We really love this St. Nicholas doll! I bought it for my infant as a St. Nicholas Day gift to keep her occupied at Mass and so far it’s worked really well - it being quiet and soft makes it a perfect toy for her to engage with, and many bonus points for being church appropriate.
The only thing I would consider if giving this as a gift to another infant is that the doll is quite round and fully stuffed, which can make it difficult for little (and uncoordinated) hands to grab. It’s not a problem...