Adam W.Verified
The flavor and texture of these is so incredible. How you’ve made a healthy snack that tastes great to fuel those long days is amazing. These will always be in our tournament bag!
Cael's Cookie ReviewsSee store reviews
Cael’s Cookie™ — Chocolate Chip
Kyle H.Verified
I like the taste and that they're chewy (not hard). Knowing that they're helping get protein and not too heavy on the sugar is another huge plus. 10/10 would recommend.
Cael’s Cookie™ — Chocolate Chip
Rachel B.Verified
My husband is on a journey to be more mindful of his diet. He’s lost 50 lbs and was looking for a beneficial snack. Protein and a little sweetness..win,win!
Cael’s Cookie™ — Chocolate Chip
Scott P.Verified
Excellent taste and texture with just the right amount chocolate. It is easy to see why his athletes like this cookie, as it is calorie dense with a great balance of nutrients. I am so glad I gave them a try.
Cael’s Cookie™ — Chocolate Chip
Tommy T.Verified
I bought the cookies for my daughter who is a youth wrestler. She loved it from the very first bite. Must say the packaging was great and cookie wrapper presentation looks great. It's a different chocolate chip cookie with a different experience from what I'm use to. But in comparison to the rest in the market, Cael's Cookie is much better and a healthier choice. Cookie size and chip size are on point and like the softness and thickness of the sized cookie. I would definite purchase agai...
Cael’s Cookie™ — Chocolate Chip
Charles B.Verified
Love the cookie with my morning coffee as the only time I really eat sweets is with coffee. Not being a big sweet eater, in my opinion I think the cookie could be even better with a little less chocolate chips. I assume it would reduce the number of calories as well. Again, just my opinion as not a significant sweet eater (haven’t eaten candy in many years). That said, best high protein cookie on the market!!!
Cael’s Cookie™ — Chocolate Chip
Jamesine S.Verified
The cookies are fantastic, even better than I expected. Healthy, nutritious remakes of sweet treats can often equal dry, tasteless versions of the original. Not these cookies - they are moist and delicious! Same goes for the chocolate chip cookies. Thank you, Cael, for creating a product I enjoy and don’t feel guilty about eating!
Cael’s Cookie™ — White Chocolate Macadamia Nut
Roni F.Verified
The cookies are so good! I wasn't sure what to expect for a protein cookie but I'm very happy with the taste. I should have known it has come from Cael Sanderson! I will be ordering again!
Cael’s Cookie™ — Chocolate Chip
Kyle H.Verified
I like the taste and that they're chewy (not hard). Knowing that they're helping get protein and not too heavy on the sugar is another huge plus. 10/10 would recommend.
Cael’s Cookie™ — White Chocolate Macadamia Nut
Thomas V.Verified
Got one box to test it out and see if I like it. Turns out it’s delicious but more importantly has high quality ingredients I can read. Solid for a boost/ pick me up.
Cael’s Cookie™ — Chocolate Chip
Darin J.Verified
Bought two boxes. My two college age daughters tried them before I got home and said they were delicious. They each took a box back to college following spring break, so I had to buy two more boxes to replace.
Cael’s Cookie™ — Chocolate Chip
Cooper C.Verified
There was a problem with shipping on my initial order. Customer service was excellent and resolved the problem quickly. There was no delay in delivery. Cookies were great! T shirt is great! Will order more in the future.
The Classic Tee
Julia D.Verified
We were lucky enough to get a few cases during the first drop and were hooked instantly. This is the perfect after workout snack for anyone looking to refuel and not put crap in their body! As someone who has worked with professional athletes and continues to be involved in the sport of wrestling, I can’t recommend a more perfect snack for athletes of all ages!
Cael’s Cookie™ — Chocolate Chip
Kade S.Verified
These things are unreal! They just feel like everything I need, plus everything I didn’t know I needed in a performance snack. Fills you up, energizes, feels clean, and TASTES GOOD.
Cael’s Cookie™ — Chocolate Chip
Nancy P.Verified
Gave a box of each flavor as gifts to two distance runners in my life and they are raving about them! Will buy again! One suggestion is what we think is an unintentional typo in the packaging - the spelling of protein.
Cael’s Cookie™ — White Chocolate Macadamia Nut
Gary O.Verified
Each cookie is packaged in its own paper and received in a sturdy box. The cookies are very good taste wise and dense with all the protein inside. I was pleasantly surprised by the great taste.
Cael’s Cookie™ — Chocolate Chip
Aaron L.Verified
Good cookie, it would be nice if it was more affordable! Shipping is way too much for what you get! $1.20 for each cookie is a little ridiculous. $5.34 each is a lot for a young kid to have to come up with. Thank you for the cookie.Aaron
Cael’s Cookie™ — Chocolate Chip
Richard B.Verified
The shipment arrived promptly. I've ate one cookie before a work out, I like the taste and didn't get the "hungries" during my work out. Real reason I wanted to try them is I am going back country hiking soon and I wanted to see how they would work as a trail snack. They will get put to the full test next week.
Cael’s Cookie™ — Chocolate Chip
Michael T.Verified
These cookies are like very tasty meals! Didn't figure they'd be called Cael's Cookies unless they were fantastic-like the perennial National Champion Penn State Wrestling Team for which he serves as Head Coach-having won 13 of the last 15 NATIONAL CHAMPIONSHIPS in NCAA College Wrestling: (let that sink in-for real).
Astonishing performance-THE dynasty of all dynasties in team sport. These cookies: they represent quite well. "Bravo! Bravissimo!"
Cael’s Cookie™ — Chocolate Chip
Raelynne P.Verified
5 stars all the way. My wrestler is hooked, and honestly so am I. As a parent of an athlete, I love having a healthier option that actually tastes good. Definitely looking forward to new flavors.
Cael’s Cookie™ — Chocolate Chip
Michelle D.Verified
The cookies arrived on time and in a sturdy box. Each cookie was individually packaged and intact.
They are tasty and a great treat to enjoy during the NCAA tournament.
Cael’s Cookie™ — Chocolate Chip
Ronald L.Verified
The cookies are for my son who is playing club baseball at PSU. Loved them so much i just had 2 more boxes sent his way. Congrats to PSU Wrestling, #1 on and off the mats!
Cael’s Cookie™ — Chocolate Chip
Ryan R.Verified
Seriously good cookies- I’ve been looking for something I can throw in a bag (for myself or the kids) that’s not loaded with artificial sweeteners. That’s the differentiator for me. Also don’t feel loaded down after. Superior product. Wish it was a little more affordable, but happy to pay a little more considering there is nothing like it on the market.
Cael’s Cookie™ — Chocolate Chip
Eric N.Verified
The order was shipped very fast and packaging was good. The cookie tasted great. It had a lot of chocolate chips and is a very big and filling cookie. I definitely recommend these cookies to everyone trying to eat healthy, and still looking for a great tasting cookie.
Cael’s Cookie™ — Chocolate Chip
Jeffrey S.Verified
I really love Cael's cookies. Lethal combo of healthy and delicious. Rare do I find a chocolate chip cookie that I want my kids to eat but here we are. They love them too.
Cael’s Cookie™ — Chocolate Chip
Jennifer C.Verified
The cookies were a gift for a family who loves PSU wrestling! They were attending the Big10 championships so I wanted to give them a treat to take with them. I missed getting them in time, but they enjoyed them afterward! Said they were very good!
Cael’s Cookie™ — Chocolate Chip
Ryan A.Verified
Not only do the cookies taste amazing, the customer service is also stellar. My first package was lost by UPS. When I called to try to see if the Cael’s Cookies staff would be willing to help, they simply sent me another box and said hopefully I also get my original box that was lost. It wasn’t their error, but they owned it and took care of it without hassle or expectation on my part.
Cael’s Cookie™ — Chocolate Chip
Christopher C.Verified
They taste great and are very filling. We’re giving a few boxes to the coaches and staff at our local wrestling clubs as thanks for their efforts this season. Personally I am using them in small pieces to reduce my reliance on after meal sweets and snacks which are less healthy than Cael’s Cookie.
Cael’s Cookie™ — Chocolate Chip
Casey A.Verified
I ordered 2 boxes and gave away one of the boxes to coworkers. They enjoyed the cookie and have now become customers. Great job and thank you for making a delicious treat without all the junk.
Cael’s Cookie™ — Chocolate Chip
Daniel C.Verified
I was pleasantly surprised with the cookie and the ingredients. Its about as clean as you can get for an off the shelf cookie that still tastes like a cookie. Glad I found these. Thanks!
Cael’s Cookie™ — White Chocolate Macadamia Nut
Michael E.Verified
The order process was fantastic. You kept in contact every step of the way.
I've been eating a serving or two during big tens. I'd like to think that it was lucky for the nittany lions.
Thank you all.
Cael’s Cookie™ — Chocolate Chip
Thomas W.
I sure hope you get your baking machines cranking out a whole lot of cookies, soon! I have run out of my original order and can’t wait for the new flavor. I just hope it’s not oatmeal raisin. I can’t stand raisins.
Cael’s Cookie™ — Chocolate Chip
Jeff M.Verified
I am not a D1 wrestler. I'm a 50+ YO Dad with a 9 to 5 job like most. Caels Cookie is the right size for a healthy afternoon snack.I recommend trying Caels Cookie!
Cael’s Cookie™ — Chocolate Chip
Jeff M.Verified
A treat for the taste buds. Better for your body than other sugary snacks. At work, around 2 o'clock each day, I need a pick me up. Caels Cookie does the trick me. Highly recommend Caels Cookie!
Cael’s Cookie™ — Chocolate Chip
John B.Verified
My son is on a weight lifting program at his High School, and they really are watching what they eat. Nice to have a snack that delivers what they need without all the sugars and fat. Plus we are huge wrestling fans!! National Champs Again!!
Cael’s Cookie™ — Chocolate Chip
Ryan S.Verified
Taste Amazing!!!
Cael’s Cookie™ — Chocolate Chip
Emmett C.Verified
Cookies were soft and amazing! Taste so good!
Cael’s Cookie™ — Chocolate Chip
Jason H.Verified
What an absolutely phenomenal cookie!
Cael’s Cookie™ — Chocolate Chip
Rodney D.Verified
The cookie was a very satisfying pick me up. It also tastes great.
Cael’s Cookie™ — Chocolate Chip
+1Holly C.Verified
Amazing Cookies!! 🍪
Cael’s Cookie™ — Chocolate Chip
Cael's Cookie ReviewsVisit store