical when I first saw your ad for "the best cheesecake" and I thought it was a little expensive, BUT it arrived perfectly and still cool. After trying it, you are ABSOLUTELY right, the flavors were incredible and it IS the best cheesecake I've ever had, and well worth the price. I will definitely be ordering on a regular basis!!!

Cheesecake Sampler

Katerina N.Verified

Was referred to Beloved Cheesecakes by a good friend for my daughter’s 24th birthday. Everyone raved about them. The Salted Caramel was the hit of the party. I would definitely recommend this company for your special occasion. ♥️

White Chocolate Raspberry Cheesecake

Karen S.Verified

Thank you so much! It is so very good. I actually had a slice for breakfast—- You make it very easy from ordering to receiving. Thank you all so very much. Karen Sabin

Salted Caramel Cheesecake

Sue W.Verified

I sent one of your cheesecakes to my Brother for his birthday. He liked it so much, he sent one to me for my birthday. After one taste of your glorious cheesecake, I decided this would be my very special go to gift for my family and friends. Without a doubt, this is the best tasting cheesecake I have ever had and I am 80 years old and use to make cheesecakes myself.

New York Style Cheesecake

Andrea B.Verified

Excellent customer service… I forgot to put in my new customer code, and they said they would gladly honor the discount when I called! Very nice people and a very classy thing to do.

Salted Caramel Cheesecake

Robin N.Verified

We have devoured 3 of the 4 varieties of the cheesecake sampler (and my husband who claims to ‘not like cheesecake’ keeps asking if we were having more cheesecake for desert so that last one will soon be gone). Our favorite so far? Key Lime!

OG Cheesecake Sampler

Kathy L.Verified

The service is above and beyond and the people are lovely . Now let’s talk about how delicious and fresh the cheese cake and it arrived fresh and delicious ! This was perfectly designed and beyond yummy ! I found them through Instagram and what a treasure. I ordered 2 cheesecakes and then a mix of small ones and all were delicious , fresh , and I’m so glad I found them . Thank you also to the lovely people who work there . Can’t wait to order my next ! I’m so sorry I didn’t take photos of these...

White Chocolate Raspberry Cheesecake

Christina K.Verified

Absolutely worth every penny! Smooth, creamy, and delicious. The chocolate mint chip was fantastic. Chocolate peanut butter absolutely wonderful. I appreciate that. It’s not so sickening sweet and doesn’t stick to the roof of your mouth. Such a quality cheesecake.

Ultimate Cheesecake Sampler

Diane R.Verified

I picked the Salted Caramel cheesecake as a surprise for my husband as he's been working his buns off more than usual lately. He loved it! It was heavenly good. Absolutely scrumptious. Thank you, Jen & the Beautiful Cheesecakes team. I pray that your business continues to thrive. Bless you all, Diane

Salted Caramel Cheesecake

Patricia C.Verified

From the moment I placed the order and I received a call to confirm my order and thank me for choosing their business I was convinced I made the right decision. The cheesecake was the best I have ever had. I would definitely order again.

New York Style Cheesecake

Melinda W.Verified

The cheesecakes were delicious, arrived in great shape too. My daughter is a pastry chef and she is a tough tough customer. She LOVED them and ate most of the 4 mini's I ordered. We are total fans!!

OG Mini Cheesecakes 4" (Pack of 4)

Linda L.Verified

Review of the Peanut butter butterfinger. Delicious! I would love to send you a photo or video but after Happy Birthday was sung and the candles blown out it was cut and served. Everyone loved it. Comments were "Best Cheesecake ever" and "OMG Peanut butter" Also your packaging was perfect. It arrived frozen and your customer service is the best ever. They actually call you verify your order and explain delivery. You can tell the people that work there care and ithe cheesecake was made with love...

Peanut Butter Butterfinger Cheesecake

Shyrie W.Verified

The cheesecake was delicious and I loved every bite. I took it to work and shared with my co-workers and within 2 hours it was all gone. The taste was amazing and the thickness of the cheesecake was perfect. I had it delivered and the packaging was good and fresh. I was very happy with my cheesecake!!!

Salted Caramel Cheesecake

Kandie H.Verified

I ordered the mini cheesecakes for my daughter’s first wedding anniversary. My daughter said the cheesecakes were delicious and smooth tasting. I was truly amazed at the exceptional customer service that I received. Communication was outstanding. I will definitely be ordering again! P.S. Let me clarify, I will be ordering again, but next time I will get myself some. 😊. Debra Primeau

OG Mini Cheesecakes 4" (Pack of 4)

Victoria J.Verified

The cheesecakes were very tasty. The wait was a little long but the cheesecakes made up for it. We also ordered cakes for our kids and they enjoyed them very much. Thanks again.

Bakers Choice Mini Cheesecakes 4" (Pack of 4)

Linda P.Verified

I made an order to support this small family business that was asking through a video I came across to place an order as they needed a boost. I ordered the sampler and was so excited. Then a bunch of people perhaps seen the same video and ordered the same time I did in February. I waited and waited then I received communication that her Beloved Cheesecakes received so many orders that there would definitely be a wait that we would receive ours as soon as possible. It came April 7th and it was to...

OG Cheesecake Sampler

Karen D.Verified

We ordered our cheesecake a couple of months ago and we were waiting to have it delivered for our Easter celebration and my husband’s birthday. There were 11 of us for the celebration and we all said it was the best cheesecake we have ever had. We live in Texas and we will be ordering again. The gluten-free crust was absolutely delicious. Thank you so much for your excellent service and your delicious cheesecake.

OG Cheesecake Sampler

Rodney H.Verified

It actually worked out great getting my order the week before Easter. I waited until Easter day to break out both cheesecakes and you might have some new customers after my family tried them.

Salted Caramel Cheesecake

Barbara W.Verified

I purchased the sample cheesecake for a friend's birthday and about 9 of us sampled each slice. It was perfection! She loved it, we all did. I would highly recommend.

Ultimate Cheesecake Sampler

Jenny B.Verified

We’ve heard wonderful things about your cheesecakes, but we have not been able to try them yet. My husband completed 30 radiation treatments for his cancer and at his last treatment last week we decided to gift the Dr and his amazing staff with this treat of the sampler. They were delighted to receive this to share with each other! Makes a great gift & we hope to get to get one and sample it ourselves!!!

Ultimate Cheesecake Sampler

Tina J.Verified

The cheesecake was frozen when it left the shop and still frozen when I received it. It was packaged really well. It was easy to thaw out a section but hard to wait for it to thaw. We are trying one section at a time. And it is so good. We had the lemon one first and I cut it in four pieces so we could all try it. It was delicious and so wonderful. We are going to try another section next week.

Bakers Choice Cheesecake Sampler

Cynthia T.Verified

Your cheesecake was waiting for me at my door. Took it in and immediately opened the box. Couldn’t wait to share it with my grandson. He loved it, too. Thank you for a delicious Key Lime Pie cheesecake.

Key Lime Cheesecake

Katherine M.Verified

Our cheesecake arrived on the day we planned. It was frozen. We waited and it was ready for our dessert. Delish! My next one will have pics! Had a trip planned the next day! But it was lemon and we all loved it in Connecticut.

Lemon Cheesecake

Kasey H.Verified

This gluten free sampler cheesecake is the bomb!!!! The pieces are HUGE and the cheesecake itself is so good, but, the gluten free crust, oh my, I'm so in love!! I don't know what the regular crusts are like, but for once I feel like mine's better than yours!! :) Will definitely order again, so good and I love the handwritten note. Clearly it's made, packaged and handled with love and care!!

OG Cheesecake Sampler

Beloved Cheesecakes ReviewsVisit store