This is a very nice shoe, and a great option for people looking for a zero-drop dress shoe with an open toe box - which is hard to find.
I only went with 4-stars because of a minor cosmetic issue. There is some a little rippling effect where it bends at the forefoot and toes, which is to be expected. However, I put the shoes in shoe trees once I took them off at the end of the day. That seems to take care of the issue.