This is the best mascara I have ever used. I have thin, and short lashes. My lashes look so much thicker and longer w/this product. I just has a friend of mine try it. Her rt eye waters and she rubs off her mascara. She loves this mascara and when I order, she will share the cost w/ me, so I will be ordering more often, And for those who complain about it being hard to wash off, I just use vaseline and it easily comes off using a kleenex. Thank you so much for this awesome mascara. Linda