Shoe Bakery Reviews - 733 Reviews | shoebakery.com

Shoe Bakery Reviews

Name: Shoe Bakery
Rating: 4.9

Customer photo review of Bake-a-Shoe Ice Cream Heel 4"

Jamie B.

In love with my custom shoes for my upcoming wedding in October. Everyone is going to be in awe. I have a wide range of items from shoebakery and this is my 1st pair of custom shoes. They are even more beautiful in person. All the detail is outstanding

Bake-a-Shoe Ice Cream Heel 4"

Customer photo review of Bake-A-Bag Charcoal Sprinkle Flap

Katie H.

I absolutely love this bag. I have the slightly larger one already and loved that one so much, I wanted the slightly smaller one. Thank you so much for some amazing products.

Bake-A-Bag Charcoal Sprinkle Flap

Customer photo review of Rainbow Cake Wedges 2.5"

Rachel L.

These shoes are so beautiful and I was so excited to wear them on my wedding day. I discovered the Shoe Bakery about 13 years ago and I had said that if I ever got married, these would be the shoes I would wear...and it happened! I was worried the shoes wouldn't arrive in time and the Shoe Bakery were amazing and so patient with me emailing them about an EDD. They came beautifully packaged and in the nick of time...about a week before our wedding.

Rainbow Cake Wedges 2.5"

Customer photo review of Unicorn Cake Bag

Christina S.

The Shoe Bakery Unicorn Bag is absolutely stunning! The vibrant, magical design makes it the prettiest accessory you could own. It’s not just about looks, though—this bag is built to last. The high-quality material feels sturdy yet soft, and it holds up perfectly even with daily use. I love that it doubles as a backpack, making it super practical for those days when you need your hands free. It’s the perfect blend of style and functionality, and I couldn’t be happier with this magical piece!

Unicorn Cake Bag

Customer photo review of Triple Chocolate Wedges

Sarah W.

I am absolutely obsessed! I have wanted “cake” shoes for years and finally got my first pair. 🙌 they are everything I ever wanted. Or only are they adorable, but surprisingly comfortable. I work on my feet all day and was able to make it through by 7 hour shift without issues. I couldn’t be happier. I can’t wait to add to my collection with another pair.

Triple Chocolate Wedges

Customer photo review of Limited Edition Pumpkin Pie 2.5'' Heels

Jennifer B.

Adore these pumpkin pie heels! I wish it were autumn again already and I can't wait to show them off next Thanksgiving! This is my third purchase from Shoe Bakery, I love their shoes, bags, etc. and they've also been very helpful and responsive when I've had issues or had any questions about orders

Limited Edition Pumpkin Pie 2.5’’ Heels

Customer photo review of Limited Edition Pumpkin Pie Flats

Lilliana R.

These shoes are AMAZING! Everyone loved them and they are well made, shipping does take some time but for the quality and the unique factor of these shoes they are totally worth it!

Limited Edition Pumpkin Pie Flats

Miguel P.

I’ve been wanting this bag for years and I finally decided to do it JUST GOT IT! It’s so beautiful and perfect. A great size! Not too big and NOT too small and the fact that you can use it as a side bag and or back pack it so amazing! I am in love! So easy to clean and although it’s a unicorn (which I absolutely love) it’s also elegant! Perfect for any age 🩷💜🩵 @Beautifulstrugglexoxo

Unicorn Cake Bag

Customer photo review of Ice Cream Jays Sneakers

Sunni D.

I can't believe how amazing these are! I got so many compliments when I wore them. They truly a work of art and great quality. Worth the price and the wait. I love them so much! I can't wait to buy another pair.

Ice Cream Jays Sneakers

Customer photo review of Bake-A-Bag Large Base

June E.

I love the pink bag and confetti sprinkles flap. The snap closure requires a bit of alignment to close, but maybe after bag is broken in… really have to press on it to get it to snap shut. Other than that, cool look, great crossbody bag.

Bake-A-Bag Large Base

Customer photo review of All Pink Cake Wedges

Sarah W.

I LOVE my cakes! A little taller than I would normally wear but with a little determination and practice I am able to wear them the entire day. The kids in my practice love them and they bring lots of smiles through out the day. Life is too short not to have cake. 💁‍♀️

All Pink Cake Wedges

Customer photo review of Red Velvet Chunk Heels

Doris C.

These shoes are soooooooo comfortable! I thought that beauty and comfort could not coexist, but I'm delighted to be proved wrong! I wore them all day to class and my feet felt great! I also got tons of compliments *wink-wink*. I love these, my newest babies!!!!! <3<3<3

Red Velvet Chunk Heels

Customer photo review of Bake-A-Shoe AF1 Sneaker

Samaah W.

I am absolutely obsessed with my new shoes! I loved how easy it was to customize every aspect of the shoe. It was fun to pick the colors/sprinkles to put on the shoes. The shoes came out just like how I designed it online. I will admit shipping took a while but the end product was definitely worth it.

Bake-A-Shoe AF1 Sneaker

Customer photo review of Pink Rainbow Sprinkle Mask

Ashlie S.

I love this mask! It’s so adorable, & comfy too! Good breathability. Nothing like making the best of wearing a mask by having one that’s as cute as it is functional!

Pink Rainbow Sprinkle Mask

Customer photo review of Pink Syrup Ice Cream Flats

Atlas M.

Let me just say... you need these shoes! I love them so much. They are comfy and made really well. Also they smell good. Beauty and quality.... I can’t wait to get another pair. (This is from the girlfriend that received them as a gift)

Pink Syrup Ice Cream Flats

Customer photo review of Love Cookie Unisex Sweatshirt

Autumn R.

This is amazing I loved the Gingerbread theme for Christmas and that collection was beautiful I wanted them to come out with something for Valentines Day and they finally did hope to see what they have for us in store for Easter hope it’s more stuff like mugs , sweatshirts and shirts and has to do with carrot cake. The fit it perfect and it’s a heavy blend material that is comfortable recommend as a cute Valentine’s Day gift for yourself or someone special in your life cookie lovers for sure sho...

Love Cookie Unisex Sweatshirt

Customer photo review of Bake-A-Shoe Sprinkle Flat

Regina W.

OMG!!! They are gorgeous. They were well worth the wait!!! I can’t wait to wear them someplace nice!!! Shoe Bakery you are awesome! I discovered your company through an article in the NY Post. (I live in Maine but am a NY girl at heart.). These will go over big in NY and if this pandemic nightmare ever ends, I plan to wear them on my next visit. Thanks again for the great surprise!

Bake-A-Shoe Sprinkle Flat

Customer photo review of Neapolitan Mint Sneakers

Stephanie H.

These shoes were absolutely amazing and so stunning to see and experience in person! These particular shoes run a little large so I had to go a half size down. Overall, they are a real conversation starter! They are comfortable to walk around in all day and I had so many excited reactions when I sported them around the classroom. These were my first pair and I look forward to buying others in the future!

Neapolitan Mint Sneakers

Stacy F.

I love my Shoe Bakery shoes! These are the sweetest, funniest flats and I giggle every time I look at them. The cherry is the best part - it's so realistic! They shipped ahead of schedule, but would have been worth the original wait time. What a unique business! I heard about them on the Tamron Hall show. If you're on the fence about ordering these shoes, just do it - they will bring you joy!

Bake-A-Shoe Sprinkle Flat

Customer photo review of Ice Cream Flats

Jennifer K.

Shipping was super fast. The shoes arrived way earlier than expected. The details of the shoe are even more amazing in person; beyond my expectations. The sizing was a bit hard because I have 6.5 wide feet. I went up to 7, which does fit more like a 7.5, so it is a little big. I’m glad I went with that because I believe if I had gone down a size, the shoe would probably be too narrow. Will definitely be back for more dessert shoes in the future!

Ice Cream Flats

Customer photo review of Just Add Sprinkles Towel

Autumn R.

Such a huge beautiful donut love the material nice and soft and feels worth it for the price it’s a huge towel perfect for the beach or to sit on the towel on the sand.

Just Add Sprinkles Towel

Chirag M.

I loved loved loved my new shoe <3 It was perfect for my expectations and super super cute to look at .. Fitting wise it was a little loose but not something I cannot manage :) So overall I love it and thank you for such a creative product. Can't wait to flaunt it <3

Bake-A-Shoe Sprinkle Flat

Customer photo review of Baked and Ready Pink Syrup Ice Cream Heel sz 8.5

Jessi M.

These shoes are adorable and I’ve always wanted a pair. The coloring is so cute and you can really see all the love and care that goes into these shoes. They’re beautiful and I can’t wait to show them off.

Baked and Ready Pink Syrup Ice Cream Heel sz 8.5

Theresa F.

I absolutely love these shoes these are the most adorable shoes. The quality is amazing and comfortable. I highly recommend. I can't wait to dress up and go out in these.

Bake-A-Shoe Sprinkle Flat

Customer photo review of Baked and Ready Teal and Pink Cake Wedge sz 7.5 2.5"

Amy F.

I am in love with these shoes! They fit perfectly and are super comfortable. The colors are so bright and the cake looks so real. I am obsessed. The 2.5 inch wedges are not too high that you can't walk in them. I already know I will be getting more wedges because I am addicted, but these ones are super cute and fun!

Baked and Ready Teal and Pink Cake Wedge sz 7.5 2.5"

Amy F.

These are so adorable! They are perfect! They seem well-made and comfortable and soooo cute! I did size up to an 8 because it said to if you were a half size you might want to (I'm normally a 7.5) and they are just the slightest bit big, but I think if I went down a size they'd be too small! I will be getting more because I just love the look and the whole concept. I'm addicted!

Pink Syrup Ice Cream Flats

Keriann W.

These are so adorable and look even cuter in real life! The fit was true to size for me. I appreciate they came in individual protective bags to help keep them delicious looking!

Bake-A-Shoe Sprinkle Flat

Customer photo review of Bake-A-Bag Large

Katie S.

I am thoroughly impressed with the attention-to-detail of this company. Each item in my order was individually wrapped and protected, and the oven-shaped box it all arrives in was just too cute. Wonderful customer service. Amazing quality. Thank you!!

Bake-A-Bag Large

Customer photo review of Bake-A-Shoe Sprinkle Flat - Customer's Product with price 90.00 ID TwWMyRtKX2CZlhUbLiS1Fy7Y

Zoe D.

This is my third pair of sprinkle shoes - I obviously love them so much that I couldn’t swap out of my flip flops before taking a picture to show my husband 😂

Bake-A-Shoe Sprinkle Flat - Customer’s Product with price 90.00 ID TwWMyRtKX2CZlhUbLiS1Fy7Y

Ariel D.

Love my card holder!! I got it to hold my business cards in my purse and it’s perfect and so cute 🥰 perfect for anyone but especially a cake decorator/ future bakery owner

Cardholders

Holly D.

My daughter LOVES her shoes and I love my purse. Soooo many compliments! I tried to see if you would donate a small item to their school auction baskets. If you can, that would be amazing! You would also be listed as a donor in their vendor booklet for their fundraising black-tie event! -Holly

Pink Syrup Ice Cream Flats

Amanda C.

Love the detail and quality is so much more than I expected. They will make my Halloween season complete as I add them to festive outfits. Love these and am excited to get more. Thank you for adding a little joy and levity to my year.

Bake-A-Shoe Sprinkle Flat

Customer photo review of Bake-a-Shoe Ice Cream Heel 5.5"

Ashley W.

These shoes are perfect! I have wanted a pair for years (as a cupcake baker, people have been tagging me in them online for years). I finally bought myself a present and custom ordered this pair and they are beautiful. The details are immaculate and they fit like a glove. I couldn’t be happier.

Bake-a-Shoe Ice Cream Heel 5.5"

Customer photo review of Bake-A-Shoe Ice Cream 2.5" Heel

Francesca P.

I have had my eye on Shoe Bakery for years and FINALLY splurged on my own pair of ice cream heels! It is truly a dream come true and more! The show fit true to size, was comfy to prance around in, and the design is gorgeous. It was fun to “bake my shoe” and have the come to life! Shipping was fast and made for a pleasant surprise when it arrived so quickly. I am over-the-moon with my new heels and cannot wait to wear them all around town!

Bake-A-Shoe Ice Cream 2.5" Heel

Customer photo review of Cookies and Cream Ice Cream Heels

Stephanie S.

These are even more stunning in person that I could have ever imagined!!! Amazingly comfortable too. I normally run a size 9.5 in pumps but the 10’s fit perfectly. I’m absolutely in love with them. Thank you!!!!

Cookies and Cream Ice Cream Heels

Customer photo review of Red Velvet Mary Janes

Erin B.

I have the red velvet purse, so I was beyond thrilled when these red velvet mary janes were brought back in stock! These shoes are beautiful; truley wearable works of art! Worth the wait too. ❤

Red Velvet Mary Janes

Erin B.

What a dream these shoes were to open...mmmm that sweet strawberry vanilla smell is such a nice treat. They look amazing, and the little girl inside me is screaming, "best shoes ever"! Yes, if I would've had these as a kid that would've been pretty awesome, but now as a grown up with a kiddo of my own these give me such joy. The recommendation to go a size up if you are a half size is a good one. I am a 8.5 and purchased a 9 and they fit pretty well. Will need to use a heel insert as the back o...

Pink Syrup Ice Cream Flats

Customer photo review of Ice Cream Charms

Kaitlyn M.

This is such a cute fluffy keychain. It goes perfect with my ice cream wallet and ice cream bag. I love the color and how soft it is. Great buy!

Ice Cream Charms

Customer photo review of Strawberry Scented Jimmie Sprinkle Flats

Kaitlyn C.

Ok... I’m very skeptical about ordering shoes online, because my feet are larger and a lot of the times things are not true to size. I’ve been wanting a pair of jimmy flats for years and decided to send off a quick email to the company. Not only did they respond promptly but helped me pick the proper size. The reviews said these are a larger fit, but after 2 brief emails and the assurance that if they did not fit I could return them, we decided that I would be best to go with my true size- 11 & ...

Strawberry Scented Jimmie Sprinkle Flats

Customer photo review of Love "Rainbow Cake" T-Shirt

Amanda R.

The shirt is sooooo comfy and great quality! Keep in mind that oxtail black is more of a really deep purple, but very pretty. The kitty loves the shirt too, so you know it's good :)

Love "Rainbow Cake" T-Shirt

Shoe Bakery ReviewsMore details