Masters of Mystery Reviews

Masters of Mystery ReviewsSee store reviews

Customer photo review of Christmas Murder Mystery Host Your Own Dinner Party Game Kit

Yvonne A.

We had an amazing time! We turned this into a surprise murder mystery birthday party for my husband. Everyone dressed up and brought their characters to life perfectly! I would highly recommend this game!

Christmas Murder Mystery Host Your Own Dinner Party Game Kit

Customer photo review of A Christmas Crime Murder Mystery Game Kit

Jackie C.

We had a lot of fun with this. I had this party for my daughter's 17th birthday. Her teenager friends really embraced their roles and had a lot of laughs. The adults had fun too. My college age son had some funny lines that really had us laughing. It was great, thank you!

A Christmas Crime Murder Mystery Game Kit

Customer photo review of 1920s Murder Mystery Game Kit

Gail B.

Everyone loved it. They arrived in character and stayed that way until the end. Our only criticism was that we could have done with another round of questioning before the conclusion. One other observation for those yet to play - take your time over the ‘rumours’ section. That said we loved it!

1920s Murder Mystery Game Kit

Customer photo review of Replay-able 1920s Murder Mystery Dinner Party Game for Up to 20 Adults - Host Your Own Dinner Party Game Night - 1920s Speakeasy Gatsby Theme - 1920s Fancy Dress Dinner Party(V2)

April W.

This was the most fun we've had in a while! We hosted the 1920's murder mystery and had all 20 characters filled. Everyone played their roles and had a blast! We're all looking for to doing another one!

Replay-able 1920s Murder Mystery Dinner Party Game for Up to 20 Adults - Host Your Own Dinner Party Game Night - 1920s Speakeasy Gatsby Theme - 1920s Fancy Dress Dinner Party(V2)

Customer photo review of Wild West Cowboy Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit

Georgia A.

This was so much fun!! We got western decor from Zurchers and everyone brought root beer and finger food. Your kits are definitely our favorite because they are so easy to use and everyone can play even the host!

Wild West Cowboy Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit

Customer photo review of Wizarding Murder Mystery Game Kit

Kerri H.

We had such a fun time with this game! This was my third annual murder mystery party with this company, and we went all out with the Harry Potter decorations (I mean…. Harriet Putter…). Everyone had fun dressing up, and we loved the scripts and details in the game. Definitely recommend

Wizarding Murder Mystery Game Kit

Karen L.

I liked the addition of the letter for the who domeit, and the rumors allowed us to spread rumors during dinner after doing the character intros. Great ice breaker for people who didn't know each other.

Wild West Cowboy Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit

Customer photo review of Halloween Murder Mystery Game Kit - Vampire Ball

Bethan B.

We had such a great night with this game! Everyone loved the characters and really got into it. Slightly confusing with the section where you spread gossip as it’s mean to be behind peoples back but it’s written like you’re saying it to their faces but we worked it out. Definitely recommend for a fun evening and can be played again as it’s always different outcomes!

Halloween Murder Mystery Game Kit - Vampire Ball

Wendy E.

So much fun! I hosted the 1920s mystery with a group of girlfriends (5 of us total), & we had a blast. The digital kit had everything we needed for the mystery, & the instructions were easy to follow. My friends went "all in" with their costumes & characters, & I decked the house out in gold & black, & we had a ton of laughs all evening.

1920s Murder Mystery Game Kit

Customer photo review of Masquerade Ball/Carnival Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit

Lori S.

Unfortunately due to the postal strike our costumes didn’t all come. We still had fun and we really liked that the murderer could be a secret and we could all play

Masquerade Ball/Carnival Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit

Close-up of a customer's dining table set for the Monarchy Game, featuring a large floral centerpiece.

Rudy H.

We had a wonderful experience with Masters of Mystery. I hosted it at our home for my daughter’s 17th birthday, and she specifically chose the Royal Family theme because she was already familiar with the company. She invited a group of friends who are mostly thespians, and they really leaned into their roles—everyone had an absolute blast. The setup was very manageable, and I appreciated all the host suggestions, from meal ideas to a Spotify playlist. The recordings from the Marshal of the Real...

Monarchy Game & Royal Family Themed Murder Mystery Game Kit

Customer in a Santa costume with a puppy, reading a script from the Christmas Murder Mystery game.

Lisa H.

5 STARS!!! Our family had a blast doing this murder mystery event! We laughed so hard. The scripts were good and the fact that we (the hosts) didn't know who the killer was made even more fun!!

Christmas Murder Mystery Host Your Own Dinner Party Game Kit

Customer's decorated character guides for the Masquerade Murder Mystery Game, showing various animal characters like a fox and cat.

Marcie D.

Such a fun experience . My daughter wanted a Murder Masquerade for her 16th birthday and this was perfect. This kit made it super easy. We had the BEST time and would def buy another one again.

Masquerade Ball/Carnival Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit

Reviewers in a group photo dressed in Wild West costumes for the murder mystery game.

Sullivan P.

We had a blast with High Noon at Dead Man’s Saloon! The game takes some logistical wrangling and pre-planning, but if your guests are up for costumes and getting into character, it’s probably the funnest party you’ll ever throw!

Replay-able Cowboy Wild West Murder Mystery Dinner Game for Up to 20 Adults - Host Your Own Dinner Party Game Night - Cowboy & Wild West Theme - Cowboy Fancy Dress Dinner PartyV2

Customers in costumes, including a nun and a scientist, play the Wine Tasting Murder Mystery Game.

Deborah L.

It was a girl's weekend dream event with wine/cheese tasting along with heavy appetizers. The game was easy to play - the directions were spot on. Only thing that would make it better was if Inspector Pirot had a little video intro into each round rather than reading it. Was so FUN - would purchase another mystery for a future event! So glad I found it online.

A Wine Tasting Themed Murder Mystery Game Kit

Customer's living room set up with a black curtain backdrop and tables for the murder mystery game.

Jason B.

It was everyone’s first time. This kit was great because there was enough of a script to feel comfortable in playing but also allowed for some improv. It brought two families together with all kinds of laughs, music, food and of course a mystery.

Eurovision & X-Factor Singing Competition Themed Murder Mystery Game Kit

Customer's pirate-themed decorations for their murder mystery game, featuring a net, skull, and ship's wheel.

Mr T.

Really good experience and easy to use. With a bit of help our 12 and 15 yo were able to be full participants! Good story and interactions. I think group of 4 is a bit small, ideally 6-10 but was still enjoyable. I’d definitely consider another one. Only thing is the sheer amount you need to print.. we ran out of ink.. and also think they’re should be a bigger variance between the full packs and the online only. But it was still good value for money,

Pirate Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit

Customer in a red sequin dress and costume posing for the 1920s Murder Mystery Game.

Nancy-ellen M.

This was our 9th annual Murder Mystery/ Holiday party and what I LOVED about this game was the flexibility. Often you have to lock in key characters with which the game won't work and then if people cannot come, you are in a pickle. This game does not have that issue as ANYONE could be the killer and you can easily flex the characters. Thanks for making such a fun and easy to use game!

1920s Murder Mystery Game Kit

Reviewers and their guests in character costumes for a fun James Bond Spy Murder Mystery party.

Chelsea B.

We hosted a murder mystery dinner party and it was so fun! The Masters of Mystery kit made it so easy. Our guests enjoyed their characters. We will definitely purchase another kit soon!

James Bond Spy Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit - Medium / 4 - 20 Players / English

Customer's party setup for the 1920s Murder Mystery Game, showing a body outline and themed decorations.

Holly N.

Everyone had a great time playing this game! It was nice that the host could play the game too. I would buy another one of these games in the future!

1920s Murder Mystery Game Kit

Shelley W.

Such a fun night to bring friends together. Had some last minute panic with the character files and masters of mystery had amazing customer support. Thank you to an awesome team! ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Masquerade Ball/Carnival Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit

Amber R.

This was an awesome experience. We all were able to get into our characters and was a hit for Halloween. The house was fully decorated from top to bottom to completed this experience. We had 12 people in our group and cant wait to try another one!

Halloween Murder Mystery Game Kit - Vampire Ball

April J.

It’s been a hot minute since I’ve done a murder mystery and everybody really got into it, it was a blast! Best part had to be everybody sweet southern drawls…

Wild West Cowboy Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit

Customer photo review of Sherlock Holmes Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit

Melissa V.

It was so much fun! We all can’t wait to do another one. Only suggestion if possible - try to keep the guilty and not guilty on the same page. People figured out the murder because they saw him on the guilty page.

Sherlock Holmes Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit

Customer photo review of Expansion Pack - Host Your Own 1920s Murder Mystery Game Kit

Brooke F.

So much fun! Plan well in advance! Two months of planning in the making but we enjoyed a dinner with 24 guests! Tip: have a bartender and have help serving food - it allowed everyone to stay seated during the game.

Expansion Pack - Host Your Own 1920s Murder Mystery Game Kit

Customer photo review of Circus Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit

Laura C.

Was a great evening! My friends loved it and really got into character! It was easily to play out. The only thing is the detective voice clip is boring and mono tone. It needs more fun and umph adding to it. Like some sound effects, and more emotion into it. But apart from that it was fun.

Circus Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit

Reviewer and friends pose behind a birthday cake during their Masquerade Ball Murder Mystery party.

Krystyna R.

I purchased the game kit for my 27th Birthday, and it was an absolute blast! The kits gave absolutely everything I would need, and it has plenty of flexibility in terms of how you want to set up your particular party. Definitely a fan favorite and will be playing again!

Masquerade Ball/Carnival Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit

Customer's dining table set for the Bake Off Murder Mystery Game, with character booklets and British-themed decorations.

Genevieve S.

I organized this murder mystery party for my birthday and it was so fun! Initially I was a litter nervous to run the game because I had never done anything like this before and wanted to make sure things ran smoothly. The kit allowed me to be 100% confident in how the game would progress allowing me the freedom to get into the gameplay as a participant. The scripts made my guests feel at ease that they didn’t have to make up a character from scratch and allowed them to put a spin on their assi...

Bake Off Themed Murder Mystery Game Kit

Reviewers gathered around a long dinner table playing the 1980s Murder Mystery Game.

Laura R.

We received all 5* reviews even tho 80s food is hardly culinary! Sooooo fun! Had over 50% never do a murder mystery and they were nervous and after said how they can’t wait to do this again! Thx so much! Hilarious screenplay to enact!

1980s Murder Mystery Game Kit

A customer dressed as a reindeer with a red nose and antlers for the Christmas Murder Mystery game.

Kerry S.

9 of us played It was fun and easy to prepare. I printed out each character profile and made booklets for each of them. I messed up a little by not differentiating between the 6 and 9 when drawing numbers to see who the killer was, but we got through it alright. We'll definitely be playing again.

Christmas Murder Mystery Host Your Own Dinner Party Game Kit

Two customers in fun circus costumes, one with a fake beard and the other with a mustache, playing the murder mystery game.

Sarah C.

We had a brilliant time playing this game on New Years Eve with our fabulous friends. The game was so much fun and straight forward to follow and brought us many giggles. We failed on getting the murderer right but had the best time acting it all out!

Circus Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit

A group of reviewers in festive Christmas costumes posing for a photo while playing the murder mystery game.

Beverley T.

We played A Christmas Mash Up on Christmas Eve and loved it. It was easy to follow, great fun, and had everyone laughing and getting involved. A perfect festive game and a really memorable way to spend the evening — we’d definitely play another Masters of Mystery game.

Expansion Pack - Host Your Own Christmas Murder Mystery Game Kit

Reviewers in formal dresses posing with a poster and large dice for their Spy Murder Mystery Game party.

Emma B.

We really enjoyed this murder mystery and hosted it for NYE! Instructions were super easy to follow and character guides were great fun. I loved that that host could also play along and great that no one knew the murderer until the very end. Highly recommended!!

James Bond Spy Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit

Reviewer in an office examines papers from the Unsolved Cold Case Files Game, with the evidence folders displayed.

Missy R.

Too cold to walk around our courtyard at work, so we killed a little downtime solving a murder. The most interesting day at work in a long time! GREAT BONDING WITH MY TEAMMATES!

Unsolved Cold Case Files Game - Edward Munst Unsolved Murder Mystery - Perfect Date Night Game - Phys

Customers in 1920s flapper and detective costumes having fun playing the Murder Mystery Game.

Ebbie D.

It was a blast! We had a dinner party and then played the game.. everyone dressed up and played their parts so well! It was fun and easy to play along!

1920s Murder Mystery Game Kit

Reviewer and guests in cowboy costumes posing outside a building for the Wild West murder mystery game.

Sage Z.

We had so much fun transforming the big room in a saloon! Everyone dressed to their character and the moment was seized! I didn’t want to disturb the flow of the game so I printed out the sheriff script and did a hat (and added a mustache) change behind the bar to read the sheriff dialogues. Printed out the “evidence” and glued them onto some cardboard to pass around to the guests when appropriate. Game dialogues were fun, the more we played (and us hams in the group fed the energy) the more eve...

Wild West Cowboy Murder Mystery Host Your Own Game Kit

Johannah T.

I purchased this game for a surprise 30th bday party for my husband. We had 20 ppl playing and it was a blast! Ppl are still talking about it weeks later, saying it was one of the best parties they’ve ever been to. We are planning to play it again in the near future!

1920s Murder Mystery Game Kit

Reviewers dressed as the characters Maxy and Cindy Lou Woo for the Christmas Murder Mystery game, posing by a tree.

Kristin W.

We have a Murder Mystery night on Boxing Day (December 26th) every year. Christmas Murder was our 2nd Masters of Mystery purchase and it did not disappoint!! We had so much fun, and the game was so easily followed with the scripts and video supplements. Customer service was EXCEPTIONAL, as I had a last minute situation and received not only an immediate email response (on a weekend) but a quick resolution to my problem! Having hosted many Murder Mystery Nights, I most definitely recommend order...

Christmas Murder Mystery Host Your Own Dinner Party Game Kit

Leonie M.

Es hat super Spaß gemacht! Alle waren begeistert und sind richtig in ihre Rolle reingeschlüpft. Ich habe mir auch Mühe bei der Deko gegeben, damit man mehr in die Stimmung kommt🥰. Ich konnte auch endlich all meine Freunde einladen, da dieses Mystery Dinner für bis zu 20 personen ist!! Fand es auch sehr cool, dass es ein Halloween Theme gab, es hat einfach perfekt gepasst. Die Audios mit dem Inspektor, haben es auch nochmal geheimnisvoller fühlen lassen. Was ich auch toll finde ist, dass der Mörd...

Halloween Murder Mystery Game Kit - Vampire Ball

A large group of children posing in various historical costumes for the Kids Murder Mystery Game Kit.

Nadia M.

After hosting several murder mysteries (that our children really couldn't participate in) we were SO excited to find one for our girls! Our three oldest (12, 11 and 8) and eleven of their friends embraced their characters, researched, learned a lot about history and laughed a half day away playing Mystery at the Museum. This one played a tad bit differently than some of the adult games, so I was glad I read through most of it to begin with to really familiarize. I read the inspector scripts m...

Kids Murder Mystery Game Kit - Mystery At The Museum

Masters of Mystery ReviewsVisit store