This is the BEST mascara I have I’m ever used, and I have used so many of the supposed best mascaras! I love the tube mascara, and My Amazing Lashes mascara definitely outperforms Thrive in: longevity, lengthening and volumizing, staying power/no flaking or smudging, and being water resistant. I am a life-long fan, and I recommend this to all my friends. Excellent job Wow Combo! Thank you for making the absolute best mascara on the market!