These period liners are soft, but quite wrinkly and noisy. They "rustle". I found after washing that they didn't lie flat, and were very bunch when wearing them. There is quite a knack to pull pants up and keep them from folding as there is only the domed wing to fix them to your pants. Not a good option if you move around a lot, or if wearing skinny jeans (due to the moving lumps the pad forms).