I don’t often write reviews, but had to write one for this mascara! Absolutely delighted with it! My eyelashes are so short, but this really lengthens them, and isn’t clumpy at all. I also usually look like a panda at the end of the day, even with waterproof mascara, but this doesn’t smudge at all! I don’t put much on, but I imagine if you layer it up that you’ll get the false eyelash look. Have already ordered more!